Media Pluralism Redux: Towards New Frameworks of Comparative Media Studies “Beyond the West” (original) (raw)
Related papers
Television News and Democratic Change in India
This article examines the impact of India’s ‘television news revolution’, or the rapid growth of privately owned television news channels, on substantive democracy, or the ability of ordinary citizens to access social, political, and economic power. Existing scholarship has largely relied upon content analysis (or textual interpretation) and reception studies to address this question. In contrast this article examines media practice, drawing upon ethnographic field research on the social and political worlds of television news production in contemporary India. Through a specific focus on the experiences of freelance stringers in the news industry, one main argument is advanced: television news expansion has had a ‘provincializing effect’ of enabling the social, political, and economic empowerment of small-town, non-metropolitan, or provincial actors. This finding nuances and unsettles the common conflation of television news media with the interests of the urban middle-class elite in India. At the same time however, a detailed exploration of the political dynamics and consequences of ‘provincialization’ cautions against its reading as empowerment, subversion, or resistance to extant patterns of power and privilege: practices and structures of exclusion and inequality persist within these newly mobile social worlds.
With annual revenues of about $17 billion in 2012, India is among the world’s top 15 global media and entertainment markets. While much attention has been focused in recent years on India’s rise as an emerging economy, its great-power potential as the world’s largest democracy and the future trajectory of its growth but the role of India’s burgeoning media industry in this wider story is much less understood. For a country with the world’s largest newspaper market, second largest telecommunications market, third largest television market and second largest Facebook community, the virtual absence of India from most mainstream global communications studies within academia is strange. In revenue terms, India’s share of the global media sector still remains small but within the top 15 media and entertainment economies, only India has had consistent over-15% growth rates for years. Yet, outside of India, within the wider ambit of policy and international relations, few understand the crucial role Indian media play in the ebbs and flows of Indian politics and how central it is to India’s boisterous democracy. This essay concentrates on Indian television and its future directions. Combined with the rise of the other device that has grown faster than toilets in India -- the mobile phone – television has fundamentally reshaped Indian democracy and emerged as a critical social lever. This essay outlines ownership patterns in Indian television, the divergences and commonalities across regional languages and what this means for India’s democracy.
Indian Media System: An Application of Comparative Media Approach
2016
India is the largest democracy of the world with a vibrant mediascape and there is a complicated relationship between Indian media and political systems. Using the approach of comparative media analysis and available literature, this study analyses Indian media on the dimensions of media and political systems developed by Hallin and Mancini (2004) in their book Comparing Media Systems. Indian political system is characterized by "clientelism" and "polarized pluralism" thus yielding high "political parallelism" and "instrumentalisation" of media at the hands of political and corporate elites. Commercialization of media has ensued weak professionalism among journalists and media organizations. However, Indian media may have a promising future because of early development of democracy and minimum state intervention. Indian media carries the features of all three media models proposed by Hallin and Mancini. Though, analysis reveals that Indian media system is dominantly closer to Liberal model of North Atlantic countries.
STATE OF DEMOCRACY IN INDIA : ROLE OF MEDIA
For a functional liberal democratic state, active and vigilant participation of the free press is essential. The media provides information necessary for rational debate. The media can be studied as an institution and analyses of its work can be important for understanding the health and state of liberal democracies. The media is generally considered the fourth pillar of democracy. However, over the years the control of media by giant corporate enterprises has seriously compromised its basic principles. The present paper is an attempt to understand the working of media in contemporary times with special reference to India.
THE MEDIA IN INDIA: AN ANALYSIS ON ACTORS AND THEIR ROLES IN POLITICS
2021
Media holds a very significant role in liberal democratic regimes. Media actors influence the way social and political events are seen and evaluated. Free and plural media is the safeguard of a healthy democracy. Media has critical functions in a democratic regime. Journalism serves functions such as giving information, making investigation, and providing society a public forum. The main objective of this article is to seek answers to the questions of "how can the media profile and ownership in India be described" and "what is the nature of the relationship between media and politics in India". India has a developing media scene with thousands of outlets in multiple languages. Media in the country has been subjected to a structural change in recent years. India has a multi-party parliamentary democracy and media-as in other democracies-has a key role for Indian politics.
Indian Media in Global Context
There is a curious partitioning of media histories of the west from those of other countries. The kind of comparative analysis that would be expected with a set of global technologies and practices is lacking. Although communications media were promoted as a technology of nation building by western powers and received as such by countries such as India, strangely, there is a wide gap between the rhetoric of globality and the literature pertaining to local and national uses of media technologies. My essay situates the history of post-independence media growth in India within this gap, in a preliminary attempt to bridge it.
Freedom of media and politics in India: The truth or a façade?
2021
Free press and media can be defined as tools provided to media organizations which are not controlled or restricted by government censorship in political or ideological matters. The Constitution of India provides freedom to the press so that they can express and criticize the government as well as their actions in a balanced manner. While the exact definition is variable, politics can be generally defined as a component of a nation, structured in a hierarchical order, with a responsibility to govern and ensure the well-being of the citizens. The main objective of the paper is to investigate the relationship between Media and politics and the impact they have on each other. In total, 208 people were received and were used for the final analysis and to explore the current sociopolitical scenario in the country due to the lockdown imposed during AprilMay, 2021. The sample size satisfies the requirements for the result analysis The random sampling method was used to establish a link bet...
Media Contouring the Societal Functioning:A Study of Indian Democracy
Media Watch, 2018
A participative and representative democracy like that of India cannot deny media's significant role in strengthening its democratic fabric. However, while media has offered a huge platform for creating awareness, educating and sensitising people, the quality of knowledge disseminated, the kind of awareness created, the way of connecting with the masses as also, the content flashed and the intention behind it are clouded with dubiousness. This paper proposed to conduct a qualitative study into analysing the role and performance of media towards nurturing democratic principles in Indian context through narrative analysis of certain instances picked deliberately for the purpose; and suggested certain measures for enhancing the effectiveness of media in this context. The paper reaffirmed media in the country, contrary to the expected role, to be biased, indulging in blatant fabrication of news, manipulating facts and spreading propaganda, hence fast losing its credibility, integrity and sanctity under the garb of reinforcing democracy.
Is Indian Media Free from State Control? An Appraisal
Policy Perspectives, 2019
This paper argues that Indian media is state-controlled and biased in its reporting. It has become a tool in the hands of Indian government for spreading Hindutva agenda and jingoistic sentiments in people, consequently giving rise to communal riots. The paper also draws attention to the phenomenon of paid news and fake news. It discusses the increasing incidents of corruption in the Indian media industry, also highlighted by the Press Council of India (PCI). Citing some specific examples, the study contends that those media channels and journalists who refuse to toe government's line face reprisals. The paper also analyzes the coverage of Indian media vis-à-vis revocation of article 370 and 35 A of the Indian constitution; most media outlets in India described situation in the Occupied Valley as ‘normal’ and Kashmiris to be ‘happy’ which could not be more far from reality.