The Economic Returns to the Knowledge and Use of a Second Official Language: English in Quebec and French in the Rest-of-Canada (original) (raw)
Related papers
With data from the 2006 Canadian census, we investigate the determinants and the economic values of different languages used at work in the Montreal metropolitan area. The working population is divided into three mother tongues groups: French, English and Others. Three indicators are defined: use of French at work as a second language, and use of an official language at work as opposed to an non-official language. One interesting result is that there is no relationship between schooling and the use of French at work for the English mother tongue group, while schooling is positively related to the use of English at work for the French mothe tongue group and to the use of an offical language at work for the Other mother tongues group. We look at the returns to using a second language at work by means of earnings regressions (with both OLS and IV to account for the endogeneity of the language of work). We find that for the English mother tongue group, using French at work does not pay....
The complementarity of language and other human capital: immigrant earnings in Canada
Economics of Education Review, 2003
This paper analyzes the effects of language practice on earnings among adult male immigrants in Canada using the 1991 census. Earnings are shown to increase with schooling, pre-immigration experience and duration in Canada, as well as with proficiency in the official languages (English and French). Using selectivity correction techniques, it is shown that there is complementarity between language skills and
Language in the labor market: The immigrant experience in Canada and the United States
1990
The determinants and labor market consequences for immigrants of proficiency in speaking the dominant language (English in the United States and English of French in Canada) are explored, with focus on adult men using self-reported data from the 1980 and 1981 censuses of the United States and Canada, respectively. It is shown that the determinants of earnings among immigrants are remarkably sinilar in the two countries. Fluency in the dominant language has a large positive effect on earnings, independent of other personal characteristics and country of origin. The study shows the importance of explicitly incorporating dominant language fluency, and the determinants of dominant language fluency, in the criteria for allocating immigrant visas, if immigrant economic success is a policy objective. It also indicates that, because of the questions asked and the coding procedures, the data related to language in the U.S. census are superior to the data from the Canadian census for both statistical and public policy analysis. (Author/LB)
Multilingualism and the Decline of French in Quebec
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2016
Using census data from 2001, 2006 and 2011, we contest the view that the French language is retreating in Quebec. We argue that the apparent decline of French in Quebec is linked to a rise in multilingualism, especially of multilingualism in which French is one of the spoken languages. We find that inter-linguistic marriages, along with a rise in the proportion of individuals whose language at home is different from their language at work, distort statistics considerably. The level of usage of the French language is therefore considerably underestimated and the often discussed downward trend is absent. This yields important implications for policy analysis.
Bilingualism and Communicative Benefits
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2000
We examine patterns of acquiring non-native languages in a model with two languages and two populations with heterogeneous learning skills, where every individual faces a binary choice of learning the foreign language or refraining from doing so. We show that both interior and corner linguistic equilibria can emerge in our framework, and that the fraction of learners of the foreign language is higher in the country with a higher gross cost adjusted communicative benefit. It turns out that this observation is consistent with the data on language proficiency in bilingual countries such as Belgium and Canada. We also point out that linguistic equilibria can exhibit insufficient learning which opens the door for government policies that are beneficial for both populations.
EARNINGS AND LINGUISTIC PROFICIENCY IN A BILINGUAL ECONOMY
Manchester School, 2005
Bilingualism is a widespread phenomenon, yet its economic effects are under researched. Typically studies find that bilingual workers are disadvantaged. Governments often protect minority languages through official promotion of bilingualism, with potential economic consequences. This paper addresses the impact of bilingualism on earnings, using the example of Wales. Results show a positive raw differential of 8 to 10 per cent depending on definition of linguistic proficiency. The use of Welsh in the workplace is not directly productive. Nevertheless language choice and earnings appear to be endogenous. The differential can be entirely explained by a selection effect. This is consistent with the effectiveness of legislation to promote the minority language.
The Complementarity of Language and Other Human Capital
2000
The Complementarity of Language and Other Human Capital: Immigrant Earnings in Canada * This paper analyzes the effects of language practice on earnings among adult male immigrants in Canada using the 1991 Census. Earnings are shown to increase with schooling, pre-immigration experience and duration in Canada, as well as with proficiency in the official languages (English and French). Using selectivity correction techniques, it is shown that there is complementarity between language skills and both schooling and preimmigration experience. That is, greater proficiency in the official languages enhances the effects on earnings of schooling and pre-immigration labor market experience. Language proficiency and post-migration experience appear to be substitutes, that is, those with greater proficiency have a smaller effect of time in Canada on earnings.
The territorial concept of official bilingualism; A cheaper alternative for Canada?
Language Sciences, 1989
Canada's present bilingualism program is presently based on the personality rather than the territorial principle. Belgium and Switzerland have adopted territoriality and a recent task force in New Brunswick has advocated that the province implement partial territoriality. This paper examines the two approaches, applying economic analysis to language planning. Given competition among languages, can government intervention in the language market protect the "weaker" language? Canadian experience suggests a negative response, in that heavy government expenditures have not stopped assimilation. Between the censal years 1971 and 1981 there was continued linguistic concentration; French in Quebec and English in the other provinces. An alternative is territoriality; this has the added bonus of being cheaper.
Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 1997
This paper analyses and compares the Canadian francophone minorities of Ontario and New Brunswick in order to see how well they have done in preserving their identity and in achieving economic success. The analysis is performed with micro data from the 1981 and 1991 Canadian censuses. Demographic trends and language use attributes are first presented, followed by a discussion of some characteristics that are related to social and economic status. The paper continues with a more direct analysis of economic performance, which is done through income comparisons and earnings regressions. The major results are as follows. First, assimilation to English is high and increasing in Ontario, but it is still relatively low in New Brunswick. Second, francophones in both provinces have less of the characteristics that lead to high economic status. There is evidence of improvement in some of the characteristics between 1981 and 1991, perhaps more so in Ontario than in New Brunswick. Third, francophones in Ontario, in spite of their less favourable characteristics compared to anglophones, have done relatively well economically. This is not the case for francophones in New Brunswick, whose incomes are behind those of their anglophone counterparts. Fourth, in both provinces, differences in incomes between anglophones and francophones are lower for women than for men.