Development and Distortion of Malaysian Public- Private Partnerships: Patronage, Privatised Profits and Pitfalls DOI: 10.1111/j.1467- 8500.2009.00655.x (original) (raw)
Related papers
Australian Journal of Public Administration, 2010
This article examines the politicisation of systemic patronage and privatised profits in the development of Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) in Malaysia. Issues associated with inadequate regulatory frameworks, control, accountability and poorly managed risks, demonstrate that much more effective reforms are required to reduce further pitfalls, to protect public interests and to uphold the integrity of the public service and government. The adoption of a transparent procurement and evaluation system will be a challenging task if public and investor confidence is to be built up and strategic partnerships in the complex web of governance and administrative relationships in the governance of PPPs are to be developed effectively. Finally directions of reform and lessons learnt are suggested.
A review of public private partnership procurement practice in Malaysia
International Journal of Technological Learning, Innovation and Development, 2016
The citizens of most developing countries are looking forward to their respective governments for significant improvements in the social and economic infrastructures. Those governments are being faced with inadequate budgeting to address these needs while they see public private partnership procurement system as an opportunity to address those challenges. Despite that some developing countries have recorded little progress in the delivery of public projects under PPP arrangements, some other countries have successfully utilised the opportunities being provided by this procurement method. The aim of this study is to review the implementation of PPP projects in Malaysia so that the experience gained could be used to address the challenges of PPP procurement method in the developing countries. The study showed that the Government of Malaysia had progressively utilised PPP method to deliver infrastructure and services, and also contributed to the growth of her economy. It is recommended that the governments in developing countries should create conducive environment for PPP arrangement to succeed through people oriented policies.
Constraints to incorporate competition in public-private partnerships in Malaysia
International Journal of Procurement Management, 2022
Competition in procurement not only benefits government and taxpayers but also provides an equal market for the private sector. Competitive procurement stimulates market creativity, as it discourages anti-competitive behaviour. Despite the complexity of the PPP procurement process, the world is now promoting competition within it, an element yet to be fully implemented in Malaysia. This paper analyses the constraints that Malaysia faces in effectively maintaining PPP competition. Within the case study research strategy, semi-structured interviews and content analysis were used as data collection and analysing methods. The study found that in its efforts to make the PPP program a success, the Malaysian PPP has followed flexible implementation, with less emphasis on competition. The effect of focusing only on PPP's macro aim has resulted in a lack of competition in practice. The current challenge is to strike a balance between achieving aims and maintaining governance and therefore getting the best out of PPP in Malaysia.
Malaysian experience with public-private partnership (PPP)
Built Environment Project and Asset Management, 2016
Purpose Lack of competition in procurement processes may affect the sustainable procurement due to overpriced and low-quality infrastructure. The purpose of this paper is to investigate the current practices in Malaysian public-private partnership (PPP) in handling unsolicited proposals within PPP and to suggest ways in which the practices can be improved to achieve sustainability. Design/methodology/approach Case study was conducted within which 13 semi-structured interviews were carried out with different groups: the policy makers, the practitioners and the experts. The study also scrutinised published guidelines and relevant regulations used by in management of unsolicited proposals in Malaysian PPP. Findings The Government of Malaysia welcomes unsolicited proposals from the private sector, even though it does not publish any established mechanisms to handle such proposals. Lack of competition in unsolicited proposals is a major concern in achieving sustainable goals of procureme...
IIUM Law Journal
In order to ensure a sustained cooperation with both the local and international private investors in Malaysia especially in the provision of public infrastructure, the government needs to develop very strong legal and regulatory capabilities which will help in providing stable institutional environment for private investment. At the same time, there is the need for commitment on the part of government to the regulatory rules so that they are perceived as credible by investors. Where the legal regime is weak or non-existent, private investment decisions will be adversely affected. No doubt, South Africa has developed one of the best legal and regulatory regimes for efficient procurement systems in the world and the project pipelines have greatly increased in recent times. This article therefore, examines the existing legal framework for Public-Private Partnership procurement in Malaysia and draws lessons from the South African legal regime. The article finally argues that for Malays...
International Journal of Supply Chain Management, 2017
Public Private Partnership (PPP) in Malaysia as an innovative procurement mechanism aims to undertake the public sector infrastructure project construction in order to overcome the weaknesses of conventional system. PPP is seen significantly viable to enhance the quality of public services and stimulate economic growth. After the decades of its implementation, many arguments have been reported along the lively growth of PPP project development. Within that context, this study provides a review of issues and challenges for PPP pertaining to project performance in Malaysia. The objective of this study is to highlight the loophole of PPP implementation in Malaysia through a qualitative approach. A qualitative approach was used to analyse contextual literature review and to investigate four selected performance measurement models as the precedent study to provide a basis for improvement of PPP in Malaysia. The findings showed that the issues and challenges were almost similar between th...
International Journal of Construction Management, 2011
There are few Public Private Partnership (PPP) projects in the UAE, but the number is increasing. Recently government and public bodies have increased their interest in PPP to encourage more involvement of the private sector in the country development. The aim of the research is to evaluate the UAE experience in using PPP projects focusing on the critical success and failure factors for PPP in the UAE. Three case studies were examined to identify the critical success factors and the failure factors. The results have shown that political support is the most important success factor followed by having a strong private consortium. The most important factor that causes PPP projects to fail in this context is when the consortium lacks the appropriate knowledge and skills. Hence, private consortia need to ensure that they assemble the relevant skills and knowledge of how to set up and manage a PPP as well as the crucial knowledge pertaining to the local business environment and political drivers.
Malaysian Public Private Partnership
Academy of Accounting and Financial Studies Journal, 2018
The Malaysian government employs Public Private Partnership (PPP) as a tool for the development of infrastructure. The literature postulates different aspects of Malaysian PPP projects however there is a dearth of the robust description of the process for Malaysian PPP projects. Therefore, this study aims to describe the process of Malaysian PPP projects. To achieve the objective, the phenomenological research method is adopted and interviews are conducted with PPP practitioners in Malaysia. The findings of interviews explain the five phases of Malaysian PPP projects. Furthermore, the detailed design concept and clear agreement play vital role in PPP projects. The findings may help the research in the better understanding of PPP.
Transparency and Good Governance as Success Factors in Public Private Partnerships
Transport Infrastructure and Systems – Dell’Acqua & Wegman (Eds). 2017. Taylor and Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-1-138-03009-1, p. 261-266., 2017
Many governments do not have all the financial resources required to meet their country’s infrastructure needs. Facing limited resources and searching for more efficient and effective delivery of their infrastructure, many countries have involved the private sector under long term public-private partnership (PPP) contractual arrangements. Typically, PPPs involve a private sector company or consortium (the ‘concessionaire’) contracting with government to finance, build, operate, and then transfer the asset back to the public sector at the end of a concession. On the premise that good governance can lead to more successful PPPs, this paper reviews some key requirements for good governance in such projects, including competitive selection of the concessionaire, public disclosure of relevant information, and regulatory oversight of the concession contract. Because PPPs in infrastructure tend to have monopolistic features, good governance in managing them is essential to ensure that the private sector’s involvement yields the optimum benefit for society.
Critical success factors of public private partnership (PPP) implementation in Malaysia
Asia-Pacific Journal of Business Administration, 2013
PurposeThis paper aims to examine the importance of the success factors as perceived by the overall respondents. Also, the study intends to identify the differences concerning the importance of the success factors between the public and private sectors.Design/methodology/approachA questionnaire survey was used to elicit the perceptions of public and private sectors on the key success factors of a PPP project in Malaysia. In total, 179 usable responses were obtained and analysed using SPSS to rank the importance of the success factors and to examine the differences in the perceptions between the government and the private sector.FindingsThe overall results show that “good governance”, “commitment of the public and private sectors”, “favourable legal framework”, “sound economic policy” and “availability of finance market” are the top five success factors of PPP implementation in Malaysia. Although the rankings of many factors were different between the public and private sectors, ther...