A rebel territory behind the tourist scene: Negotiating national belonging and indigeneity in Quintana Roo (original) (raw)
Related papers
In the Name of El Pueblo: Place, Community and the Politics of History in Yucatán
2010
The term "el pueblo" is used throughout Latin America, referring alternately to small towns, to community, or to "the people" as a political entity. In this vivid anthropological and historical analysis of Mexico's Yucatán peninsula, Paul K. Eiss explores the multiple meanings of el pueblo and the power of the concept to unite the diverse claims made in its name. Eiss focuses on working-class indigenous and mestizo populations, examining how those groups negotiated the meaning of el pueblo among themselves and in their interactions with outsiders, including landowners, activists, and government officials. Combining extensive archival and ethnographic research, he describes how residents of the region have laid claim to el pueblo in varied ways, as exemplified in communal narratives recorded in archival documents, in the performance of plays and religious processions, and in struggles over land, politics, and the built environment. Eiss demonstrates that while el pueblo is used throughout the hemisphere, the term is given meaning and power through the ways it is imagined and constructed in local contexts. Moreover, he reveals el pueblo to be a concept that is as historical as it is political. It is in the name of el pueblo--rather than class, race, or nation--that inhabitants of northwestern Yucatán stake their deepest claims not only to social or political rights, but over history itself.
In the following article I aim at bridging some of the sources that have critically addressed the invention of Quintana Roo in the regional historiography with the need of rethinking its contemporary relation to time after the takeoff of tourism in the 1970s. I contend that by means of thoroughly reinterpreting the politics of the vacuum and the historiographical particularities of Quintana Roo, we will be able to find some clues for understanding the need to rewrite history in a shorter scope, as a way of taking a fresh look at pending issues concerning new myth-making and ethnic memory processes and their relation to broader narratives such as the regional historical time and the overheated Mexican nationalism.
2018
The Caste War of Yucatán (1847-1901) is widely regarded a "successful" revitalization movement in the Americas. Construction of historical memories that emerged from the golden age of peasant studies in anthropology highlight redress of colonialism's socioeconomic disparities, the birth of a new religion, and return to traditional lifeways, which recall the glories of the prehispanic era. But what is the basis of these interpretations? Were the entangled social, economic, political, and religious asymmetries of the colonial era truly swept away? In this paper, I examine written and archaeological evidence of the Caste War's aftermath in the area between Chichén Itzá and Valladolid, Yucatán. I compare how shifts in demography, migration, and socioeconomic inequality inscribed the landscape from the first decades after independence through the early twentieth century. My results indicate that social memories of the worsening disparities of the postcolonial era were reproduced and appropriated during post-revolutionary agrarian reform.
Politics of Post-War Tourism in Guatemala: Contested Identities, Histories, and Futures
Revue en ligne de géographie politique et de géopolitique, 2016
The Guatemalan tourism industry is a contested terrain of post-war politics where state officials, indigenous Maya, and ex-guerilla brigades compete to define post-war national identity, historical memory, and future possibilities. I use the analytic of territory to show how the state and civil society groups use tourism development to pursue unexpected political ends. First, I track changes in state marketing practices to suggest the Guatemalan government has used tourism to redefine post-war national identity and the place of Maya within the nation. I then turn to the Maya village of San Juan la Laguna to examine how the Maya Tz’utujil reassert their Tz’utujil identity and claims to San Juan as Tz’utujil space through community tourism. Lastly, I explore how ex-guerillas practice solidarity tourism to carve out alternative spaces of life and livelihood through cooperative living. This paper comparatively examines the territorial practices of state tourism, indigenous and ex-guerilla tourism to illustrate the tourism industry’s political stakes and possibilities in Guatemala.