Plant–plant interactions promote alpine diversification (original) (raw)
Related papers
Interactions among species determine local-scale diversity, but local interactions are thought to have minor effects at larger scales. However, quantitative comparisons of the importance of biotic interactions relative to other drivers are rarely made at larger scales. Using a data set spanning 78 sites and five continents, we assessed the relative importance of biotic interactions and climate in determining plant diversity in alpine ecosystems dominated by nurse-plant cushion species. Climate variables related with water balance showed the highest correlation with richness at the global scale. Strikingly, although the effect of cushion species on diversity was lower than that of climate, its contribution was still substantial. In particular, cushion species enhanced species richness more in systems with inherently impoverished local diversity. Nurse species appear to act as a ‘safety net’ sustaining diversity under harsh conditions, demonstrating that climate and species interactions should be integrated when predicting future biodiversity effects of climate change.
Facilitative plant interactions and climate simultaneously drive alpine plant diversity
Ecology Letters, 2014
Interactions among species determine local-scale diversity, but local interactions are thought to have minor effects at larger scales. However, quantitative comparisons of the importance of biotic interactions relative to other drivers are rarely made at larger scales. Using a data set spanning 78 sites and five continents, we assessed the relative importance of biotic interactions and climate in determining plant diversity in alpine ecosystems dominated by nurse-plant cushion species. Climate variables related with water balance showed the highest correlation with richness at the global scale. Strikingly, although the effect of cushion species on diversity was lower than that of climate, its contribution was still substantial. In particular, cushion species enhanced species richness more in systems with inherently impoverished local diversity. Nurse species appear to act as a 'safety net' sustaining diversity under harsh conditions, demonstrating that climate and species interactions should be integrated when predicting future biodiversity effects of climate change.
Climatic drivers of plant–plant interactions and diversity in alpine communities
Alpine Botany, 2011
Alpine plant communities are particularly amenable to experimentally test the stress-gradient hypothesis (SGH), which predicts that competitive interactions will be more frequent in relatively productive environments, whereas facilitation will be more common in severe systems. Experimental testing of the SGH along latitudinal and elevation gradients within and across continents indicated that particular climatic variables act as drivers of plant-plant interactions and community structure. However, the SGH in its current form remains a general framework that does not link explicitly climate variables such as temperature and precipitation to plant interactions or diversity. Here, we re-analyse our published data in order to explore whether climate can regulate biotic interactions and species diversity in alpine communities. We applied PCA to meteorological data, introduced latitude as a variable, and also used specially developed composite variables that combine temperature and precipitation during the growing season. The intensity of competitive interactions at low elevations decreased with increasing latitude, whereas the intensity of facilitative interactions at higher elevations did not vary with latitude. Micro-scale spatial patterns followed the same trend indicating that plant-plant interactions could generate these patterns. These findings specify the role of temperature in shifting the balance of plant interactions and can be readily incorporated in the SGH. We also found that species richness correlated positively with a composite climate variable, which is the product of maximum temperature and precipitation. Inclusion of this finding into the SGH will, however, need further studies focusing on the importance of water-energy relations for the dynamic balance of facilitation and competition.
FACILITATION AND COMPETITION ON GRADIENTS IN ALPINE PLANT COMMUNITIES
Ecology, 2001
We conducted a neighbor removal experiment in natural alpine plant communities of the southwestern Alps to test for the relative importance of competitive and facilitative interactions along elevational and topographical gradients. The experimental sites were chosen to encompass most of the floristic diversity observed along gradients of elevation and topography, which are the two main ecological gradients associated with alpine plant communities in the western Alps. The effects of neighbor removal on the survival, aboveground biomass, and reproduction of five target species were tested at each of six experimental sites. Using biomass data, we calculated relative competitive index (RCI) and log response ratio (LRR) as measures of interaction strength and direction. We found highly significant shifts from strong competitive effects in low and sheltered sites to strong facilitative responses in high and exposed sites. When experimental results were integrated with gradient analyses, we found that the responses of particular alpine plant species to neighbor removal generally depended on the species' position on elevational and topographical gradients. When neighbors were removed from around target species at experimental sites that were lower in elevation than the distributional mean of the target species, biomass generally increased. When neighbors were removed from around target species at experimental sites that were higher in elevation than the distributional mean of the target species, biomass decreased. In other words, facilitation appeared to allow species from lower elevations to move up the gradient, but competition at low elevations appeared to restrict species from higher elevations from moving down the gradient. In high and exposed sites, experimental evidence for facilitation was coupled to small-scale spatial associations among species, but spatial disassociation was not coupled to experimental evidence for competition at any sites. We conclude that the distribution and abundance of many species in high-elevation communities of the western Alps appears to be enhanced by neighbors, and that species continua commonly observed along environmental gradients are the result of both negative and positive plant interactions.
Facilitation among plants as an insurance policy for diversity in Alpine communities
Functional Ecology, 2015
1. Positive interactions have started to gain a place as important drivers of community structure and biological diversity. Defined as non-trophic interspecific interactions that increase the average individual fitness of one species, by definition, the presence of one plant species enhances the chances that another species co-occur in the same place, indicating that positive interactions may determine biological diversity. However, this has been poorly explored. 2. The majority of the studies addressing community-level consequences of facilitation have compared the diversity of the plant assemblages growing within nurses vs. those growing outside them, reporting contrasting results among them. Nonetheless, nurses and their alternative microhabitats (open areas among nurses) are part of the same community. Thus, if nurses allow for the persistence of species that otherwise would be excluded from the community, a net increase in the species diversity at the entire community level will be generated even though nurse plants contained fewer species than open areas. 3. Here, we conducted a bibliographic search using the ISI Web of Knowledge data base and reviewed the literature conducted on alpine plant communities where assessments of the diversity of plants growing within and outside a nurse species were available. In most cases nurse species substantially increased species richness at the community level, despite the fact that in some cases, they contained lower species numbers than open areas. Nurse species enhanced species richness more in systems with impoverished local diversity, suggesting that facilitative interactions in alpine habitats act as an insurance policy that sustains diversity under very harsh conditions.
Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research, 2002
This study explores whether the high variability of vascular plant diversity among alpine plant communities can be explained by stress and/or disturbance intensities. Species numbers of 14 alpine plant communities were sampled in the Swiss Alps. To quantify the intensity of 13 stress and 6 disturbance factors potentially controlling plant life in these communities, a survey was conducted by asking numerous specialists in alpine vegetation to assess the importance of the different factors for each community. The estimated values were combined in stress-and disturbance-indices which were compared with diversity according to the Intermediate Stress Hypothesis, the Intermediate Disturbance Hypothesis, and the Dynamic Equilibrium Model, respectively. Each of these theories explained a part of the variability in the species richness, but only the Dynamic Equilibrium Model provided a complete and consistent explanation. The last model suggests that community species richness within the alpine life zone is generally controlled by stress intensity. Disturbance and competition seem to playa secondary role by fine-tuning diversity in specific communities. As diversity is primarily limited by stress, a moderation of temperature-related stress factors, as a result of global warming, may cause a shift of the equilibrium between stress, disturbance, and competition in alpine ecosystems.
Oikos, 2014
Th e determinants of local species richness in plant communities have been the subject of much debate. Is species richness the result of stochastic events such as dispersal processes, or do local environmental fi lters sort species into communities according to their ecological niches? Recent studies suggest that these two processes simultaneously limit species richness, although their relative importance may vary in space and time. Understanding the limiting factors for species richness is especially important in light of the ongoing global warming, as new species establish in resident plant communities as a result of climate-driven migration. We examined the relative importance of dispersal and environmental fi ltering during seedling recruitment and plant establishment in an alpine plant community subjected to seed addition and long-term experimental warming. Seed addition increased species richness during the seedling recruitment stage, but this initial increase was cancelled out by a corresponding decrease in species richness during plant establishment, suggesting that environmental fi lters limit local species richness in the long term. While initial recruitment success of the sown species was related to both abiotic and biotic factors, long-term establishment was controlled mainly by biotic factors, indicating an increase in the relative importance of biotic interactions once plants have germinated in a microhabitat with favourable abiotic conditions. Th e relative importance of biotic interactions also seemed to increase with experimental warming, suggesting that increased competition within the resident vegetation may decrease community invasibility as the climate warms.
New Phytologist, 2013
Facilitative interactions are defined as positive effects of one species on another, but bidirectional feedbacks may be positive, neutral, or negative. Understanding the bidirectional nature of these interactions is a fundamental prerequisite for the assessment of the potential evolutionary consequences of facilitation. In a global study combining observational and experimental approaches, we quantified the impact of the cover and richness of species associated with alpine cushion plants on reproductive traits of the benefactor cushions. We found a decline in cushion seed production with increasing cover of cushion-associated species, indicating that being a benefactor came at an overall cost. The effect of cushion-associated species was negative for flower density and seed set of cushions, but not for fruit set and seed quality. Richness of cushion-associated species had positive effects on seed density and modulated the effects of their abundance on flower density and fruit set, indicating that the costs and benefits of harboring associated species depend on the composition of the plant assemblage. Our study demonstrates 'parasitic' interactions among plants over a wide range of species and environments in alpine systems, and we consider their implications for the possible selective effects of interactions between benefactor and beneficiary species.
1. Positive interactions have started to gain a place as important drivers of community structure and biological diversity. Defined as non-trophic interspecific interactions that increase the average individual fitness of one species, by definition, the presence of one plant species enhances the chances that another species co-occur in the same place, indicating that positive interactions may determine biological diversity. However, this has been poorly explored. 2. The majority of the studies addressing community-level consequences of facilitation have compared the diversity of the plant assemblages growing within nurses vs. those growing outside them, reporting contrasting results among them. Nonetheless, nurses and their alternative microhabitats (open areas among nurses) are part of the same community. Thus, if nurses allow for the persistence of species that otherwise would be excluded from the community, a net increase in the species diversity at the entire community level will be generated even though nurse plants contained fewer species than open areas. 3. Here, we conducted a bibliographic search using the ISI Web of Knowledge data base and reviewed the literature conducted on alpine plant communities where assessments of the diversity of plants growing within and outside a nurse species were available. In most cases nurse species substantially increased species richness at the community level, despite the fact that in some cases, they contained lower species numbers than open areas. Nurse species enhanced species richness more in systems with impoverished local diversity, suggesting that facilitative interactions in alpine habitats act as an insurance policy that sustains diversity under very harsh conditions.