Bike-sharing and the performative promotion of urban sustainable mobility. A comparison of the political-aesthetic experiences provided by Vienna's Citybike and Paris' Vélib'. (original) (raw)
Related papers
Ride the City A New Way of Living the City and its Unexpected Places
(Book chapter) V. Ferrari 'Ride the City, A New Way of Living the City and its Unexpected Places', in Urban Design Ecologies: Projects for City Environments, M. Ghibusi, F. Marchetti, eds. 98-109. Santarcangelo di Romagna: Maggioli 2018. (English), 2018
The essay talks about the bicycle's utopia and how ever-changing cities have ever-new needs, linked to the quality of life of citizens. The study aims to promote the true value of sustainable mobility and the collective benefits it can bring. The collective benefits have not only effects on health, but also effects on the economy of families with a reduction in costs dedicated to the car, on economic policy such as the reduction of energy dependence and the saving of non-renewable resources. The bicycle is seen as the tool to trigger an urban revolution, it is a social fact, it is an opportunity for an unprecedented experience: it allows reevaluating distances and following impossible routes for public transport following fixed itineraries. To dream of a bicycle-friendly city, comprehensive and timely planning is essential, as well as following the example of many virtuous urban realities that already promote mobility and sustainable practices.
This paper is based on an ongoing comparative analysis on the social representations and usages of bicycles as a gateway to understand the current dynamics of urban life fruition. The project Alternative lifestyles in urban environment: multiple sceneries of the social usages of bicycles includes the cases of: Porto, in Portugal; Skopje, in Macedonia, and Niteroi (State of Rio de Janeiro), in Brazil. In this paper we discuss the first findings of the research developed in Porto, Portugal, with particular focus on personal experience of bicycles users and to the inclusion of bicycle usages in ecological, anti-capitalist and anti-mechanization lifestyles, as well as in capitalistic fashion trends, which rely on diverse forms of sharing platforms and practices. These results were collected through a preliminary content analysis to bicycle promotion groups' online platforms and semi-structured interviews with members of two collectives ‒ the Cicloficina do Porto («Bike Kitchen of Porto») and Massa Crítica do Porto («Critical Mass of Porto»). The content analysis of facebook pages, websites and blogs show that Cicloficina focuses mainly on the mechanics of bicycles and events promotion, while Massa Crítica highlights also aspects related to the history of bicycle and to urban planning projects favourable to bicycles users. In what concerns their interviewed members, there are some characteristics that define usages patterns. Eight of the eleven people use bicycles as their usual transportation mode and three of them that use bicycles mainly for leisure and sport purposes. This segmentation is associated with differentiated lifestyles.
Mundane intermodality: a comparative analysis of bike-renting practices
Mobilities
Bike rental systems have been introduced as a sustainable urban mobility alternative. This paper analyses the social practices that emerge as part of these systems. We specifically focus on the interactions and street-level performances at a bike rental station. We argue that the bike-sharing service is a pivotal device that enables its users to transform (to re-configure from pedestrians to cyclists and vice versa), hence creating intermodality. The bike rental system ensures the technical standardization of behaviour while simultaneously revealing differences between those familiar with the system and those who are not. Thus, competences and meanings of the station are not subordinate to materialsthey are interdependent, entwined and enacted in and through the practice itself.
The Making of a Pro-cycling City: Social Practices and Bicycle Mobilities AOM:
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING A
This article explores the contemporary co-production of bicycle practices in Copenhagen and the heterogeneous work involved in making a city pro-cycling. Attention is given as much to the sayings and doings of everyday commuters, as to planners, physical designs and campaigns. I ask: why, and how, are cycling practices continually (re)produced in Copenhagen and how can they attract so many practitioners? The first section discusses and employs practice theory, as it is well suited for examining practices of cycling. The second section explores how Copenhagen Municipality designed and scripted a cycle-friendly space by installing bike infrastructure, promoting cultural meanings and nourishing user competences. I argue that this is done through a heterogeneous process of normalizing and mainstreaming cycling and making alliances with other commuters. The third section shows how cyclists co-produce cycling practices by performing cycling and by enlisting and passing on knowledge to new practitioners. The concluding highlights the potentials of practice theory to fully understand cycling, and it unravels some of the problems of Copenhagenizing low-cycling cities.
The cycling as a driver of a renewed design and use of public space within the neighbourhoods
A great contribution both to the energy consumption and to the air pollution results from road transport and mainly from travels in urban areas. The great number of trips occurring into the urban areas is certainly due to the increase of people in the cities, which will increase in the future representing thus a large proportion of the world population. Therefore, it is most influential the reference of the urbanization model and related transport model. In fact, for different historical periods, the shape of cities was depending on transportation technologies. The massive use of the cars has induced the extension of the urban areas in all directions without a prevalent priority, it has encouraged the private motorized mobility with respect to the widespread accessibility and it has allowed the separation of urban functions. As a consequence a reduced quality of life, social segregation - especially for people with a low level of self-sufficiency, and a reduced sense of community of...
Limits on the Use of Public Space and Consumer Tactics: A Study on Urban Cycling
Latin American Business Review, 2019
Although public space is supposed to be democratic and accessible to all, in reality, such access is inegalitarian and exclusionary. The research aims, therefore, to understand how public space that reflects the imposition of interests of dominant ideologies affects the consumption practices of nondominant ideologies. The qualitative research data were collected in the context of urban cycling through in-depth interviews and observation and are analyzed using a hermeneutical approach. The research explains that, in order to deal with the limits of public space use, these consumers use tactics involving (1) disputes for space, (2) disorganized occupation, and (3) transgressive practices; moreover, there is an overlapping relationship between the agency of consumers and public space. RESUMEN Aunque el espacio p ublico tendr ıa que ser democr atico y accesible a todos, se observa que, en realidad, es poco igualitario y excluyente. Por ende, el prop osito de esta investigaci on es comprender c omo el espacio p ublico, que refleja la imposici on de los intereses de las ideolog ıas dominantes afecta las pr acticas de consumo de las ideolog ıas no dominantes. Los datos de la investigaci on cualitativa se recopilaron en el contexto del ciclismo urbano mediante entrevistas en profundidad y observaci on analizados de forma hermen eutica. Como resultado, la investigaci on explica que, para liderar con los l ımites de uso del espacio p ublico, esos consumidores usan las t acticas de (1) disputa de los espacios (2) ocupaci on desorganizada y (3) pr acticas desviacionistas, existiendo una relaci on entrelazada entre las agencias de los consumidores y del espacio p ublico. RESUMO O espaço p ublico deveria ser democr atico e acess ıvel a todos, mas, na realidade, revela-se pouco igualit ario e excludente. A pesquisa tem como objetivo, portanto, entender como o espaço p ublico que reflete a imposic¸ão de interesses de ideologias dominante afeta as pr aticas de consumo de ideologias não dominantes. Os dados da pesquisa qualitativa foram coletados no contexto do ciclismo urbano por meio de entrevistas ARTICLE HISTORY
Contested values in bike-sharing mobilities -A case study from Sweden
Journal of Transport Geography, 2021
The aim of this paper is to analyse the type of mobilities and subjects that are being promoted and constituted through bike-sharing systems. This is done through an analysis of the bike-sharing system in the city of Lund in Sweden. The analysis utilises Bacchi’s What is the Problem Represented to be? framework and develops it through adding a spatial perspective. Departing from a critical velomobilities perspective, we argue that urban transport policies cannot merely be regarded as one specific and delimited reaction to well-defined policy problems. Instead, the ways that BSSs are, described, motivated – but also spatially organised – constitute which mobilities are produced. The analysis is based in an analysis of relevant policy documents, maps and observations. It is concluded that bike sharing is not seen as cycling and is rarely linked to cycling as such, but rather is seen as part of the public transport system. Further, it is concluded that the motivation behind the location of the stations is to facilitate the flow of workers to public transport, and promote attractiveness and tourism, thus constituting a strong belief in a win-win situation between sustainability and growth. Here prioritisation between different values, and the possible tensions between different social and environmental dimensions of sustainability is down-played.
The paper examines the spectacle of contemporary forms of advertising and product placements techniques in the context of urban environments (including the phenomenon of the so called 'brand city').This is an 'over-exposed city', to use Virilio's terminology, a city penetrated by media and advertising, a topical manifestation of what Guy Debord called the 'Society of the Spectacle'. The paper juxtaposes to the above well rehearsed critical scenarios an examination of several urban art projects that attempt to design an image of the city as a locus of convergence, creativity and citizenship. There is a powerful visual language at work in the contemporary city, one that operates beyond the phantasmagoria of consumption. Inspired by the Situationists' intent to stimulate permanent social dynamics in the city through playful interventions based on integration between art and technology, such projects show the ability of individuals and social groups to appropriate and co-create urban space. It remains to be seen, though whether such playful interventions bring about new viable conceptions of the public sphere or, conversely, whether their impact is similar, in its ineffectuality, to that of the Situationist precursors.