Quantized zero-bias conductance plateau in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures without topological Majorana zero modes (original) (raw)
Related papers
Physical Review B, 2013
We show that a topologically trivial zero bias conductance peak is produced in semiconductorsuperconductor hybrid structures due to a suppressed superconducting pair potential and/or an excess Zeeman field at the ends of the heterostructure, both of which can occur in experiments. The zero bias peak (ZBP) (a) appears above a threshold parallel bulk Zeeman field, (b) is stable for a range of bulk field before splitting, (c) disappears with rotation of the bulk Zeeman field, and, (d) is robust to weak disorder fluctuations. The topologically trivial ZBPs are also expected to produce splitting oscillations with the applied field similar to those from Majorana fermions. Because of such strong similarity with the phenomenology expected from Majorana fermions we find that the only unambiguous way to distinguish these trivial ZBPs (of height 4e 2 /h) from those arising from Majorana fermions (of height 2e 2 /h) is by comparing the (zero temperature) peak height and/or through an interference experiment.
Physical Review B
The recent experimental observations of decaying energy oscillations with increasing magnetic field in semiconductor-superconductor Majorana nanowires is in contrast with the theoretical expectations based on the presence of Majorana zero modes localized at the ends of the system. These observations have been recently theoretically justified by considering a position-dependent spin-orbit coupling that can emerge due to a tunnel gate. Here, we show that the window in parameter space where this phenomenology occurs is vanishingly small when compared to the parameter region where Majorana oscillations should increase in amplitude with the applied magnetic field. Further, including a position-dependent effective potential that is also induced due to a tunnel gate practically removes this small window. Using extensive numerical calculations, we show that, as expected, increasing amplitude oscillations of the hybridization energy represent a generic property of topological Majorana zero modes, while decreasing amplitude oscillations are a generic property of low-energy trivial Andreev bound states, recently called partially separated Andreev bound states. By averaging over several realistic parameter configurations, we identify robust features of the hybridization energy that can be observed in a typical differential conductance experiment without fine-tuning the control parameters.
Physical Review Letters, 2012
We investigate theoretically the low-energy physics of semiconductor Majorana wires in the vicinity of a magnetic field-driven topological quantum phase transition (TQPT). The local density of states at the end of the wire, which is directly related to the differential conductance in the limit of point-contact tunneling, is calculated numerically.We find that the dependence of the end-of-wire local density of states on the magnetic field is nonuniversal and that the signatures associated with the closing of the superconducting gap at the Majorana TQPT are essentially invisible within a significant range of experimentally relevant parameters. Our results provide a possible explanation for the recent observation of the apparent nonclosure of the gap at the Majorana TQPT in semiconductor nanowires.
2013
Rashba spin-orbit coupled semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structures in the presence of Zeeman splitting have emerged as the first experimentally realizable topological superconductor supporting zero-energy Majorana bound states. However, recent experimental studies in these hybrid structures are not in complete agreement with the theoretical predictions, for example, the observed height of the zero-bias conductance peak (ZBCP) associated with the Majorana bound states is less than 10% of the predicted quantized value 2e 2 /h. We try to understand the sources of various discrepancies between the recent experiments and the earlier theories by starting from a microscopic theory and studying non-equilibrium transport in these systems at arbitrary temperatures and applied bias voltages. Our approach involves quantum Langevin equations and non-equilibrium Green's functions. Here we are able to model the tunnel coupling between the one-dimensional semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structure and the metallic leads realistically; study the role of tunnel coupling on the height of the ZBCP and the subgap conductance; predict the nature of the splitting of the ZBCP with an increasing magnetic field beyond the critical field; show the behavior of the ZBCP with an increasing gate-controlled onsite potential; and study the evolution of the full differential conductance across the topological quantum phase transition. When the applied magnetic field is quite large compared to the Rashba splitting and the bulk energy gap is much reduced, we find the ZBCP even for an onsite potential much larger than the applied magnetic field. The height of the corresponding ZBCP depends on the tunnel coupling even at zero temperature and can be much smaller than 2e 2 /h.
Metamorphosis of Andreev bound states into Majorana bound states in pristine nanowires
Physical Review B
We show theoretically that in the generic finite chemical potential situation, the clean superconducting spin-orbit-coupled nanowire has two distinct nontopological regimes as a function of Zeeman splitting (below the topological quantum phase transition): one is characterized by finite-energy ingap Andreev bound states, while the other has only extended bulk states. The Andreev bound state regime is characterized by strong features in the tunneling spectra creating a "gap closure" signature, but no "gap reopening" signature should be apparent above the topological quantum phase transition, in agreement with most recent experimental observations. The gap closure feature is actually the coming together of the Andreev bound states at high chemical potential rather than a simple trivial gap of extended bulk states closing at the transition. Our theoretical finding establishes the generic intrinsic Andreev bound states on the trivial side of the topological quantum phase transition as the main contributors to the tunneling conductance spectra, providing a generic interpretation of existing experiments in clean Majorana nanowires. Our work also explains why experimental tunnel conductance spectra generically have gap closing features below the topological quantum phase transition, but no gap opening features above it.
Quantized Majorana conductance
Nature, 2018
Majorana zero-modes-a type of localized quasiparticle-hold great promise for topological quantum computing. Tunnelling spectroscopy in electrical transport is the primary tool for identifying the presence of Majorana zero-modes, for instance as a zero-bias peak in differential conductance. The height of the Majorana zero-bias peak is predicted to be quantized at the universal conductance value of 2e/h at zero temperature (where e is the charge of an electron and h is the Planck constant), as a direct consequence of the famous Majorana symmetry in which a particle is its own antiparticle. The Majorana symmetry protects the quantization against disorder, interactions and variations in the tunnel coupling. Previous experiments, however, have mostly shown zero-bias peaks much smaller than 2e/h, with a recent observation of a peak height close to 2e/h. Here we report a quantized conductance plateau at 2e/h in the zero-bias conductance measured in indium antimonide semiconductor nanowires...
Majorana Fermions in Semiconductor Nanowires: Fundamentals, Modeling, and Experiment
2013
After a recent series of rapid and exciting developments, the long search for the Majorana fermion-the elusive quantum entity at the border between particles and antiparticles-has produced the first positive experimental results, but is not over yet. Originally proposed by E. Majorana in the context of particle physics, Majorana fermions have a condensed matter analog in the zero-energy bound states emerging in topological superconductors. A promising route to engineering topological superconductors capable of hosting Majorana zero modes consists of proximity coupling semiconductor thin films or nanowires with strong spin-orbit interaction to conventional s-wave superconductors in the presence of an external Zeeman field. The Majorana zero mode is predicted to emerge above a certain critical Zeeman field as a zero-energy state localized near the order parameter defects, viz., vortices for thin films and wire-ends for the nanowire. These Majorana bound states are expected to manifest non-Abelian quantum statistics, which makes them ideal building blocks for fault-tolerant topological quantum computation. This review provides an update on current status of the search for Majorana fermions in semiconductor nanowires by focusing on the recent developments, in particular the period following the first reports of experimental signatures consistent with the realization of Majorana bound states in semiconductor nanowire-superconductor hybrid structures. We start with a discussion of the fundamental aspects of the subject, followed by considerations on the realistic modeling which is a critical bridge between theoretical predictions based on idealized conditions and the real world, as probed experimentally. The last part is dedicated to a few intriguing issues that were brought to the fore by the recent encouraging experimental advances.
Physical Review B, 2010
We show that an ordinary semiconducting thin film with spin-orbit coupling can, under ap- propriate circumstances, be in a quantum topologically ordered state supporting exotic Majorana excitations which follow non-Abelian statistics. The key to the quantum topological order is the coexistence of spin-orbit coupling with proximity-induced s-wave superconductivity and an externally-induced Zeeman coupling of the spins. For the Zeeman coupling below a critical value, the system is a non-topological (proximity-induced) s-wave superconductor. However, for a range of Zeeman coupling above the critical value, the lowest energy excited state inside a vortex is a zero-energy Majorana fermion state. The system, thus, has entered into a non-Abelian s-wave superconducting state via a topological quantum phase transition (TQPT) tuned by the Zeeman coupling. In the one-dimensional version of the same structure and for the Zeeman coupling above the critical value, there are localized Majorana zero-energy modes at the two ends of a semiconducting quantum nanowire. In this case, the Zeeman coupling can be induced more easily by an external magnetic field parallel to the wire, obviating the need for a magnetic insulator. We show that, despite the fact that the superconducting pair potential in the nanowire is explicitly s-wave, tunneling of electrons to the ends of the wire reveals a pronounced zero-bias peak. Such a peak is absent when the Zeeman coupling is below its critical value, i.e., the nanowire is in the non-topological s-wave superconducting state. We argue that the observation of this zero-bias tunneling peak in the semiconductor nanowire is possibly the simplest and clearest experiment proposed so far to unambiguously detect a Majorana fermion mode in a condensed matter system.
Physical Review B, 2013
A proposed signature for the Majorana zero-energy quasiparticle predicted to occur in semiconductor nanowires proximity-coupled to an s-wave superconductor is the zero-bias conductance peak (ZBCP) for tunneling into the end of the wire. Recently, it has been shown that, in the presence of a smooth confining potential, nearly ZBCPs can occur even in the topologically trivial phase. Here we show that, for a smooth confinement, the emergence of the nearly ZBCP at Zeeman fields corresponding to the topologically trivial phase is necessarily accompanied by a gap closing signature in the end-of-wire local density of state (LDOS). A similar behavior is found for nearly ZBCPs that appear in the presence of strong disorder. Our results strengthen the identification of the ZBCP observed in the recent Delft measurements, which show no gap-closing signatures, with topological Majorana fermions localized at the ends of the wire.