A Study of the Impact of Culture on Trust Determinants in eCommerce: A Cross-culture Comparison Study (original) (raw)
Related papers
On the Need to Include National Culture as a Central Issue in E-Commerce Trust Beliefs
2006
Trust and trust beliefs (trustworthiness) are key to e-commerce success but depend, to a large extent, on culture. With e-commerce being an international phenomenon, understanding the cross-cultural aspects of trust creation is therefore arguably required although mostly ignored by current research which deals almost exclusively with the U.S. This exploratory study examines whether definitions of trust beliefs as conceptualized and verified in the U.S. apply in Israel which differs markedly in individualism, uncertainty avoidance, and power distance. The data, cross-validating the scale of trust and its antecedents in both cultures, generally support the proposition that trust beliefs apply across cultures, and may be a relatively unvarying aspect of e-commerce. However, as expected, the effects of predictability and familiarity on trust beliefs may differ across national cultures. Implications about the need to include national culture in the research on trust, in general, and in e-commerce in particular, are discussed.
International Journal of Information Management National culture and consumer trust in e-commerce
This study uses Hofstede's cultural dimensions theory to explain variance in consumer trust in e-commerce. We model trust as a combination of a consumer's disposition to trust and context specific trustworthiness of an online store. The study hypothesizes direct effects of national cultural dimensions on disposition to trust, and of disposition to trust on dimensions of trustworthiness. We also examine whether and how disposition to trust mediates the effects between national culture and trustworthiness of an online store. We test the hypotheses with a sample of 616 online bookstore customers from China and Finland, countries that represent opposite cultural poles in many respects. We find that national culture solely explain 23% of the variance in the consumer's general disposition to trust, and that disposition to trust is a highly significant predictor of the perceived trustworthiness of an online store. We further find that the mediating role of disposition to trust between national culture and trustworthiness depends greatly on the individual cultural dimension studied.
Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 2012
ABSTRACT The importance of trust in consumers' purchase decisions in e-retailing is of significant interest to retailers. As retailing becomes increasingly globalized, retailers are more interested in cultural differences related to purchase decisions. This empirical study researches how cultural factors are related to multiple dimensions of trust and trust building. Although previous research has examined the influence of trust as a one-dimensional construct, this research examines three dimensions of the trust construct—competence, benevolence and integrity. This research proposes that cultural values will have an impact on how consumers with Eastern vs. Western cultural backgrounds form their trust of e-retailers and how that trust influences their interactions with e-retailers. It focuses on differences between USA (n=252) and Korean (n=256) online customers. It examines how two significant trust forming antecedents, reputation and website quality, affect the three dimensions of trust in the two different cultures, and how the trust dimensions impact two significant consequences, willingness to depend on the e-retailer and related perceptions of risk when dealing with e-retailers.
Frontiers in Psychology, 2021
The outgrowth of e-commerce has advanced the development of countries' economies. Today, online marketplaces are targeting not only their local customers but are also spreading their interests overseas, expanding cross-border e-commerce. The current study aims to analyze the interaction of customer's personal traits, such as national culture, disposition to trust, and perceived trustworthiness, and their effect on the purchase intention within different e-commerce contexts. The contexts are chosen based on the country-of-origin parameter and serve as the moderator in the research model. Both direct and indirect effects of cultural dimensions on trustworthiness and purchase intention are analyzed within the research framework. The data for the analysis are randomly collected among the Russian population and assessed using structural equation modeling (SEM). The analysis results prove the marketplace context moderates the interaction of customers' personal traits among eac...
Cultural effect on electronic consumer behaviour
School of Information Systems, Computing and …, 2006
The ubiquitous nature of e-commerce demands an innovative conceptualization of consumer behaviour that responds to various cultural preferences. Culture has been identified as an underlying determinant of consumer behaviour, and this extends to e-commerce. This research investigates this phenomenon for the Egyptian consumer. This research designed a plausible, integrated framework for investigating the target phenomenon, especially for un-explored cultures. To help to identify salient components of the phenomenon, a three-study exploratory phase, that included: interviews, a survey, and card sorting sessions, was undertaken. The exploratory results highlighted the roles of trust, uncertainty avoidance, Internet store familiarity, and reputation as the main salient factors affecting the perception of the targeted group toward e-commerce. The research hypotheses were then developed based on the exploratory results. Finally, a model testing phase to empirically assess the research hypotheses through a laboratory experiential survey with 370 Egyptian Internet users was undertaken. The experiential survey results support the significant role of the Internet store's perceived familiarity and reputation as the main antecedents of online trust. The relationship between trust and its two antecedents are found to be culturally sensitive; the high uncertainty avoidance of the consumer is found to be associated with a stronger effect of the store's reputation on trust, and a stronger effect of store's familiarity on trust. The research also highlights the significant effect of trust on the attitude towards and the willingness to buy from an e-commerce site. This research, by providing an understanding of the cultural drivers of e-commerce, contributes to building a theory of consumer's cultural trust within an Internet store context. The research reports on the development of an integrated cultural trust model that highlights recommendations for expanding the adoption of e-commerce.
Managing Consumer Trust in Intercultural E-Commerce Transactions
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2000
The importance of consumer trust to the success of online business transactions is well documented. An analytical look at the typical online purchase indicates the level of trust required to complete a transaction is dependent on such factors as: the privacy information consumers must provide, the confidence levels consumers have in their suppliers, the perceived quality of the goods, the supplier's delivery service, customer service options, and the security of the transaction. Consumers are justifiably concerned about the privacy of the personal data they must submit over the internet to complete an online purchase. They perceive security risks to the point they may not want to engage in online transactions. If suppliers can gain consumer confidence and demonstrate the quality of the offered goods via detailed product descriptions in their website content, they can overcome security-related fears and entice consumers to engage in online transactions. Suppliers have resorted to using product and vendor reviews to allow consumers to increase their level of trust in the transaction by vicariously adopting the experiences of previous customers. This practice is now an important part of online purchases and has helped raise consumer confidence.
Purpose – Employee trust research has been criticized for restricted theoretical conceptualization, limited contextual application and low replication of measures in organizational studies. The purpose of this paper is to expand the theoretical framework underpinning individual-level organizational trust to include cognitive and socio-affective components in order to examine trust determinants in a unique cultural setting. Design/methodology/approach – A national survey of 653 employees from six companies in Jamaica completed the perceived organizational support scale, perceived organizational justice scale, employee trust propensity scale and the organizational trust measure (Rawlins, 2008) after focus groups revealed the role of socio-cultural values in employee trust relationships. Findings – Controlling for common methods variance, confirmatory factor analyses revealed that a model of organizational trust that included a combination of cognitive and socio-affective determinants was more valid in the Jamaican culture than a model comprised of cognitive determinants alone. National social values of justice and respect were significant determinants of employee trust. Results also provide validity evidence for the previously non-replicated Rawlins trust scale, thereby, providing future researchers with a measure that can be readily replicated. Research limitations/implications – Employee trust levels influenced participation and consequently restricted the sample size and industry profile of the survey. Cross-cultural trust researchers are, therefore, encouraged to design studies with similar subject loss projections. Originality/value – Strict focus on the collectivistic/individualistic dimension of culture restricts researchers' ability to measure trust effectively across a range of settings. The authors, therefore, propose the uncertainty avoidance dimension as a more valid paradigm to understand inter-cultural differences in trust orientations, particularly in restricted trust domains.
Which “Kind” of Trust for Buying Online? An Intercultural Study
2008
Although there has been rapid growth in the use of the Internet around the world, many issues remain for the development of the online transactions. Many studies have shown that one of the inhibiting factors of online transactions is the lack of confidence in the seller. But, as the Internet itself is an open technology and not a familiar environment,
Trust-Commitment in E-Commerce: A Cross -Cultural Exploration
2014
We investigate the issues of online trust and commitment in a cross- cultural setting. We hypothesize trust to be driven by perceived reputation, perceived security control, perceived privacy control, fulfillment and delivery, sensory characteristics and perceived risk. Trust in turn is hypothesized to drive affective and calculative commitment, which in turn drives willingness to buy. We conducted a survey of 1,094 undergraduates in seven countries (both collectivist and individualistic; five Asian and two Western) to collect data. The model we tested is common to all countries. We find broad support for our model across different cultures.