Kurniawati Hastuti Dewi. Indonesian Women and Local Politics: Islam, Gender and Networks in Post-Suharto Indonesia. Singapore: NUS Press in association with Kyoto: Kyoto University Press, 2015, xxi+246p (original) (raw)
Related papers
This paper examines the constitutional court’s verdict by annulling article 214 that in turn decides majority votes under open list Proportional Representation (PR) system for elected members of the House Representative in the 2009 Legislative election. It is important to note that Indonesia experiences implementing closed list Proportional Representation (PR) electoral system for many years particularly under new order regime. Closed list system enables the candidates who were on the top list of being elected. However, due to the demand to support democracy, open list Proportional Representation is currently introduced by Indonesian government through the implementation of Constitutional Court’s decree. Thus, Laws on legislative election which previously used sequence numbers are not longer used because it is not in accordance with the spirit of popular sovereignty which is embodied in the basic Acts of 1945. Despite to support democracy, Constitutional Court’s decision becomes a controversial problem. The study shows that the constitutional court’s decree seems to be contradicted with the objective of affirmative action. Affirmative action is one of ways to increase women’s political representation which can be carried out through such methods as quota, zipper system and so forth. As a result, it is indeed very hard for women to take part in political arena as they have to plainly compete with men while at the same time they are disadvantaged by some factor such as lack of money, network and having double responsibilities. The study demonstrates that even though some positive aspect of verdict are seemingly rewarding, this does not necessarily give any benefits for women. Taking these into account, to increase women political representation, there are at least two strategies. First, women should join both formal and non formal course. These agenda are important to improve women’s capacity. Second, women should make networks by engaging in social organizations in order to get support from grass-roots level on the one hand, and they will have better understanding about society’s problems on the other. Keywords: Constitutional Court, women, politics, representation, Indonesia
The Emergence of Female Politicians in Local Politics in Post-Suharto Indonesia
Journal of Indonesian Social Sciences and Humanities
This dissertation addresses factors behind the rise and victory of Javanese Muslim women political leaders in direct elections since 2005, in post-Suharto Indonesia. By using gender perspectives to examine political phenomenon, it reveals that that the role of Islam, gender, and networks are decisive to their political victory. The Islamic belief on female leadership at the local level, provides a strong religious foundation for Javanese Muslim women politicians to assume political leadership. Ability to use their gender in combination with the idea and practice of Islamic piety, and to use religio-political support and male/female base networks in political campaign, is signifcant. This fndings indicates that important social changes has occurred in postSuharto Indonesia in where more Muslim women continue to take political leadership role beginning in local politics and gradually rising to national politics. In broader scope, this dissertation signifes that a new trend of Muslim w...
Women’s Political Representation in Indonesia: Who Wins and How?
Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs, 2021
This article analyses barriers to women’s political representation in Indonesia and the ways that women candidates overcome them. Surveying the literature and drawing on three data sources – findings of thirteen teams of researchers studying women candidates running in the 2019 election, a survey of 127 such candidates, and a nationally representative survey of Indonesian citizens – the article identifies widespread patriarchal attitudes as one significant barrier, alongside structural disadvantages. It highlights two distinctive methods by which women candidates aim to overcome these barriers: one group of candidates target women voters and draw on women’s networks to mobilise what has been called “homosocial capital”; another group of dynastic candidates rely on the political and financial resources of (often male) relatives. The article briefly surveys the place of political Islam in both impeding and facilitating women’s representation. By surveying these issues, the article int...
Challenges Faced by Women Legislators in Indonesia: A Case Study from Cirebon, West Java1
Women's representation in Indonesian politics has entered a new era following the introduction of affirmative action policy through the 2002 Political Party Law and the 2003 Electoral Law which was then expanded and strengthened in the 2008 Electoral Law. The said laws have the potential to improve women's representation in the political sphere by stipulating that each participating political party must include at least 30 per cent (30%) women in its candidate list. Without a doubt, this affirmative action policy in the form of a gender quota system has brought new hopes for Indonesian women to be meaningfully involved in Indonesia's political processes. Nevertheless, empirical evidence shows that this is not always the case. Indonesian women have faced significant resistance and challenges not only when they tried to run for election, but also when they performed as legislators in their respective legislative institutions. How can this phenomenon be explained? What sort of resistance and challenges have they faced? How do they cope with such resistance and challenges? This paper tries to answer these questions by specifically discussing a case study of women legislators in local representative assemblies (DPRD) in Cirebon, West Java, Indonesia.
Challenges Faced by Women Legislators in Indonesia : A Case Study from Cirebon , West Java
2014
Women's representation in Indonesian politics has entered a new era following the introduction of affirmative action policy through the 2002 Political Party Law and the 2003 Electoral Law which was then expanded and strengthened in the 2008 Electoral Law. The said laws have the potential to improve women's representation in the political sphere by stipulating that each participating political party must include at least 30 per cent (30%) women in its candidate list. Without a doubt, this affirmative action policy in the form of a gender quota system has brought new hopes for Indonesian women to be meaningfully involved in Indonesia’s political processes. Nevertheless, empirical evidence shows that this is not always the case. Indonesian women have faced significant resistance and challenges not only when they tried to run for election, but also when they performed as legislators in their respective legislative institutions. How can this phenomenon be explained? What sort of ...
Democracy and Continuing Marginalization of Women in Indonesian Politics
E3S Web of Conferences, 2018
Although much progress and efforts have been made to increase women’s participation in politics, the main idea of women’s involvement in politics has not yet penetrated into the mainstream of Indonesian politics. The main idea is not only a representation of the number of female population but also the representation that will bring new norms for Indonesian politics that has been so far dominated by the assumption of masculinity based on power politics and struggle to control resources by one party for the loss of others. This paper seeks to see how this marginalization of women continues to occur. One of the reasons for this cannot be separated from the waning of the reform spirit that inspired the reformation. Slowly but surely Indonesian politics is re-defined in term of power struggles by all means including by corruption, collusion, and nepotism that was once the object of criticism of reform groups. In this context, it is often the case that if women want to succeed in politic...
Challenges to Equal Representation: Female Deputies in the Indonesian National Parliament
2019
This dissertation investigates challenges in achieving equal representation in the national parliament in Indonesia where a legislated candidate gender quota has been adopted since 2003. It examines the world's largest Muslim democracy as a case study by observing (1) the trends and challenges in women's political nomination, and (2) attitudes toward female politicians and gender quotas. This study contributes to key academic literature on gender quotas and women's political representation. It finds that women's electability into parliament cannot be automatically improved by the provision of gender quotas targeting the process of nominating women. It argues Islamic ideology plays no obvious role in limiting female participation in legislative elections, as Islamist and pluralist parties do a similarly good job at recruiting females and a similarly bad job at putting them first on the list. The study also suggests the open-list PR system is prohibitively expensive and it hurts women candidates more than it does male aspirants because women generally have less access to financial resources. This research delves into not only what hinders women in winning elective office, but also which women win and what happens once they get into parliament. Incumbency, age, and list position are factors that have statistical significance in predicting women's electability. Furthermore, women have been assigned to feminine and low-prestige committees more than to masculine and high-prestige committees. The dissertation employs a multi-method approach, conducting both quantitative and qualitative analysis. I draw on in-depth interviews with v legislators, party leaders, and voters to analyse the election outcomes from 1999-2014. I also used a dataset on 47 Asian countries in establishing a comparative perspective on women's parliamentary representation. vi Dedication This thesis is dedicated to my parents, who have loved and supported me. I also dedicate this work to my lovely husband, Malikus Widyatama. This would be an excellent achievement which marks our tenth wedding anniversary! I also wish my journey will inspire our two gorgeous children, Safiyya and Aqila, to pursue higher education and to shape the world to become a better place for everyone. vii Acknowledgements Did We not expand for you, [O Muhammad], your beast? And We removed from you your burden, Which had weighed upon your back, And raised high for you your repute. For indeed, with hardship [will be] ease. Indeed, with hardship [will be] ease. So when you have finished [your duties], then stand up [for worship]. And to your Lord direct [your] longing. (Al-Qur'an Chapter 94: Ash-Sharh [The Relief]) My first and my foremost praise is due to Allah, The All Mighty. As every time I experience difficulties, I can only consult with Allah and cite my favourite chapter in the Qur'an; "The Relief". And thus "For indeed, with hardship [will be] ease. Indeed, with hardship [will be] ease" has been my mantra in embracing the fouryear process of writing this dissertation. This thesis would not have been possible without the help and support from a great number of people. I would like to thank my supervisors Professor Graham Brown and Professor Samina Yasmeen for their assistance and encouragement which allowed me to write and to finish this research. I enjoyed our meetings and discussions about Indonesian politics and women in Islam.
POLITICALLY EQUAL BUT STILL UNDERREPRESENTED: WOMEN AND LOCAL DEMOCRATIC POLITICS IN INDONESIA
This research challenges the relevance of a change towards liberal democracy for gender equality. In particular, it connects the political logic of the survival and failure of incumbents in the direct election for local leaders (pilkada) with the acceptance of gender related considerations in local policies and women preferences in voting. By carrying out comparative assessments concerning the pilkada in four rural and urban districts in East Java, the study reveals that local democracy does not provide incentives which encourage the incumbents who run in re-election bids to promote better gendered policies during their terms in office due to women's ignorance in voting. Female voters were less critical in reviewing the incumbents' performance. Women were too busy receiving tangible policy outputs; they paid inadequate attention to the importance of strategic gender interests. Consequently, incumbents who perform better in reducing gender disparity often lose their posts. Worse, during local democratic contests, women were marginalised by the practices of male-dominated informal politics amongst the incumbents, informal actors and partisan bureaucrats. Also, the pilkada is not an easy race for women's candidacy, as the regulations do not affirm women and political parties hinge on pragmatic considerations that favour male candidates as having a better chance of winning in election. Moreover, this study challenges the arguments of decentralisation policy that have led to the negligence of local government concerning a gender-mainstreaming agenda. In fact, the decentralisation regulatory regime overwhelmingly controlled by the national government has restricted local governments from better addressing gender strategic needs. The national authority strictly determines local expenditure items, which do not incorporate gender mainstreaming approaches in local budgeting.