A note on limitations of standard thermodynamics (original) (raw)
Related papers
On the Connections between Thermodynamics and General Relativity
In this thesis, the connections between thermodynamics and general relativity are explored. We introduce some of the history of the interaction between these two theories and take some time to individually study important concepts of both of them. Then, we move on to explore the concept of gravitationally induced temperature gradients in equilibrium states, first introduced by Richard Tolman. We explore these Tolman-like temperature gradients, understanding their physical origin and whether they can be generated by other forces or not. We then generalize this concept for fluids following generic four-velocities, which are not necessarily generated by Killing vectors, in general stationary space-times. Some examples are given. Driven by the interest of understanding and possibly extending the concept of equilibrium for fluids following trajectories which are not generated by Killing vectors, we dedicate ourselves to a more fundamental question: can we still define thermal equilibriu...
General Relativity and Gravitation, 1989
A new type of cosmological history which includes large-scale entropy production is proposed. These cosmologies are based on a reinterpretation of the matter-energy stress tensor in Einstein's equations. This modifies the usual adiabatic energy conservation laws, thereby leading to a possible irreversible matter creation. This creation corresponds to an irreversible energy flow from the gravitational field to the created matter constituents. This new point of view results from the consideration of thermodynamics of open systems in the framework of cosmology. It appears that the usual initial singularity is structurally unstable with respect to irreversible matter creation. The corresponding cosmological history therefore starts from an instability of the vacuum rather than from a singularity. The universe evolves through an inflationary phase. This appears to be an attractor independent of the initial vacuum fluctuation.
Electronic Journal of Theoretical Physics Thermodynamical Model of the Universe
2014
Abstract: We inquire in to the physics of a self gravitating medium in quasi-static equilibrium, using the phenomenological approach of thermodynamics. Gravitational galaxy clustering is statistical and its origin is dynamical one. Hence the aspects of clustering must be understood in order to arrive at a proper appreciation of the subject of the formation and evolution of the large scale structure of the universe. Long range gravitational forces modify the thermodynamic functions and equations of state. The thermodynamical model is discussed at many levels. First we discuss the importance of thermodynamics as applicable to the gravitational clustering problem and extend our remarks to study various thermodynamic functions like free energy, entropy, pressure, internal energy and others. The various results that we discuss have interested implications for the study of large scale structure in the universe.They support the view that an easy and simple approach can be made an alternati...
13. The Field View on Thermodynamics
When one reads textbooks on the thermodynamics the first time, one feels like reading a scientific paper written in the 18th century. Bulky description of the initial ideas, absence of clear distinction between concepts of heat, temperature and internal energy of the very difference between the system and its exterior - all these features essentially hinder understanding until realization comes that this is just a collection of experimental facts, a block of clay not reduced to the form of plates and dishes necessary for the housewife. Electrodynamics Maxwell’s ideas were much luckier than his thermodynamic ones. Electrodynamics quickly became an accu-rate science and yielded plentiful fruits. Why did this not happen with thermodynamics, even though the gauge of the scientists who devoted their life to thermodynamics is not less? Certainly there are many causes for this, and they are differ-ent. Let us make a supposition concerning cognition side of the problem. In electrodynamics, the electron was detected rather quickly. The concept of current was introduced as charged flow, and this became a powerful incite to the theory development and at-tached clear physical meaning to the concept of field. Until recently the concept of thermodynamic charge was not introduced; instead, the not very transparent idea of a particle was introduced, and instead of an inductively constructed image of a field, they speak about an ensemble of particles that is amalgamated into a “system” that interacts with its “compliment” – the rest of the universe. We are to admit that stochastic description of the ensemble not only did not make more transparent the problem, but even hindered understanding of the problem’s essence. In quantum mechanics, it has led us into blind alley in understanding. Thus the slogan: “I believe because this is absurd” has become the oath of loyalty in modern mainstream physics. The second cause of modern thermodynamics’ problem is apparently reluctance to recognize the fundamental character of Brownian particle movement. See, the fact that Brownian particle movement time is proportional not to the covered path, but its square, immediately differentiates this movement from the concepts of traditional mechanics. Physical analyses of the problem were changed with probabilistic description and purely groundless exchanging of mean for dispersion. But if we can prescribe quite understandable meaning to the word ‘mean’ then what physical meaning can be given to the word ‘dispersion’, which characterizes deviation from the mean? The aim of this article is to formulate field concept in the thermodynamics. Mechanical dimensions for concepts of heat and temperature are introduced, particle’s spin is considered as the charge of the thermodynamic field. The main thermodynamic assertions are paraphrased in these terms.
Classical Thermodynamics as a Consequence of Spacetime Geometry
2015
Abstract: Just as Maxwell’s magnetic equations emerge entirely from dd = 0 of exterior calculus applied to a gauge potential A, so too does the second law of thermodynamics emerge from applying dd=0 to a scalar potential s. If we represent this as dds = dU = 0, then when the Gauss / Stokes theorem is used to obtain the integral formulation of this equation, and after breaking a time loop that appears in the integral equation, we find that U behaves precisely like the internal energy state variable, and that the second law of thermodynamics for irreversible processes
Early universe thermostatistics in curved momentum spaces
Physical review, 2016
The theories known as doubly special relativity are introduced in order to take into account an observer-independent length scale and the speed of light in the framework of special relativity. These theories can be generally formulated on the de Sitter and also recently proposed anti-de Sitter momentum spaces. In the context of these theories, we study the statistical mechanics and to do this, we consider the natural measure on the corresponding extended phase space. The invariant measure on the space of distinct microstates is obtained by restriction of the natural measure of the extended phase space to the physical phase space through the disintegration theorem. Having the invariant measure, one can study the statistical mechanics in an arbitrary ensemble for any doubly special relativity theory. We use the constructed setup to study the statistical properties of four doubly special relativity models. Applying the results to the case of early universe thermodynamics, we show that one of these models that is defined by the cosmological coordinatization of anti-de Sitter momentum space, implies a finite total number of microstates. Therefore, without attribution to any ensemble density and quite generally, we obtain entropy and internal energy bounds for the early radiation dominated universe. We find that while these results cannot be supported by the standard Friedmann equations, they indeed are in complete agreement with the nonsingular effective Friedmann equations that arise in the context of loop quantum cosmology.
Thermodynamical Model of the Universe
2012
We inquire in to the physics of a self gravitating medium in quasi-static equilibrium, using the phenomenological approach of thermodynamics. Gravitational galaxy clustering is statistical and its origin is dynamical one. Hence the aspects of clustering must be understood in order to arrive at a proper appreciation of the subject of the formation and evolution of the large scale structure of the universe. Long range gravitational forces modify the thermodynamic functions and equations of state. The thermodynamical model is discussed at many levels. First we discuss the importance of thermodynamics as applicable to the gravitational clustering problem and extend our remarks to study various thermodynamic functions like free energy, entropy, pressure, internal energy and others. The various results that we discuss have interested implications for the study of large scale structure in the universe.They support the view that an easy and simple approach can be made an alternative study w...
The postulates of gravitational thermodynamics
Physical Review D, 1996
The general principles and logical structure of a thermodynamic formalism that incorporates strongly self-gravitating systems are presented. This framework generalizes and simplifies the formulation of thermodynamics developed by Callen. The definition of extensive variables, the homogeneity properties of intensive parameters, and the fundamental problem of gravitational thermodynamics are discussed in detail. In particular, extensive parameters include quasilocal quantities and are naturally incorporated into a set of basic general postulates for thermodynamics. These include additivity of entropies (Massieu functions) and the generalized second law. Fundamental equations are no longer homogeneous first-order functions of their extensive variables. It is shown that the postulates lead to a formal resolution of the fundamental problem despite non-additivity of extensive parameters and thermodynamic potentials. Therefore, all the results of (gravitational) thermodynamics are an outgrowth of these postulates. The origin and nature of the differences with ordinary thermodynamics are analyzed. Consequences of the formalism include the (spatially) inhomogeneous character of thermodynamic equilibrium states, a reformulation of the Euler equation, and the absence of a Gibbs-Duhem relation.
2021
Mini-symposia M3 – Foundation, theories, and philosophy of thermodynamicsInternational audienceThermodynamics proposes very general principles; the question then arises as to its links with the other major fields of physics that are the theory of relativity and quantum mechanics. Is it upstream? Can it be derived from them? Our conviction is that the concepts of physics, including space and time, are a way of naming comparisons between phenomena, within a relational approach. Each field of physics results from a particular perspective on reality, and does not reflect the particular functioning, on its own, of a limited segment of that reality. The question then is not to try to link supposedly achieved mathematical corpuses corresponding to each of these fields, but, by returning to the study of "raw" phenomena, to find, within the different fields, the qualities still hidden and already perceived in the others. In this spirit, we will discuss several concepts (each one is...
Quantum cosmic models and thermodynamics
Classical and Quantum Gravity, 2008
The current accelerating phase of the evolution of the universe is considered by constructing most economical cosmic models that use just general relativity and some dominating quantum effects associated with the probabilistic description of quantum physics. Two of such models are explicitly analyzed. They are based on the existence of a sub-quantum potential and correspond to a generalization of the spatially flat exponential model of de Sitter space. The thermodynamics of these two cosmic solutions is discussed, using the second principle as a guide to choose which among the two is more feasible. The paper also discusses the relativistic physics on which the models are based, their holographic description, some implications from the classical energy conditions, and an interpretation of dark energy in terms of the entangled energy of the universe. PACS numbers: 95.36.+x, 98.80.-k