Romanchuk A. A. 2023. ‘Blind spots’ of the ‘Scandinavian-centric’ Hypothesis on the Origin of the Old Russian State. Social Evolution & History, Vol. 22 No. 2, September 2023, pp. 94–110. DOI: 10.30884/seh/2023.02.06. (original) (raw)
The author considers some of the 'blind spots' of the 'Scandinavian-centric' hypotheses on the emergence of the Old Russian state. He shows that adherents of the 'Scandinavian-centric paradigm' very often resort to ad hoc explanations without noticing the critical contradictions in their constructions. If we collect partial statements of the Scandinaviancentred hypotheses, we see how they begin to contradict each other. For example, according to Elena Melnikova, Old Russian 'варѧгъ' comes from Scandinavian 'vaeringi', which in turn comes from Greek 'βάρaγγοι', and Greek 'βάρaγγοι' in turn comes from the Old Russian 'варѧгъ'. In the context of the processes leading to the formation of the Old Russian state, the author critically evaluates the ideas of the 'Scandinavian control over the Baltic-Volga trade route' and 'Scandinavian colonies' in Eastern Europe. The local polities of early medieval Eastern Europe, whether Slavic, Baltic or Finnish, obviously possessed sufficient power and military potential to close off uncontrolled movement along the river routes to the Scandinavians if they so wished. The author also raises the question of the initial political status and real role in the formation of the Old Russian state of the emerging settlements specialized in trade in Ladoga and Gnezdovo.
Related papers
Scandinavia in Recent Historical Research in Russia
2017
This article is based on the author’s presentation at the international conference“Historical Background and Future Prospects in Russian-Nordic Relations” that was held in Moscow on June 23, 2016. Certain issues of cooperation between historians from Russia and the Scandinavian-Baltic region are covered in the article. The author gives specific examples of this cooperation and analyzes the main tendencies of Russian historical Scandinavistica’s development in recent decades.
The article continues the study of historical geography and trade routes of Eastern Europe of the 9th century. It analyzes the map of the archeological finds connected with the culture of medieval Scandinavians and other inhabitances of Northern Europe (arms, jewelry etc.). The map of these fi nds is compared with the map of hoards of the 9th century, which allows asserting that in a number of cases the places of the fi nds of Scandinavian artifacts and hoards coincide. Once again this fact is testimony to the participation of Scandinavians in the transit of silver coins across Eastern Europe. The data analysis of terminus post quem of the settlements connected with the presence of the Scandinavians in Eastern Europe allows to assert that all those settlements (except Ladoga and Rurikovo Gorodische) appeared in the early 10th century, and till the end of the 9th century there were no fi xed Scandinavian settlements outside the regions of the Volkhov and the Ilmen’. The areas, where the series of sing fi nds were found give the reason to mark the limits of arrival of the Scandinavian (Northern) pioneers. We argue that the 9th century was a special period in the history of Eastern Europe, the use of the later historical data (above all, concerning the 10th century) for the reconstruction of the historical processes of this century methodologically is inappropriate.
Special issue "Language and Border Between Scandinavia and Russia" of The Nordic Historical Review
This issue covers a region of Europe that is sometimes mentioned in reference to events such as the conquest of Ingria by Pontus de la Gardie in the 1580s or the Soviet-Finnish war of 1939 -1940, yet remains generally poorly known in Western Europe: the borders between Russia and its Nordic neighbours. The collected papers deal with this subject over several centuries, from the end of the Middle Ages to the late twentieth century. This broad span of time enables the issue to assess profound changes in the meaning that we attribute to different words designating the border and border territories.
Colonisation of the Past: Kyivan Rus and Moscow
This article considers the linguistic roots of the languages of the Eastern Slavs, where they meet and where they clearly have the same roots or often different ones, and the history of their developments. Modern commentators will be exclusively used. Influences on the different Slav groups will be considered and the extensive role played by Tatar groups in the development and enrichment of Volodymyr-Suzdal in the northeast including the Mongol invasion and its long term developments up to today. Also considered is the separate development of the above princedom and the subsequent identity collapse before and after the Mongolian takeover of their land, as well as the Russian academic position of limited Tatar involvement, showing that the evidence challenges this and demonstrates deep and lasting Tatar cultural impact from the Volga Bulgars to the Mongols, mainly directed towards the North Eastern princedom. Moscow functioned within the Golden Horde as their representatives in the West.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.