Police Stop and Search Powers: Understanding the Adversarial Nature of Contact Between PSNI and the Public (original) (raw)

Abstract

As an initial point of comparison, Northern Ireland possesses almost identical stop and search powers and Codes of Practice to those of England and Wales in terms of the Police and Crime Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1989 (PACE) and the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 (MDA) (c.f. Dickson, 2013). In turn, the volume, proportionality and arrest rates related to stop and search are therefore legitimate points of analysis (Scotland is of course governed by yet another legal framework, rendering such comparisons slightly more difficult). However, while in England and Wales almost all (currently over 99%) stops/searches are conducted under 'normal', PACE-type powers, in Northern Ireland only 70% of stops are carried out under such everyday powers (Hargreaves et al., 2017; PSNI, 2017b). The remaining 30% are conducted under the Terrorism Act 2000 and the Northern Ireland-only Justice and Security (Northern Ireland) Act 2007 (JSA). While the use of terrorist-related powers comprises a stark contrast with England and Wales (Hargreaves et al., 2017), it is not the intention to meld the analysis of terrorist and 'normal' (PACE-type) stop and search powers into a single and potentially muddled profile. Rather, this policy brief focuses deliberately upon 'ordinary' stop and search powers used by PSNI precisely because it is those powers which have (arguably) failed to come under the purview of the police (or public) oversight in the country. In stark contrast to the voluminous research dedicated to counter-terrorist powers utilised during the conflict and post-conflict periods of the jurisdiction (c.f. Hillyard, 1988; 1994; McGovern and Tobin, 2010; McVeigh, 1994; Seymour, 2017), it is precisely the absence of policy or academic attention directed at PACE-type stop and search which merits further investigation. This relative invisibility has, in a way both like and unlike the situation in Scotland before the groundbreaking research of Murray (2014b), persisted in the face of evidence of a recurrent problem with the use of stop and search in Northern Ireland. Not once has the power been referenced in the past decade of policing plans set forth by the Northern Ireland Policing Board (NIPB). But over the same period (2004/5-2015/16) use of stop and search in Northern Ireland increased by 74%, and it is now used here at a significantly higher rate than in England and Wales or Scotland (Bradford, 2017; Hargreaves, Husband and Linehan, 2017; PSNI, 2017b; Murray and Harkin, 2017). Consideration of such 'ordinary' stop and search powers by PSNI can usefully start with the 'importation' of PACE into Northern Ireland. While the political, civil and cultural context in the country in 1989 bore little resemblance to that in England and Wales, the underpinning police organisational 'currency' of stop and search in terms of its efficacy has remained as a remarkable constant over the years (Bradford & Loader, 2016). The PSNI still adhere to the inherently 'deterrent' notion of PACE-type powers to stop and search citizens (in spite of its technically investigative basis), where the power is construed as a multipurpose tool to respond to almost any 'street-level' criminogenic circumstance (Bradford, 2017). Further tying notions of stop and search to general purpose, PSNI also link the power to their indeterminate duties and police powers set out in section 32 of the Police (Northern Ireland) Act 2000 centred on protecting life and property; preserving order; and

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (37)

  1. References -Ariza, J.J.M. 2014. Police initiated contacts: young people, ethnicity, and the 'usual suspects'. Policing and Society 24(2): 208-223 -Atikenhead, D. 2018. 'David Lammy: Kids are getting killed. Where is the Prime Minister? Where is Sidq Khan?, The Guardian 6 th April. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/apr/06/david-lammy-kids-are-getting-killed-where-is-the-prime-minister-where-is-sadiq-khan -Black, D., 1998. The social structure of right and wrong. San Diego: Academic Press.
  2. -Bowling, B. and Marks, E., 2015. Towards a transnational and comparative approach, in R. Delsol and M. Shiner (eds.) Stop and search: the anatomy of a police power. Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.
  3. -Bowling, B. and Phillips, C., 2007. Disproportionate and discriminatory: reviewing the evidence on police stop and search. Modern law review, 70 (6), 936-961.
  4. -Bradford, B., 2015. Assessing the impact of stop and search powers on individuals and communities, in R. Delsol and M. Shiner (eds.) Stop and search: the anatomy of a police powers. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
  5. -Bradford, B., 2017. Stop and search and policing legitimacy. Abingdon: Oxon: Routledge.
  6. -Bradford, B. and Loader, I., 2016. Police, crime and order: the case of stop and search', in B. Bradford, B. Jaurengi, I. Loader and J. Steinberg (eds.) The SAGE handbook of global policing. London: Sage Publications.\ -Brewer, J., 2001. The growth, extent and causes of crime: Northern Ireland. In: M. Shaw, ed. Crime and policing in transitional societies seminar report. Johannesburg, South Africa: KAS, 103-110.
  7. -Byrne, J., Jarman, N. and Topping, J., 2013. Community perspectives on public order policing. Ulster University / Institute for Conflict Research. Unpublished research report, commissioned by Police Service of Northern Ireland.
  8. -Campbell, C., 2017. PSNI search thousands of under-18s, but few arrests made. The Irish Times, 29 th March, available at: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/psni-searches-thousands-of-under-18s-but-few-arrests-made-1.3028818 -Child Poverty Alliance, 2014. Beneath the surface: child poverty in Northern Ireland. Available at: http://www.ci- ni.org.uk/DatabaseDocs/nav_991889__cpa_presentation.pdf -Committee on the Administration of Justice, 2012. Still part of life here? A report on the use and misuse of stop and search / question powers in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Committee on the Administration of Justice.
  9. -Delsol, R. and Shiner, M. 2015 (eds.) Stop and search: the anatomy of a police powers. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
  10. -DHSSPS, 2015. Delivering excellence, achieving recovery: a professional framework for the mental health nursing profession. Belfast: DHSSPS. -Dickson, B., 2013. Law in Northern Ireland (2 nd ed.). Oxford: Hart Publishing -Ellison, G., 2007. A Blueprint for Democratic Policing anywhere in the world: police reform, political transition, and conflict resolution in Northern Ireland. Police quarterly, 10 (3), 243-269.
  11. -Flacks, S. (2017). The stop and search of minors: a 'vital police tool'?. Criminology and Criminal Justice, published 12 th July, available at:http://dx.doi.org/10.1177%2F1748895817720485
  12. -Garland, D., 2001. The culture of control: crime and social order in contemporary society. Oxford University Press.
  13. -Hall, S., Critcher, C., Jefferson, T., Clarke, J., and Roberts, B., 1978. Policing the crisis: mugging, the state and law and order. London and Basingstoke: The Macmillan Press ltd -Hamilton, J., Radford, K., and Jarman, N., 2003. Policing, accountability and young people. Belfast: Institute for Conflict Research. Available at:http://conflictresearch.org.uk/reports/policing/NIPB-PONI-Young-People-April-2003.pdf -Harcourt, B., 2004. Rethinking race profiling: a critique of the economics, civil liberties, and constitutional literature, and of criminal profiling more generally. The University of Chicago law review. 71 (4), 1329-1330.
  14. -Hargreaves, J., Husband, H. and Linehan, C. 2017. Police powers and procedures, England and Wales, year ending 31 st March 2017. London: Home Office, available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment\_data/file/658099/police-powers-procedures-mar17- hosb2017.pdf -Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary, 2013. Stop and search powers: are the police using them effectively and fairly?. London: HMIC, available at: https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/media/stop-and-search-powers-20130709.pdf -Hillyard, P. (1988) 'Political and Social Dimensions of Emergency Law in Northern Ireland', in A. Jennings (ed.) Justice Under Fire: The Abuse of Civil Liberties in Northern Ireland. London: Pluto Press -Hillyard, P. (1994) 'Irish People and the British Justice System', Journal of Law and Society 21, pp.39-56 -Home Office Select Committee, 2007. Young black people and the criminal justice system. London: House of Commons. -Keeling, P., 2017. No respect: young BAME men, the police and stop and search. Criminal justice alliance, available at: https://www.barrowcadbury.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/No-Respect-CJA-June-2017.pdf -Lennon, G. and Murray, K., 2016. Under-regulated and unaccountable? Explaining variations in stop and search rates in Scotland, England and Wales. Policing and society, DOI: 10.1080/10439463.2016.1163359 -Loader, I., 1996. Youth, policing and democracy.
  15. -McAlister, S., Scraton, P., and Haydon, D., 2011. Place, territory and young people's identity in the 'new' Northern Ireland, in B. Goldstein (ed.) Youth in crisis? Gangs, territoriality and violence. Abington: Routledge, 89-109.
  16. -McAlister, S., Scraton, P., and Haydon, D., 2009. Childhood in transition: experiencing marginalisation and conflict in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Queen's University Belfast / Save the Children / Prince's Trust.
  17. -McAra, L. and McVie., S., 2005. The usual suspects? Street-life, young people and the police. Criminal justice, 5 (1), 5-36.
  18. -McCandless, R., Feist, A., Allan, J. and Morgan, N. 2016. Do initiatives involving substantial increases in stop and search reduce crime? Assessing the impact of operation BLUNT 2. London: Home Office.
  19. -McDonald, H., 2017. Belfast officer injured in drive-by shooting. The Guardian, 22 nd January, available at: https://www.theguardian.com/uk- news/2017/jan/22/belfast-police-officer-injured-in-terrorist-shooting -McGovern, M. and Tobin, A. (2010) Countering Terror or Counter-Productive: Comparing Irish and British Muslim Experiences of Counter-Insurgency Law and Policy. Report of a Symposium, Belfast/Edge Hill University.
  20. -McPherson, W., 1999. The Stephen Lawrence inquiry: report of an inquiry by Sir William McPherson of Cluny. Cm. 4262-I.
  21. -McVeigh, R., 1994. 'It's part of life here': The security forces and harassment in Northern Ireland. Belfast: CAJ -Mulcahy, A., 2006. Policing in Northern Ireland: conflict, legitimacy and reform. Devon: Willan Publishing.
  22. -Murray, K., 2014a. Stop and search in Scotland: an evaluation of police practice. SSCJR Report 01/2014: Scottish Centre for Crime and Justice Research, available at: http://www.sccjr.ac.uk/publications/stop-and-search-in-scotland-an-evaluation-of-police-practice/ -Murray, K., 2014b. The practice turn: stop and search in Scotland (a study in elite power). PhD thesis, Edinburgh University.
  23. -Murray, K., 2016. Understanding and preventing youth crime survey (UPYC) early findings stop and search in Glasgow and Edinburgh. The University of Edinburgh. Available at: http://www.spa.police.uk/assets/128635/352708/uypcstopandsearch -Murray, K., 2017. The modern making of stop and search: the rise of preventative sensibilities in post-war Britain. British journal of criminology, published 23 rd June, available at: https://doi.org/10.1093/bjc/azx030
  24. -Murray, K. and Harkin, D., 2017. Policing in cool and hot climates: legitimacy, power and the rise and fall of mass stop and search in Scotland. British journal of criminology, 57, 885-905
  25. -Nelson, E., McBride, R., O'Riordan, O. and Smyth, P., 2010. Beyond the margins: building trust in policing with young people. Belfast: Institute for Conflict Research. Available at: http://conflictresearch.org.uk/reports/policing/Beyond-the-Margins-Building-Trust-in-Policing-With-Young-People.pdf -Northern Ireland Policing Board, 2013. Human rights thematic review: policing with children and young people. Update on PSNI Implementation of recommendations. Belfast: NIPB. Available at: https://www.nipolicingboard.org.uk/sites/nipb/files/media-files/human-rights-thematic-review-policing-with-children.pdf -Northern Ireland Policing Board (2017) Public perceptions of the police, the PCSPs and the Northern Ireland Policing Board. Belfast: NIPB. Available at: https://www.nipolicingboard.org.uk/sites/nipb/files/media-files/omnibus-survey-april-2017.pdf Northern Ireland Policing Board / Institute for Conflict Research, 2005. Young people's attitudes and experiences of policing, violence and community safety in north Belfast. Belfast: Institute for Conflict Research. Available at: http://conflictresearch.org.uk/reports/young-people/NIPB-North-Belfast-Youth-Survey.pdf -Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency 2012. Census 2011 key statistics for Northern Ireland. Belfast: NISRA, available at: https://www.nisra.gov.uk/sites/nisra.gov.uk/files/publications/2011-census-results-key-statistics-northern-ireland-report-11-december-2012.pdf -Penzer, J. 1999 Reported crime and PACE stop and search activity: An investigation of the possible relationship. (Unpublished paper). -Police Service of Northern Ireland (2017a) Advice and Information: Stop and Search. Available at: https://www.psni.police.uk/advice\_information/stop- and-search/ -Police Service of Northern Ireland (2017b). Stop and search statistics financial year 2016/17, available at: https://www.psni.police.uk/globalassets/inside-the-psni/our-statistics/stop-and-search-statistics/2016/march/2016-17-fy-stop-and-search-report-official--- public.pdf -Police Service of Northern Ireland (2017c). SI0817 Youth justice. Available at: https://www.psni.police.uk/globalassets/advice--information/our-publications/policies-and-service-procedures/youth-justice---external-120517.pdf -Police Scotland 2017. Stop and search data publication. Available at: http://www.scotland.police.uk/about-us/police-scotland/stop-and-search/stop-and-search-data-publication/ -Quinton, P., Tiratelli, M. and Bradford, B., 2017. Does more stop and search mean less crime? Analysis of Metropolitan Police Service panel data 2004 -2014. College of Policing, available at: http://whatworks.college.police.uk/Research/Documents/SS\_and\_crime\_report.pdf -Roche, R., 2005. 'Something to say': the complete TRIPROJECT report on the view of young school leavers in the Derry City council district areas. Belfast: Blackstaff.
  26. -Rosenfeld, R. and Fornango, R. 2014. The impact of police stops on precinct robbery and burglary rates in New York City, 2003-2010. Justice Quarterly 31(1): 6-122 -Seymour, D., 2017. Report of the independent reviewer: Justice and security (Northern Ireland) Act 2007 9 th report: 1 st August. London: HMSO -Shirlow, P. and Murtagh, B., 2006. Belfast: segregation, violence and the city. London: Pluto Press.
  27. -Smith, D., Purtell, R. and Guerrero, S. (2012) Is stop, question and frisk an effective tool in the fight against crime? Paper presented at the Annual Research Conference of the Association of Public Policy and Management: Baltimore, Maryland, USA. -The Detail TV, 2017. PSNI urged to reconsider use of stop and search on under-18s. Available at: http://www.thedetail.tv/articles/psni-urged-to- reconsider-use-of-stop-and-search-on-children -Tiratelli, M., Quinton, P. and Bradford, B. 2018. Does stop and search deter crime? Evidence from ten years of London-wide data, The British Journal of Criminology, , azx085, https://doi.org/10.1093/bjc/azx085
  28. -Topping, J.R., 2008a. Community policing in Northern Ireland: a resistance narrative. Policing and society, 18 (4), 377-398.
  29. -Topping, J.R., 2008b. Diversifying from within: community policing and the governance of security in Northern Ireland. British journal of criminology, 48 (6), 778-797.
  30. -Topping, J.R. and Byrne, J. (2012b). 'Policing, Terrorism and the Conundrum of Community: A Northern Ireland Perspective', in B. Spalek, Counter- terrorism: Community-based Approaches to Terror Crime, 157--180. Basingstoke.
  31. -Topping, J. R. 2015. 'Policing in Transition', in C. Dwyer and A. McAlinden (eds.) Criminal Justice in Transition: The Northern Ireland Context. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 109--130.
  32. -Topping, J. R. (2016). 'Accountability, Policing and the PSNI: Leading Globally, Limited Locally?', in Lister, S. and Rowe, M. (eds.) Accountability and Policing, 150--171. Oxon.
  33. -Topping, J. R. 2017. 'What's wrong with children? Stop and search as a barometer of young people's treatment in a post-conflict landscape', presented at the European Society of Criminology, Cardiff 13 th -16 th September.
  34. -Travis, A., 2014. Teresa May announces reform of police stop-and-search powers. The Guardian 30 th April, available at: https://www.theguardian.com/law/2014/apr/30/theresa-may-reform-police-stop-and-search-powers -Ward, L., Nicholas, S. and Willoughby, M., 2011. An assessment of the Tackling Knives and Serious Youth Violence Action Programme (TKAP) -phase II. Research Report 53. London: Home Office.
  35. -Weber, L. and Bowling, B. 2008. Valiant beggars and global vagabonds: Select, eject, immobilise. Theoretical Criminology 12(3), 355-375 -Weisburd, D., Wooditch, A., Weisburd, T. and Yang, S-M. 2015. Do stop, question and frisk practices deter crime? Evidence from microunits of space and time. Criminology and Public Policy 15(1):31-56
  36. -Wiley, S. A. and Esbeusen, F. A., 2016. The effect of police contact: does official intervention result in deviance amplification? Crime and delinquency, 62 (3), 283-307
  37. Wilson, R., 2016. Northern Ireland Peace Monitoring Report Number Four. Belfast: Community Relations Council.