In search of academic excellence with the strategy map: analysis of an Italian case study (original) (raw)
Related papers
Performance measurement in academic departments: the strategy map approach
Public Money & Management, 2011
The purpose of the paper is the implementation of the strategic map model to an academic department. We use a qualitative methodology to identify dimensions of performance measurement suitable for application. After identifying the relations between the four perspectives and identifying the strategic maps, the case proposes a set of goals and measures which are suitable to satisfy the managerial needs a public service organization.
Using the balanced scorecard as a performance management tool in higher education
Management in Education, 2020
This paper presents a critical review of the relevant literature on managerialism and performance management in higher education. Afterwards, it features an inductive research that involved semi-structured interview sessions with academic members of staff. The interpretative study relied on the balanced scorecard's (BSC) approach as it appraised the participants' opinions and perceptions on their higher education institution's (HEI) customer, internal, organizational capacity and financial perspectives. The findings have revealed the strengths and weaknesses of using the BSC's financial and non-financial measures to assess the institutional performance and the productivity of individual employees. In sum, this research reported that ongoing performance conversations with academic employees will help HEI leaders to identify their institutions' value creating activities. This contribution implies that HEI leaders can utilize the BSC's comprehensive framework as a plausible, performance management tool to regularly evaluate whether their institution is: (i) delivering inclusive, student-centered, quality education; (ii) publishing high impact research; (iii) engaging with internal and external stakeholders; and (iv) improving its financial results, among other positive outcomes.
American Journal of Operations Research, 2013
The principal objective of the research reported in this article is to validate a Balanced Scorecard (BSC) model and a Strategic Map for the University by studying the relationships of efficiency between its dimensions. Subsequently, the validation is completed by establishing hypotheses of efficiency relationships between the perspectives proposed, employing Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). Empirical evidence has been obtained on the validity of the proposed BSC for a unit of academic management in the university. The first contribution of this work is the establishment of a framework of analysis of the hypothetical cause-effect relationships in the BSC in university institutions. The second contribution is to obtain the determining factors of the performance in this type of institution and, therefore, the Strategic Map. Specifically, these factors are: the participation of teaching staff in innovation activities; the number of doctorate-level staff; the academic subjects and credits in the Virtual Campus; and the scores in the surveys of student satisfaction. With respect to research, the determining factors of the performance are: the research sexennials; the funding obtained from contracts with companies; the number of research projects obtained; their financing; and the participation of teachers in these projects.
Strategic Performance Management Using the Balanced Scorecard in Educational Institutions
Open Education Studies, 2023
The balanced scorecard (BSC) is a mission-oriented and strategy-focused performance management tool for educational institutions. The study reviews the literature on the implementation of the BSC by different educational institutions as a strategic performance management. After a comprehensive review of the literature, we analyzed the documents based on the publication trends during the years, authors' affiliations by countries, sources from which the documents have been published, most frequently used keywords in the documents, and the highest cited documents in the Scopus database. A bibliometric mapping analysis was used to construct and visualize the bibliometric networks. We found that 267 documents that were published in the sources are indexed by Scopus. Finally, gaps in the relevant literature are identified, leading to several directions for future research.
The conception “Balanced Scorecard”-tool for strategic management of higher education institutions
2020
The paper deals with the conception of Balanced Scorecard (BSC) as an innovation strategic management system, which appears to be a superstructure of the Quality Management Systems and provides for the assessment of the basic processes in an organization. The BSC methodology and its relationship with the ISO 9001 requirements is presented and on this basis, an innovation strategy map serving the purposes of a university development has been developed.
Ekonomika, 2016
European higher education institutions (HEIs) in the last two decades have faced a number of challenges: reduced public funding, increased competition from foreign and private universities, constant pressures and demands for their greater quality, and constant changes of education laws and legal regulations. The only way for fast adjustment of HEIs to the new competitive conditions is to explore all possibilities for effective implementation of some of the most popular management concepts such as Balanced Scorecard (BSC) system. Although the application of the BSC in the business sector is well documented, limited research has been reported regarding the application of the BSC in the education sector. For this purpose, relied on the existing literature, reported results and experiences from its implementation in business, firstly, we propose a suitable process for building a BSC system for HEI, and then we design a specific Strategy map and BSC system applicable for the Faculty of Economics-Skopje, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University, easily adaptable for implementation in other HEIs.
Applying balanced scorecard strategic management in higher education
2011
The functional efficiency of an institution of higher education depends on the size of the available resources and their efficient use, which is expressed using corresponding indicators e.g. the duration of study. Therefore, there is a need of using new and intelligent models and tools to control and evaluate the educational work. Such models give an emphasis in the processes of developing criteria, techniques, and indicators, and facilitate measurement and performance’s investigation. Recent research showed that Balanced Scorecard gained preferences of the administration of Educational Institutions. This paper presents a discussion of basic elements in a balanced target setting in the area of Higher Education. Keywords Higher Education Institution; Balanced scorecard; Strategic management; Quality criteria; KPI, Quality assurance; Quality strategic Map; ADOscore;
This paper concerns the topic of strategic planning in universities, considering both the normative requirements recently issued by the Italian Minister of Education and the emerging practices in the strategic plans published by the universities. The first section of this paper introduces some general observations in terms of regulatory prescriptions and management implications. Section 2 describes the practices of the Italian universities as regards the drafting and communication of strategic plans, while Section 3 outlines a methodological framework for the strategic planning process. The control of strategic objectives stated in the plans implies a performance measurement system, which may be based on the use of strategic performance indicators, better organized in a dashboard or scorecard. Section 4 describes the performance indicators used in the strategic plans published by the universities, in compliance with normative requirements as well as the management control systems fr...
Performance evaluation in research departments: from the Balanced Scorecard to the Strategy Map
2007
Notwithstanding a growing interest towards performance management systems for universities, little is known on their application to academic departments. Being an institution dedicated to research, a department presents specific characteristics: creativity, professional autonomy, low degree of repetitiveness, uncertainty on results, unclear relation between input and output. Such peculiarities make the evaluation and measurement of its performance particularly difficult. The purpose
Implementation of Balanced Scorecard: Case study of a Portuguese higher education institution
DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals - DOAJ, 2021
Contemporary organizations need to follow their performance over a continuous period, as the short period is not enough to provide complete control. Bearing this in mind, performance measurement indicators must be reflecting the organizational strategy, not just in the short term, but also in the medium and long term. In the past, especially in industrial enterprises, a high interest in measuring organizational performance was noted. Afterward, the need for effective performance management has also gained increased recognition and interest in Higher Education Institutions (HEIs). Considering the transversal demand for management control tools, the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) gained special highlight, based on its four interlinked perspectives (financial, customer, internal processes, and learning & growth), originally developed by Kaplan and Norton. The BSC was selected for this research, as it has been already implemented by multiple HEIs, to guide managers and directors in their decisions and contribute to greater efficiency. It was, therefore, also selected for the implementation by an analyzed Portuguese higher education institution. This research aims to contribute to the empirical and practical understanding of BSC implementation in higher education, whilst providing orientation to directors and managers of HEIs. With the implementation of this tool, managers and directors can monitor the organizational performance and follow the defined strategy in the medium and long term. Based on these findings, other institutions could use this study as a guide and a benchmark.