Cognitive Load and Learner Expertise: Split-Attention and Redundancy Effects in Reading with Explanatory Notes (original) (raw)
Related papers
Based on cognitive load theory, this paper explores the extent to which the redundancy effect influences L2 reading comprehension skills of two groups of learners whose ages and English language proficiency differed widely. 59 learners participated; 24 of them were teenagers with low-intermediate proficiency and 35 were adults whose command of English was advanced. Each group was divided into two sets. One was exposed to a single mode of instruction (reading alone) while the other was presented with a dual format (reading and listening simultaneously). Results revealed that students presented with the single mode of instruction outperformed the other group in the reading comprehension task, independently of their command of the language. Furthermore, when comparing results obtained in both read-only groups (low-intermediate and advanced), the students with higher proficiency obtained better results. In the light of the findings revealed some pedagogical implications for reading comprehension instruction are discussed.
2016
Using the Cognitive Load Theory as a theoretical framework, this paper explores the extent to which the redundancy effect influences the L2 reading comprehension skills of a group of young learners at a private school in Mar del Plata, Argentina. A group of 24 Hispanophone English learners participated in this study. They were divided into two groups: A & B. Both groups completed the same reading comprehension task separately, but each used a different mode of presentation. Group A was exposed to a single mode of instruction: reading alone, while group B was presented with a dual format which integrated reading and listening. Both groups had the same amount of time on task. Results revealed that group A (nonredundant group) outperformed group B (redundant group) in the task set. In the light of these findings some pedagogical implications for the teaching of reading comprehension skills in the English language classroom are discussed. Second language acquisition (henceforth, SLA) re...
ReCALL, 2010
Cognitive load theory has been utilized by second language acquisition (SLA) researchers to account for differences in learner performance with regards to different learning tasks. Certain instructional designs were shown to have an impact on cognitive load and working memory, and this impact was found to be accentuated in a multimedia environment where there is a variety of interacting elements and tools that can lead to cognitive overload and consequently reduced learning outcomes. This study investigated the influence of split-attention and integrated instructional formats on students’ cognitive load and how they might facilitate second language online reading and vocabulary learning. Twenty English as a Second Language (ESL) intermediate students studying at an Australian language institution were randomly assigned to four conditions: SAND (Split-Attention No Dictionary), SAOD (Split-Attention with Online Dictionary), IFND (Integrated Format No Dictionary), and IFOD (Integrated ...
Managing Working Memory in Language Instructions: An Overview of Cognitive Load Theory
Thammasat Review, 2013
Cognitive Load Theory (CLT) deals with different types of load available in human working memory and how to manipulate instructional designs so that working memory can be available for learning. Designing relevant instructional materials based on CLT can help promote students’ language learning based on research studies in language education when intrinsic cognitive load is hold stable, extraneous cognitive load is low, and germane cognitive load is high. Major areas of instructional designs which pose great challenges on language education include split-attention, modality effect, worked example and completion problem effect, and redundancy effect. Suggestions based on research studies in vocabulary, grammar, reading, writing, and listening-speaking are explored so that capacity in working memory can be enhanced, suitable for language learning. [Thammasat Review 2014, Vol.16, No.2, pp.93-108]
Unpacking the efficacy of Reading to Learn using Cognitive Load Theory
Journal of Academic Language and Learning, 2020
This paper synthesises the key findings of two past separate studies conducted by the same authors, which sought to assess the efficacy of the Reading to Learn (RtL) literacy intervention on students' academic writing performance. Both previous studies of RtL were implemented in response to growing concerns about the academic under-preparedness of undergraduate students at universities across South Africa. The first study aimed to support mostly firstgeneration, first-year English Additional Language (EAL) learners in their transition to higher education. The second study aimed to support EAL students' academic writing development at a senior secondary school level prior to the school-to-university transition. In both studies, the cohorts of students examined originated from low socioeconomic communities, where linguistic marginalisation arguably imposes significant barriers to successful university completion. The novel contribution of this paper is to use a Cognitive Load Theoretical lens to explicate why RtL might improve the academic writing skills of under-prepared students making the transition to university.
Effect of Text Presentation on Reading Fluency and Comprehension: An Exploratory Analysis
Previous research found that the type of text being read affected reading fluency and recall, and students of varying reading skills take different approaches to the task. The current study explored the effect the reader's skill level and format of presentation had on fluency and comprehension assessment by comparing student behavior between conditions in which students read from a book or from a typed single page. No significant differences were found in mean fluency and comprehension scores between the Book and Typed conditions for the two highest reading skills groups. However, the difference between the Typed and Book conditions was significant for both fluency and comprehension among children in the lowest reading group. Students in the lowest reading group read more fluently and with better comprehension from the Book condition than from the Typed condition. Suggestions for further research are included.
Effects of text structure on use of cognitive capacity during reading
Journal of Educational Psychology, 1982
In three experiments, the demand that text processing imposes on learners' cognitive capacity was measured with a secondary-task technique. In all experiments, the meaning of the textual materials was held constant while several structural (surface) variables were manipulated. Experiment 1 showed that text versions with simplified vocabulary and syntax (but equivalent content) required less cognitive capacity to process than standard versions. Experiment 2 revealed that the reduction in use of cognitive capacity observed in Experiment 1 was due primarily to syntactic factors. Finally, Experiment 3 demonstrated that texts containing signals about idea importance and idea relations required less cognitive capacity to process than texts with approximately the same propositional content, but no such signals. In each experiment, measures of total inspection time and content recall were also secured. In general, the findings of all three experiments indicated that aspects of the surface structure of text made demands on the reader's cognitive processing capacity.
The Effect of Integrated Instructions on Reading Comprehension, Motivation, and Cognitive Variables
Issues in Educational Research, 2016
This quasi-experimental study examined the contribution of concept-oriented reading instruction (CORI) on fifth grade students’ reading comprehension, motivation and metacognition. Participants were sixty-six fifth grade female Jordanian students who matched in gender, socioeconomic status, number of years learning English, and school attended. Students completed measures of reading comprehension test, motivation, and metacognition twice (before and after the intervention reading program). Results of preand post-test analyses of female students’ responses to the reading test and the metacognition and motivation questionnaires showed that reading comprehension, motivation, and metacognition increased only in the CORI group. This study has revealed the feasibility of implementing CORI in EFL reading contexts.