Intransigent anti-communism and/or pragmatic diplomacy? Pius XII's Eastern policy between world war and cold war (original) (raw)
In an investigation involving Vatican sources that have recently been opened for research, the paper reassesses the story of the actual or alleged Vatican-Soviet attempts at rapprochement initiated during and after World War II with the aim to explore the considerations that shaped Vatican eastern policy at the end of the war. On the basis of a closer examination of the Orlemanski mission in the spring of 1944, the Flynn mission in March 1945, and the negotiations initiated in 1946 through Hungarian Jesuits it argues that despite Moscow’s brief apparent display of willingness to cooperate at the end of the war, the failure of actual attempts at rapprochement was primarily due to the Kremlin’s lack of interest. By contrast, the Vatican was truly open to dialogue, given the right conditions. Consequently, Pius XII’s Eastern policy is to be interpreted through the paradigm not of intransigence but traditional Vatican concordat policy. The term Ostpolitik, however, unless used with some distinguishing qualification, seems inappropriate to Pius XII’s stance on Eastern policy. Despite the similarities with the Vatican Ostpolitik of the 1960s, a close comparison shows up several basic differences.
Related papers
2022
One of the open questions in the historiography of the Vatican-Kremlin relations after World War II, is whether bilateral dialogue and reaching an agreement was prevented by the caution and anti-communist priciples of Pope Pius XII, or rather by the aloofness of the Soviet Union. Based on the newly opened Vatican sources, the paper examines the mission of Edward J. Flynn, an American Democrat politician, who in February-March of 1945 attempted to mediate between the two parties. After a brief review of the assessment of the Flynn mission in scolarly literature, the paper first outlines the course of events, then evaluates the goals and perspectives of the actors involved. It concludes that it was the lack of interest shown by Moscow that led tot he failure of the first postwar Vatican-Soviet approaches while the Holy See was open to dialogue. Pius the XII’s eastern policy is therefore to be interpreted not in terms of intrasigence buth rather within the paradigm of the traditional Vatican concordat policy. Nonetheless, by contrast with the later „classic”, „active” Vatikan Ospolitik under Popes John XXIII and Paul VI, Pius XII pursued what might at most be termed a „passive” Ostpolitik.
Czechoslovak-Vatican Diplomatic Relations on the Eve of World War II
Central Europe , 2020
The study dealswith the attitude of the Vatican towards the situation in Czechoslovakia in 1938–1939, within the context of international events on the eve of the Second World War. It describes and analyzes Czechoslovak-Vatican diplomatic relations, which underwent a rapid transformation in the second half of the 1930s. The Holy See had deep concerns about the escalating tension betweenGermans and Czechs in Czechoslovakia and between that country and Nazi Germany. With the threat of conflict, Pope Pius XI pleaded for peace. In the late 1930s, when Czechoslovakia became internationally isolated, the Vatican represented one of the few international voices in support of Czechoslovakia.
The Catholic Church, Italian Catholics and Peace Movements: The Cold War Years, 1947–1962
Contemporary European History, 2008
This article focuses on the early years of the cold war in Italy in the form of an analysis of the Catholic press from 1947 to the eve of the Second Vatican Council in 1962. In so doing it attempts to answer key questions for Italian Catholicism relating to peace building that arose from total war in the age of mass democracy.
Vatican and Catholics in Russia in 1920 - 1930: Communication Problems
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2016
The paper is concerned with Vatican looking for ways of communication with catholic church and believers in the USSR under conditions of church and religion persecution and authority's strict control over moving home, correspondence and personal contacts between priests and congregation and different foreign organisations as well. To establish links, obtain information and provide financial and moral support Vatican used such ways as receiving information from priests moving temporarily into the country or leaving it, from cloisterers and laymen as well as involving foreign diplomats. The most vulnerable was official correspondence even if letters were delivered by embassies and consulates.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.