Using the Proton Energy Spectrum and Microdosimetry to Model Proton Relative Biological Effectiveness (original) (raw)
Related papers
Journal of Radiation Research, 2013
The authors attempt to establish the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) calculation for designing therapeutic proton beams on the basis of microdosimetry. The tissue-equivalent proportional counter (TEPC) was used to measure microdosimetric lineal energy spectra for proton beams at various depths in a water phantom. An RBE-weighted absorbed dose is defined as an absorbed dose multiplied by an RBE for cell death of human salivary gland (HSG) tumor cells in this study. The RBE values were calculated by a modified microdosimetric kinetic model using the biological parameters for HSG tumor cells. The calculated RBE distributions showed a gradual increase to about 1cm short of a beam range and a steep increase around the beam range for both the mono-energetic and spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP) proton beams. The calculated RBE values were partially compared with a biological experiment in which the HSG tumor cells were irradiated by the SOBP beam except around the distal end. The RBE-weighted absorbed dose distribution for the SOBP beam was derived from the measured spectra for the mono-energetic beam by a mixing calculation, and it was confirmed that it agreed well with that directly derived from the microdosimetric spectra measured in the SOBP beam. The absorbed dose distributions to planarize the RBE-weighted absorbed dose were calculated in consideration of the RBE dependence on the prescribed absorbed dose and cellular radio-sensitivity. The results show that the microdosimetric measurement for the mono-energetic proton beam is also useful for designing RBE-weighted absorbed dose distributions for range-modulated proton beams.
Journal of Radiation Research, 2013
The authors attempt to establish the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) calculation for designing therapeutic proton beams on the basis of microdosimetry. The tissue-equivalent proportional counter (TEPC) was used to measure microdosimetric lineal energy spectra for proton beams at various depths in a water phantom. An RBE-weighted absorbed dose is defined as an absorbed dose multiplied by an RBE for cell death of human salivary gland (HSG) tumor cells in this study. The RBE values were calculated by a modified microdosimetric kinetic model using the biological parameters for HSG tumor cells. The calculated RBE distributions showed a gradual increase to about 1cm short of a beam range and a steep increase around the beam range for both the mono-energetic and spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP) proton beams. The calculated RBE values were partially compared with a biological experiment in which the HSG tumor cells were irradiated by the SOBP beam except around the distal end. The RBE-weighted absorbed dose distribution for the SOBP beam was derived from the measured spectra for the mono-energetic beam by a mixing calculation, and it was confirmed that it agreed well with that directly derived from the microdosimetric spectra measured in the SOBP beam. The absorbed dose distributions to planarize the RBE-weighted absorbed dose were calculated in consideration of the RBE dependence on the prescribed absorbed dose and cellular radio-sensitivity. The results show that the microdosimetric measurement for the mono-energetic proton beam is also useful for designing RBE-weighted absorbed dose distributions for range-modulated proton beams.
International Journal of Radiation Oncology*Biology*Physics, 2012
Purpose: The physical and potential biological advantages of proton and carbon ions have not been fully exploited in radiation therapy for the treatment of cancer. In this work, an approach to predict proton and carbon ion relative biological effectiveness (RBE) in a representative spreadout Bragg peak (SOBP) is derived using the repair-misrepair-fixation (RMF) model. Methods and Materials: Formulas linking dose-averaged linear-quadratic parameters to DSB induction and processing are derived from the RMF model. The Monte Carlo Damage Simulation (MCDS) software is used to quantify the effects of radiation quality on the induction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSB). Trends in parameters a and b for clinically relevant proton and carbon ion kinetic energies are determined. Results: Proton and carbon ion RBE are shown to increase as particle energy, dose, and tissue a/b ratios decrease. Entrance RBE is w1.0 and w1.3 for protons and carbon ions, respectively.
Journal of Biomedical Physics and Engineering, 2017
Background: The assessment of RBE quantity in the treatment of cancer tumors with proton beams in treatment planning systems (TPS) is of high significance. Given the significance of the issue and the studies conducted in the literature, this quantity is fixed and is taken as equal to 1.1. Objective: The main objective of this study was to assess RBE quantity of proton beams and their variations in different depths of the tumor. This dependency makes RBE values used in TPS no longer be fixed as they depend on the depth of the tumor and therefore this dependency causes some changes in the physical dose profile. Materials and Methods: The energy spectrum of protons was measured at various depths of the tumor using proton beam simulations and well as the complete simulation of a cell to a pair of DNA bases through Monte Carlo GEANT4. The resulting energy spectrum was used to estimate the number of double-strand breaks generated in cells. Finally, RBE values were calculated in terms of the penetration depth in the tumor. Results and Conclusion:The simulation results show that the RBE value not fixed terms of the depth of the tumor and it differs from the clinical value of 1.1 at the end of the dose profile and this will lead to a non-uniform absorbed dose profile. Therefore, to create a uniform impact dose area, deep-finishing systems need to be designed by taking into account deep RBE values. Keywords: Proton Therapy , Relative Biological Radiation Effectiveness , Geant4 , Absorbed Dose , Iso-effective Dose , DSB
The Irradiation of V79 Mammalian Cells by Protons with Energies below 2 MeV
International Journal of Radiation Biology, 1989
The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) has been determined for protons with mean energies of 1 . 9, 1 . 15 and 0.76 MeV, from measurements of the survival of V79 Chinese hamster cells . The cells are supported as a monolayer and are swept through a beam of scattered protons produced using a 4 MeV Van de Graaff accelerator . An estimation of the dose and unrestricted linear energy transfer (LET) variation within the sensitive volume of the cells is given for the three proton energies . The RBEs for cell survival (relative to 250kVp X-rays) at the 10 per cent survival level are 1 . 6, 1 .9 and 3 . 36 for protons with track-average LETs of 17, 24 and 32 keV µm -I respectively, and the data suggest that protons are most effective at about 40-50keVum _1 . It is shown that the proton RBEs can be reconciled with those of other light ions if plotted against x*Z/ fl2 (where x* is the effective charge and fi is the relative velocity) rather than against LET .
Medium-thickness-dependent proton dosimetry for radiobiological experiments
Scientific Reports
A calibration method was proposed in the present work to determine the medium-thickness-dependent proton doses absorbed in cellular components (i.e., cellular cytoplasm and nucleus) in radiobiological experiments. consideration of the dependency on medium thickness was crucial as the linear energy transfer (Let) of protons could rise to a sharp peak (known as the Bragg peak) towards the end of their ranges. Relationships between the calibration coefficient R vs medium-layer thickness were obtained for incident proton energies of 10, 15, 20, 25, 30 and 35 MeV, and for various medium thicknesses up to 5000 μm, where R was defined as the ratio D A /D E , D A was the absorbed proton dose in cellular components, and D E was the absorbed proton dose in a separate radiation detector. in the present work, D A and D E were determined using the McnpX (Monte carlo n-particle eXtended) code version 2.4.0. For lower incident proton energies (i.e., 10, 15 and 20 MeV), formation of Bragg-peak-like features were noticed in their R-vs-medium-layer-thickness relationships, and large R values of >7 and >6 were obtained for cytoplasm and nucleus of cells, respectively, which highlighted the importance of careful consideration of the medium thickness in radiobiological experiments.
Empirical model estimation of relative biological effectiveness for proton beam therapy
Radiation Protection Dosimetry, 2012
A simple model for proton relative biological effectiveness (RBE) is proposed. It describes the RBE as a function of proton depth, the dose and the linear energy transfer (LET) when proton passes through tissue-like materials. Radiobiological parameters were first obtained by fitting the published experimental cell survival data. The dose-averaged LET values were calculated for 250-MeV proton beam in a water phantom by using GEANT4 Monte Carlo simulation code and were then used as input values to calculate the values of RBE as function of depths. The model was also applied to proton spread-out Bragg peak, where the increasing RBE with depth causes an extended RBE-weighted dose in the distal fall-off region. This model was found to be able to reproduce the measured RBE values as a function of LET, depth and dose for a specific cell line.
Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2002
A calibration method was proposed in the present work to determine the medium-thickness-dependent proton doses absorbed in cellular components (i.e., cellular cytoplasm and nucleus) in radiobiological experiments. consideration of the dependency on medium thickness was crucial as the linear energy transfer (Let) of protons could rise to a sharp peak (known as the Bragg peak) towards the end of their ranges. Relationships between the calibration coefficient R vs medium-layer thickness were obtained for incident proton energies of 10, 15, 20, 25, 30 and 35 MeV, and for various medium thicknesses up to 5000 μm, where R was defined as the ratio D A /D E , D A was the absorbed proton dose in cellular components, and D E was the absorbed proton dose in a separate radiation detector. in the present work, D A and D E were determined using the McnpX (Monte carlo n-particle eXtended) code version 2.4.0. For lower incident proton energies (i.e., 10, 15 and 20 MeV), formation of Bragg-peak-like features were noticed in their R-vs-medium-layer-thickness relationships, and large R values of >7 and >6 were obtained for cytoplasm and nucleus of cells, respectively, which highlighted the importance of careful consideration of the medium thickness in radiobiological experiments.
Purpose: The Geant4 Monte Carlo simulation toolkit was used to reproduce radiobiological parameters measured by irradiating three different cancerous cell lines with monochromatic and clinical proton beams. Methods: The experimental set-up adopted for irradiations was fully simulated with a dedicated open-source Geant4 application. Cells survival fractions was calculated coupling the Geant4 simulations with two analytical radiobiological models: one based on the LEM (Local Effect Model) approach and the other on a semi-empirical parameterisation. Results was evaluated and compared with experimental data.