“More than a diet”: A qualitative investigation of young vegan Women's relationship to food (original) (raw)
Related papers
You are what you eat? Vegetarianism, health and identity
Social Science & Medicine, 2008
This paper examines the views of 'health vegetarians' through a qualitative study of an online vegetarian message board. The researcher participated in discussions on the board, gathered responses to questions from 33 participants, and conducted follow-up e-mail interviews with eighteen of these participants. Respondents were predominantly from the US, Canada and the UK. Seventy per cent were female, and ages ranged from 14 to 53, with a median of 26 years. This data is interrogated within a theoretical framework that asks, 'what can a vegetarian body do?' and explores the physical, psychic, social and conceptual relations of participants. This provides insights into the identities of participants, and how diet and identity interact. It is concluded that vegetarianism is both a diet and a bodily practice with consequences for identity formation and stabilisation.
Living in a Minority Food Culture: A Phenomenological Investigation of Being Vegetarian/Vegan
This phenomenological investigation aims to explore the lived experience of being vegan or vegetarian in a society and culture that is primarily non-vegetarian. As members of a unique minority group, vegans and vegetarians can sometimes be misunderstood by non-vegetarians and stereotyped as judgmental or difficult to deal with. Living with this type of misunderstanding from others can lead to feelings such as worry, loneliness, and fear. As such, the use of phenomenological inquiry is well suited to uncover the lived experience this phenomenon in such a way that no other method of inquiry could. The author brings forward themes that emerged from in depth conversations with two vegan/vegetarian participants, and draws from her own personal experiences as a vegetarian to supplement the data and further uncover the phenomenon. Themes are brought forward through the use of, among other works, and descriptions of "inside vs. outside" and van notion of secrecy.
Reflexivity in Vegan Eating Practices: A Qualitative Study in Santiago, Chile
Sustainability
Global warming and the necessity to reduce carbon emissions have introduced plant-based diets and veganism into academic and general discussion. Previous studies analyzed vegan consumption practices as central to leading such a lifestyle, but these studies focused on the material dimension of vegan consumption and not on the cognitive strategies involved in food choices. The purpose of this research was to analyze the cognitive and practical strategies used by vegans in adopting non-animal food consumption. For this purpose, the study examined biographic interviews with young vegans in Santiago, Chile. The results showed that adopting veganism implies a new social identity that redefines the edible/inedible categories. To maintain their identity, vegans must control their eating and make it reflexive. The establishment of new eating practices, based on individual and peer learning, facilitates their daily food choices, although reflexivity will always be present. This work contribut...
“I am a Vegetarian”: Reflections on a Way of Being
Employing a qualitative method adapted from phenomenological psychology, the paper presents a socio-psychological portrait of a vegetarian. Descriptives are a product of the author’s reflection on (dialogue with) empirical findings and published personal accounts, interviews, and case studies. The paper provides evidence for the hypothesis that vegetarianism is a way of being. This way of experiencing and living in the world is associated with particular forms of relationship to self, to other animals and nature, and to other people. The achievement of this way of being, particularly in the interpersonal sphere, comprises an initial, a transitional, and a crystallizing phase of development. The paper frames contrasts between vegetarianism and carnism through the phenomena of the presence of an absence and the absent referent, respectively.
Vegan Killjoys at the Table—Contesting Happiness and Negotiating Relationships with Food Practices
This article reports upon research on vegan transition, which I bring into dialogue with Sara Ahmed’s figure of the killjoy. Ahmed’s work on affect and the feminist killjoy is found to be apt for considering contemporary vegans and their transgression of normative scripts of happiness and commensality in a dominant meat and dairy consuming culture. The decentring of joy and happiness is also found to be integral to the critical deconstructive work of the vegan killjoy. Ahmed’s ideas further complement the frame of practice theory that I draw upon to understand the process of transition especially in the sense of opposing the meanings of dominant practices. Although food and veganism are not commented upon by Ahmed, the vegan subject constitutes, I argue, a potent further example of what she terms an “affect alien” who must willfully struggle against a dominant affective order and community. Drawing upon interviews with 40 vegans based in the UK, I illustrate examples of contestation and negotiation by vegans and those close to them. The article finds in the figure of the killjoy not only a frame by which to partly understand the negotiation of relationships between vegans and non-vegans but also an opportunity for further intersectional labour between veganism and feminism.
Comprehending Vegan Identity Construction through Consumption: A qualitative meta-synthesis
CBR - Consumer Behavior Review, 2020
This article aims to comprehend vegan identity construction through consumption. For this, a meta-synthesis of the accomplished results was made. It was conceived according to Sandelowski and & Barroso (2006) model, in order to compile the results into a grounded theory. As the analyses were complete, a theoretical model composed by eight microcategories and a central category was assembled. Results showed that reflection about consumption is one of the primordial factors on vegan identity construction, since this lifestyle imposes to its supporters the need to act consciously towards their purchase actions. In addition, it is by means of these actions that the defended ethic and moral considerations are converted into practical actions. Therefore, it is observed that reflection and consumption behavior are responsible for differentiating the vegan public from the others and what allows the construction and affirmation of its identity.
“What Pushed Me over the Edge Was a Deer Hunter”: Being Vegan in North America
Society & Animals, 2011
Thirty-two vegans were interviewed in order to examine the reasons for becoming vegan, the sustaining motivation to persist, the interpersonal and intrapersonal impact of the diet and associated practices, and the vegans’ assessment of omnivores’ eating practices. Interviews were analyzed using a model that diagrams the process of becoming vegan provided by McDonald (2000). Participants reported strained professional and personal relationships as a result of their diet and beliefs. Vegan diets were associated with an increase in physical, eudaemonic, and spiritual well-being.
THE PSYCHOLOGY OF VEGANISM: RESEARCH ARTICLE, 2019
Veganism is a growing area of research as the plant-based, ethically-motivated lifestyle is gaining traction faster than any other movement around the world. Being part of the vegan community can affect how people shape their social lives and how they are treated by non-vegans – with prejudice against vegans being known as ‘vegaphobia’. As the vegan population rises other fields of psychological research ought to be considered – such as whether cognitive dissonance occurs amongst vegans in the same way it occurs amongst meat consumers. This study focussed on exploring the personal and social identity aspects of those following the vegan lifestyle and looked at the existence of cognitive dissonance within the vegan community – using an online questionnaire shared to vegan Facebook groups. A total of 994 participants were included in the research analysis, to which Kruskal-Wallis tests were applied to discover whether respondent’s identity, social experiences and relationships were affected by their gender, age and the duration of their veganism. The same tests were utilised to discover whether cognitive dissonance was apparent within the sample population when they were confronted with the morally grey areas of the vegan lifestyle. Results showed a significant main effect of gender, age and duration of veganism on various aspects of vegan living – such as on the strength of vegan identity, perceived levels of vegaphobia, friendship circles and romantic relationships. Results also demonstrated the existence of cognitive dissonance within the vegan community regarding grey areas such as feeding meat to carnivorous pets, using animal-tested medications, using animal products purchased pre-veganism and purchasing products from ethically-questionable companies.