Conflicting visions: debates relating to Soviet Jewish emigration in the global arena (original) (raw)
In 1966, Soviet leader Alexei Kosygin stated that Soviet citizens had the right to emigrate for family reunification. This sparked the campaign for Soviet Jewish emigration movement, which adopted the slogan "Let My People Go." Yet, despite the biblical symbolism, there was a significant controversy about their final destination, with those opting for the West known as "drop-outs" (noshrim). There were intense debates between those Jewish Diaspora leaders, particularly in the United States, who stressed the democratic right of "freedom of choice," and the Israeli leadership. When the Soviets drastically reduced emigration in the 1980s, the drop-out phenomenon (neshira) was blamed. In 1983 Morris B. Abram became chairman of the National Conference on Soviet Jewry and reversed the accepted American Jewish approach. He developed a close friendship with Australian Jewish leader, Isi Leibler. Both men believed Soviet Jews should migrate to Israel. In the late 1980s, the United States ended the refugee status of Soviet Jews, reducing its financial support. As a result, one million Russians migrated to Israel in the 1990s. This article focuses on this global debate over neshira and illustrates the importance of cooperation between American and non-American actors in global Jewish politics.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
Related papers
"Let my People Go" – The beginnings of Israel's Operation to open Soviet Immigration Gates
The Soviet and Post Soviet Review, 2020
This article deals with the fate of Soviet Jews during the period between Stalin's death and the outbreak of the Sinai War (1956). It focuses on the attitudes of Israeli government circles, and specifically on their actions on the international arena oriented towards opening Soviet immigration to Israel (Aliyah) gates. The goal of Aliyah stood high on the agenda of Israeli decision makers. Nevertheless, up to the period under review, its treatment was limited to sporadic diplomatic contacts with Soviet authorities. Israel has also avoided exerting international pressure on Moscow on this issue. This situation changed fundamentally towards the end of 1955. We describe the chain of events that led to this transformation. In the background of Israeli and Soviet policy on Jewish themes stood major issues, such as the structure of Soviet society, relations with the West, and the internal political situation in Israel; these are not discussed here in depth but are important in understanding the events that unfolded. The article is based largely on documents from Israeli and Soviet archives, including those that have not yet been published. We also use Nativ organization documents, which are shown here for the first time. *
A Half Century of Jewish Emigration from the Former Soviet Union
2020
Based on collected data, it was guesstimated that since 1970 almost two million Jews and their relatives emigrated from the former Soviet Union (FSU). Most of this mass emigration occurred since 1989—about 1.7 million. The analysis clearly shows the decisive role of the push factor in the migration movements from the FSU. Pronounced selectivity of Jewish migration by age and sex was found. Also studied were the dramatic shrinkage in the size of the Jewish population remaining in the FSU and the resettlement of ex-Soviet Jews mainly in three destination countries—Israel, the USA, and Germany. The largest group went to Israel, and the positive demographic transformation of this group—a sizable increase of fertility and fast decrease of mortality—was analyzed.
From the Soviet Union to Israel: How the Post-Soviet Union Aliyah of the 1990s Shaped Israeli Polity
2019
Today, Russian Jews constitute approximately 15% of Israel’s population. Although a lot of them came to Israel to pursue the Zionist dream and to escape antisemitism, a majority of them came for better economic prospects that were not present in unstable post-Soviet Russia because of discrimination. Considering the timely overlap between the conservatization of Israelis and the arrival of Post-Soviet Jews, it is highly possible that a correlation between the two exists. Hence, this paper argues that the emigration of Russian Jews in the Post-Soviet Aliyah of the 1990s has contributed as a factor to the Israeli population’s movement towards the right-wing in two ways, one being internal and the other being external in relation to the Russian-Jewish immigrants. (1) Internally, conservative values, especially regarding the Palestine situation, held by the Russian Jews strengthened right-wing alliances and increased the population of the right-wing support base. (2) Externally, the overwhelming number of Soviet immigrants has caused Israel to reevaluate its immigration policy and take a more conservative approach while creating a discriminatory atmosphere filled with prejudices towards the Russian-Jews of the Post-Soviet Aliyah.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.