Rupturing illusionism: the bullet catch (original) (raw)

Abstract

In the Golden Age of stage conjuring, magicians performed various illusions 'which dismembered, disappeared or distorted human bodies'. A famous example is the notorious 'bullet catch'. The fact that a number of magicians were injured or killed performing it has become part of the publicity and mythology surrounding this illusion. Considering its inherent danger, spectators of the 'bullet catch' not only watch the staging of a shooting, respectively suicide, they are further implicitly aware of the persisting potentiality of witnessing a life-threatening or lethal accident during the show, such as the one that famously killed pseudo-Chinese magician Chung Ling Soo in 1918. Therefore, regarding illusions inspired by daredevilry and danger, the line between illusionism and reality is particularly thin. A simple false movement in a card trick will reveal the operations underlying the effect, just as a mishap during a grand illusion will bare (part of) the concealed mechanism working it. In these cases, glitches constitute a disruption of the performance's illusory character by realism. When a magician fails to catch a bullet, however, a hole in the veil of illusionism constitutes an incursion of the real that creates a drastic and violent emergency situation. With this in mind, what does the bullet catch reveal about the character of stage magic, specifically about illusions implying danger? In what way are these staged? After giving an overview of accidents and shootings in the Golden Age, this article analyzes the bullet catch in view of these questions and topoi.

Figures (2)

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (50)

  1. Jean Chavigny was the first to assume that Torrini never existed after failing to find any mention of him or de Grisy, his real name given by Robert-Houdin, anywhere outside of Robert-Houdin's writings (Chavigny 1946). See also Clarke (2001), 439; Christopher (1947), 42; Cook (2001), 188; Steinmeyer (2005a), 143; Wraxall (1860), iv.
  2. De Line's name's similarity to De Linsky, and his story being a mix of the shooting of De Linsky's wife and the account about Torrini's son given by Robert-Houdin, might indicate that he is a product of the forming of legends around the bullet catch.
  3. For indications of the contrary, see Cox 2011.
  4. A photograph of Adelaide Herrmann's bullet-catching costume is reprinted in Herrmann (2012), 201. On Alexander Herrmann's similar costume, see Steinmeyer (2005b), 157. The first female magician to perform the bullet catch seems to have been Annie Vernone, in 1857, aged 17; Dawes (1979), 173.
  5. There was one near-accident when, in one show, an amateur magician who had offered himself as a volunteer refused to fire at Anderson, realizing that there had been a mistake and the gun was actually loaded (Dawes 1979, 173-175).
  6. According to some accounts, it was De Linsky himself who shot his wife on stage (Clarke 2001, 180; Whaley 2007, 142). This incident might have inspired Robert-Houdin's account of Torrini shooting his son (Sharpe 1967, 88; Steinmeyer 2005b, 147).
  7. While Soo benefited from the publicity about the Boxer Rebellion at first, its negative connotations also posed some difficulties (Steinmeyer 2005b, 216-217, 251-252). On Orientalist magic, see Solomon (2008) ; Stahl (2008).
  8. References [la rédaction]. 1903. "Chung Ling Soo." L'Illusionniste Journal De Prestidigitateurs, Amateurs Et Professionnels 2 (14): 105-106.
  9. 'Inquest on Chung Ling Soo'. 1918. Performer. April 11.
  10. June 2017. "US Woman Shoots Boyfriend in YouTube Stunt." BBC News. Accessed 29 November 2017. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-40438207.
  11. Astley, Philip. 1785. Natural Magic: Or, Physical Amusements Revealed. London: self-published.
  12. Beard, Thomas, and Thomas Taylor. 1648. The Theatre of Gods Judgements: Wherein Is Represented the Admirable Justice of God against All Notorious Sinners, Great and Small, Specially against the Most Eminent Persons in the World, Whose Exorbitant Power Had Broke through the Barriers of Divine and Humane Law. 4th ed. London: S.I. & M.H. Burlingame, Hardin Jasper. 1895. History of Magic and Magicians. Chicago, IL: C. L. Burlingame.
  13. Campbell, Joseph. 2004. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
  14. Chavigny, Jean. 1946. Robert-Houdin: Rénovateur de la magie blanche. Blois, Wien: Lhermite.
  15. Christopher, Milbourne. 1947. "One Wizard's Wanderings." The Linking Ring 27 (1): 42, 91.
  16. Christopher, Milbourne. 1951. "Magic Letters." The Magic Circular: the Magazine of the Magic Circle 46 (506): 335-342.
  17. Christopher, Milbourne. 1973. The Illustrated History of Magic. New York, NY: Crowell.
  18. Clarke, Sidney Wrangel. 2001. The Annals of Conjuring: From the Earliest Times to the Present Day. Ed. by Edwin A. Dawes & Todd Karr, in association with Bob Read. Seattle, WA: Miracle Factory.
  19. Cook, James W. 2001. The Arts of Deception. Playing with Fraud in the Age of Barnum. Cambridge, MA, London: Harvard University Press.
  20. Cox, John. 2011. "Did Houdini Do the Bullet Catch in the 1890s?." Wild About Harry, March 12. Accessed 11 January 2018. http://www.wildabouthoudini.com/2011/03/did-houdini-do-bullet- catch-in-1890s.html
  21. Dawes, Edwin A. 1979. The Great Illusionists. Secaucus, NJ: Chartwell Books.
  22. de Chassanion, Jean. 1586. Histoires Mémorables des Grands et Merveilleux Jugemens et Punitions de Dieu. Geneva: Jean le Preux.
  23. Dexter, Will. 1955. The Riddle of Chung Ling Soo. London. New York, NY: Arco Publishers.
  24. During, Simon. 2002. Modern Enchantments: The Cultural Power of Secular Magic. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  25. Eliade, Mircea. 1975. Schamanismus und archaische Ekstasetechnik. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.
  26. Foley, Jack. 1988. "Magician Shot to Death: Audience Watches in Horror as Trick Show Ends in Tragedy." Weekly World News, February 9. doi:10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(88)79586-7.
  27. Gibson, Walter B. 1949. "Jinxiana." The Conjurors' Magazine 5 (5): 15-17.
  28. Grauerholz, James W. 2002. "The Death of Joan Vollmer Burroughs: What Really Happened?" Accessed 3 December 2017. http://traumawien.at/stuff/theory/burroughs/deathofjoan-full.pdf.
  29. Herrmann, Adelaide. 2012. Queen of Magic: Memoirs, Published Writings, Collected Ephemera. Ed. By Margaret Steele. Colchester: Bramble Books.
  30. Hoffmann, Professor, pseud. Angelo J. Lewis. 1877. Modern Magic: A Practical Treatise on the Art of Conjuring. 2nd ed. London, New York, NY: George Routledge and Sons.
  31. Jones, Graham M. 2010. "Modern Magic and the War on Miracles in French Colonial Culture." Comparative Studies in Society and History 52 (1): 66-99. doi:10.1017/S0010417509990338.
  32. Mangan, Michael. 2007. Performing Dark Arts. A Cultural History of Conjuring. Bristol, Chicago, IL: Intellect.
  33. Marco, Tony. 29 June, 2017. "Woman Fatally Shoots Boyfriend in YouTube Stunt" CNN. Accessed 29 November 2017. http://edition.cnn.com/2017/06/29/us/fatal-youtube-stunt /index.html.
  34. North, Dan. 2008. Performing Illusions: Cinema, Special Effects and the Virtual Actor. London. New York, NY: Wallflower Press.
  35. Pfaller, Robert. 2012. Zweite Welten und andere Lebenselixiere. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer.
  36. Price, David. 1985. Magic: A Pictorial History of Conjurers in the Theater. New York, NY, London, Toronto: Cornwall Books.
  37. Priest, Christopher. 1997. The Prestige. New York, NY: TOR.
  38. Ricky, Smith, and The Bullet Catch. "The Conjuring Arts Research Center." Accessed 6 December 2016. http://conjuringarts.org/exhibitions/the-bullet-catch/.
  39. Robert-Houdin, Jean Eugène. 1860. Memoirs of Robert-Houdin: Ambassador, Author, and Conjurer. 4th ed. Chapman & Hall: London.
  40. Robinson, Ben. 1986. Twelve Have Died: Bullet Catching -The Story and Secrets. Watertown, MA: Magic Art Book Company.
  41. Robinson, Ben. 2004. "A Brief History of Twelve Have Died." https://www.illusiongenius.com/ history-of-12-have-died. Accessed 2 December 2017.
  42. Robinson, Olive. 1918. Statement In: Coroner's Inquest on the Death of William Elsworth Robinson Aka Chung Ling Soo. London Metropolitan Archives.
  43. Sharpe, Sam H. 1967. "Salutations to Robert-Houdin: His Life Magic and Automata." The Linking Ring 47 (10): 24-27. 53-55.
  44. Snowden, Alan. 1988. "Backstage." The Magic Circular: The Magazine of the Magic Circle 82 (883): 25-29.
  45. Solomon, Matthew. 2008. "The "Chinese" Conjurer. Orientalist Magic in Variety Theater and the Trick Film." In Early Cinema and the 'National', edited by Richard Abel, Giorgio Bertellini, and Rob King, 248-257. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
  46. Stahl, Christopher. 2008. "Outdoing Ching Ling Foo." In Performing Magic on the Western Stage. From the Eighteenth Century to the Present, edited by Francesca Coppa, Lawrence Hass, and James Peck, 151-176. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
  47. Steinmeyer, Jim. 2005a. Hiding the Elephant: How Magicians Invented the Impossible. London: Arrow.
  48. Steinmeyer, Jim. 2005b. The Glorious Deception: The Double Life of William Robinson, Aka Chung Ling Soo the 'Marvelous Chinese Conjurer'. New York, NY: Carroll & Graf Publishers.
  49. Whaley, Bart. 2007. The Encyclopedic Dictionary of Magic 1584-2007. 3rd ed. Lybrary.com.
  50. Wraxall, Lascelles. 1860. "Translator's Preface." In Memoirs of Robert-Houdin: Ambassador, Author, and Conjurer, edited by Jean Eugène Robert-Houdin. 4th ed, 3-4. Chapman & Hall: London.