Towards a Critique of Corporate Governance Research (original) (raw)
Related papers
Advancing the Corporate Governance Research Agenda
Corporate Governance: An International Review, 2016
ENDNOTES 1. The institutional logics research claims that there exists a dominant logic defined as "socially constructed, historical patterns of material practices, assumptions, values, beliefs, and rules by which [organizations] produce and reproduce their material subsistence, organize time and space, and provide meaning to their social reality" (Thornton & Ocasio, 2008). 2. Recent studies that opted for a mixed-methods approach include Binacci,
2015
Abstract: The progression of theories or models of corporate governance, it is one of the new dimensions taken in a very crux of social ethics that is minimal and profit making took center stage. In this competitive world, companies are trying to inculcate the wisdom of good governance into their corporate organization. With the massive outpouring of capitalism, companies became stronger while governments around the globe had to accede to its influences and supremacy. However, this paper is a review of literature on the variety of theories in corporate governance. The ultimate theories in corporate governance started with the agency theory, extended into stewardship theory and stakeholder theory and evolved to resource dependency theory, political theory, legitimacy theory and social contract theory. However, these theories discourse the cause and consequence of variables, such as the formation of board structure, audit committee, independent non-executive directors and the duties o...
Corporate Governance: Its scope, concerns and theories
Corporate Governance, 1997
This paper outlines the conceptual, cultural, contextual and disciplinary scope of the rapidly evolving topic of corporate governance. As a basis for improving the rigour of research and analysis, some definitions are suggested. Reasons for the diversity of viewpoints and concerns are considered. To provide an orientation for new scholars and those from specialised disciplines, recent surveys of corporate governance are reviewed from their ethnocentric, contextual, and intellectual contingencies. The prospects of developing the topic as a "science of organization" are considered along with areas for future research.
Corporate Governance: An organisational attribute or an academic exercise
The Market, 2021
This conceptual paper provides an overview of the theory and application to the practice of corporate governance. The evolution of corporate governance theory and definitions are described, taking an international perspective. The paper offers insights at a national level into governance experiences within the UK, Ireland, and Cyprus. The paper reviews four classic corporate governance theories most often cited in the literature. Each theory is critically discussed and applied at an organisational level. The authors introduce language theory, sociology, psychology and organisational theory as a means of uncovering the changing governance epistemologies as corporate governance is more than economic and legal theories. A summary table outlining key foci, actors, features and critique of each model is provided so as to enable the reader easily identify each in practice. The paper concludes with recommendations for future research. Key terms: Corporate governance, board, behavioural theory, agency theory, stakeholder theory, resources dependency theory, stewardship theory, conceptual paper.
From pillars to new horizons in corporate governance research
Corporate governance: A search for emerging trends in the pandemic times, 2021
This international online conference ― Corporate Governance: A Search for Emerging Trends in the Pandemic Times held by the team and international scholarly network of Virtus Global Center for Corporate Governance is an excellent platform to present, discuss and share the most recent ideas in the corporate governance research. This conference is the third scholarly online forum held by the team of Virtus GCCR since May 2020. There are more than 20 accepted presentations from scholars from various countries of the world. Such sort of joint efforts of scholars is a bridge to the new horizons in corporate governance research, especially in the time of the pandemic
European Journal of Business and Management, 2016
Theories and philosophical approaches in research are crucial to the understanding of the overall perspective from which the study is designed and carried out. However, inconsistencies in theory and duality in philosophical paradigms leads to predicaments as to which approach is suitable in a certain area of inquiry. This paper examines some of the theoretical and philosophical predicaments faced by researchers in corporate governance. This is achieved by identifying and discussing controversies in theories and philosophical approaches applicable in corporate governance studies. A review of theoretical literature shows lack of a unitary perspective to explain the relationship between corporate governance and firm financial performance. Consequently, researchers may have to adopt a multi-theory approach by taking views of property rights agency, resource based and stewardship and stakeholder's theories to understand different perspectives of corporate governance. The multiplicity of theories and inconsistencies of expected relationships between variables also creates dilemma to researchers in predicting the relationships between corporate governance variables and firm performance. The duality of philosophical paradigms and divergent assumptions of ways of knowing also creates dilemma as to which is the best approach to apply in corporate governance research. This study found that most corporate governance studies opts for objectivism position in ontology which leads to positivism view in epistemology, associated with value free axiology, deductive approach and application of quantitative methods. This is in contrasts to the choice of subjectivism position in ontology which leads to the selection of interpretivism stance in epistemology and consequently value laden position in axiology. Subjective approach also leads to inductive approach and application of qualitative methods of data collection and analysis. It is therefore concluded that identification of ontology at the start of the research process is crucial in determining the choice of the research design.
Insight of Corporate Governance Theories
todayscience.org
The progression of theories or models of corporate governance, it is one of the new dimensions taken in a very crux of social ethics that is minimal and profit making took center stage. In this competitive world, companies are trying to inculcate the wisdom of good governance into their corporate organization. With the massive outpouring of capitalism, companies became stronger while governments around the globe had to accede to its influences and supremacy. However, this paper is a review of literature on the variety of theories in corporate governance. The ultimate theories in corporate governance started with the agency theory, extended into stewardship theory and stakeholder theory and evolved to resource dependency theory, political theory, legitimacy theory and social contract theory. However, these theories discourse the cause and consequence of variables, such as the formation of board structure, audit committee, independent non-executive directors and the duties of upper management and their organizational and social responsibilities rather than its regulatory structures. Similarly, it is proposed that a mixture of various theories is best to describe an effective and efficient good governance practice rather than hypothesizing corporate governance based on a sole theory.
Editorial: Emerging cross-disciplinary themes in corporate governance research
Corporate Board: Role, Duties and Composition
Corporate governance as a field is witnessing an intellectual evolution, where the traditional theoretical paradigms and the established research questions genuinely coexist with and are fruitfully stimulated by fresh lines of inquiry. This issue of Corporate Board: Role, Duties and Composition represents a striking example of such a theoretical and thematic integration at the intersection of multiple fields
The ambiguity and subjectivity of the corporate governance concept motivated the study to explore the understanding of corporate governance from a social reality perspective. Based on the nature of the study, where the subject matter is ambiguous, subjective and complex, social constructionist epistemology is appropriate. Social constructionist epistemology is suitable for the subjective dimension, where seeking the meaning of the subject matter is the objective. Relevant to the characteristic of social constructionist epistemology, interviews are used as the main primary data. Interviews were conducted among experts in corporate governance in Malaysia. The meaning of corporate governance is interpreted based on the text derived from the verbatim transcription of the interviews. Text is used as the main unit of analysis. The emergent themes from the analysis indicate that there is a new paradigm of understanding concerning the concept of corporate governance. The finding of this study revealed corporate governance as a social process that bring forth the meaning of a system that oriented towards economic objective, guided by value in guiding corporations towards proper conduct in order to achieve corporate sustainability. It is suggested that the concept of corporate governance needs modification, where the moral foundation of the corporate governance concept is required. The study offers a social constructionist perspective in seeking the meaning of corporate governance.