Comparing hypothetical versus non-hypothetical methods for measuring willingness to pay in a food context (original) (raw)
Related papers
Agricultural Economics, 2011
Biofortification of maize with provitamin A carotenoids is a new approach to the alleviation of vitamin A deficiencies in Africa. Unfortunately these varieties are yellow or orange, while consumers generally prefer white. Consumer willingness to pay for yellow and fortified maize was compared in experimental auctions in three regions in Kenya. The premium that consumers are willing pay for fortified maize (24%) was higher than the discount they require to buy yellow maize (11%), and in one zone consumers prefer yellow. Yellow color is, therefore, not an impossible obstacle for biofortified maize, although it would clearly be easier to introduce this maize first in regions where yellow maize is currently grown.
2011
Experimental auction and discrete choice experiment are two popular value elicitation methods. Theoretically they should yield the same results but empirical results have been mixed (e.g., Lusk and Schroeder 2004, 2006; Corrigan et al. 2010.) This study uses both methods to determine consumers’ willingness to pay (WTP) for rice with improved insect control and for rice stored using Integrated Pest Management (IPM). This study investigates two potential reasons – anchoring and information – for why some studies have found apparent inconsistencies between auction and choice experiment results. Results indicate that consumers’ WTP derived in the auction and choice experiments are significantly different. Consumers’ average bids in the auction are higher than their willingness to pay calculated from the choice experiments. Further, anchoring in the choice experiment appears to be an explanation for the discrepancy. Providing consumers with more product information help consumers behave ...
Willingness To Pay Organic Agricultural Products: Contingent Valuation Methods Approach
Economics Development Analysis Journal
The objective of this study is to analyze the value of Willingness to Pay (WTP) of eco-friendly agricultural products and the factors that influence it. The analytical method used was the contingent valuation method (CVM) and logistic regression analysis. The results show that the total number of WTP in West Java is IDR 620,000, meaning that there will be an additional value of eco-friendly agricultural products by 620,000 for each sale. Then, the total number of WTP in Central Java is IDR 580,000 and then the total number of WTP in East Java is IDR 532,000. Based on the results of the logistic regression estimation, it shows that the variables that have a significant effect on the willingness to pay for eco-friendly agricultural products in West Java include gender, education, marital status, number of family dependents, income, and concern for the environment. Based on the results of the logistic regression estimation, it shows that the variables that have a significant effect on ...
Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie, 2012
Experimental auctions are normally conducted using single-unit auctions. In this paper, we explore the use of multi-unit auctions to investigate the determinants of consumers' willingness to pay (WTP) for a food product (i.e., organic milk) in a multi-unit shopping scenario. We also analyze the effect of positive and negative information about organic farming on WTP. Our results suggest that although consumers are willing to pay for organic milk, their WTP decreases with the number of purchased units. We also found that the magnitude and the statistical significance of the determinants of WTP change from one unit to another. The most important factors affecting WTP are the number of units subjects are willing to buy, health concerns, and perceived animal welfare benefits of organic production. The type of information provided also plays a relevant role. Specifically, we find that positive information on organic farming increases WTP, negative information decreases WTP, and provision of both positive and negative information does not affect WTP.
2004
This paper presents the results of experimental auctions of a genetically modified (GM) food that were conducted in Japan. A series of experimental auctions were conducted to elicit consumers' willingness to pay (WTP) for the selected non-genetically modified (non-GM) food along with WTP for its GM counterpart. The paper provides mean bidding prices for the non-GM and GM food products and analyzes the relationship between bidding prices and consumers' attitudinal and demographic variables. It also elicit hypothetical willingness to pay a premium for the non-GM product. Whereas auction experiments yield a premium of 30-40% of base price, a comparable hypothetical premium is nearly 90-100% of base price, which provides evidence of large hypothetical bias. Although it is impossible to claim that the experimental subjects are representative of the regional population, let alone the Japanese population, both qualitative and quantitative information gathered from the study is useful for anyone involved in the distribution of GM foods.
Journal of applied economics and business studies, 2021
The purpose of this study is to examine the effect of contingent valuation questions format on households 'preferences revelation and willingness to pay (WTP) for chemicals free fruits in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) province of Pakistan. A sample of 1000 randomly selected households, from rural and urban areas of the KP province, were confronted with three different WTP questions for chemicals free fruits-double bounded dichotomous choice question, open-ended question and payment card question. Results show that households' willingness to pay price premium for chemicals free fruits were 14 percent from open-ended question, 16 percent from payment card format and 25 percent from double bounded question. Regression analyses identified head's age, education, monthly income, awareness regarding use of pesticides in fruit production and their impact on human health and natural environment as important determinants of households' stated WTP for chemicals free fruits. The study concludes that households are willing to pay substantial price premium for chemicals free fruits and recommends growers to start their production on commercial scale. Findings of this split-sample study reveals that results of contingent valuation method are sensitive to WTP question format and recommends that proper guidelines must be followed in order to get accurate and reliable results.