Physical modelling of fires spreading upslope, involved in fire eruption triggering (original) (raw)
2022, Imprensa da Universidade de Coimbra eBooks
Eruptive fires are one category of extreme fire behaviour. They are characterized by a sudden and unpredictable change in the fire behaviour which represents an extreme danger for people involved in firefighting. The major point is about the mechanism that turns a usual fire behaviour into an eruptive fire behaviour. Among the different explanations found in the literature, the pioneering interpretation consisting in a feedback effect caused by the convective flow induced by the fire under wind and/or slope conditions, has never been disproved with an example of fire accident. The main goal of this work lies in proposing a physical modelling of this fire induced wind. This modelling attempt is derived from the brand-new version of the Balbi model, which is a simplified physical model for surface fires at the field scale that explicitly depends on the triangle of fire (fuel bed, wind and slope). This work is a first step to the modelling of fire eruption. The model tries to represent accurately the acceleration of the fire rate of spread propagating on different sloped terrain under no-wind or weak wind conditions. It is tested against three sets of experiments carried out at the laboratory scale without external wind and against a high intensity experimental fire spreading on a steep sloped terrain and conducted under weak wind conditions in the northwestern of Corsica. Some statistical tools are used to compare predicted and observed rate of spread (NMSE, Normalized Mean Square Error and MAPE, Mean Absolute Percentage Error) and to understand the model's under-predictions or over-predictions trends (FB, Fractional Bias).
Related papers
The importance of fire front width in the anticipation of eruptive fires
Fire eruption is a significant threat to the safety of wildland fire fighters. Over the last few years, several accidents have caused important human losses. Generally, these fire fighters are surprised by the sudden acceleration of the head fire and they are not prepared for facing it. We characterize eruptive fires by an unexpected increasing of the head fire in a short lapse of time. Despite the danger of the phenomenon, fires rarely erupt and consequently studies of the mechanisms contributing to fire eruption are not so numerous. A recent paper [1] reviewed them in two ways: explanations are mainly based on a variation of the external conditions or on the spreading fire's own properties. Our interpretation about the mechanism leading to a possible eruption consists in an induced air flow created by the fire. We use a semi-physical steady-state model with two equations, which are coupled by this induced wind. This coupling is solved thanks to a fixed-point method and it converges under certain conditions (or does not). In the divergence case, the rate of spread grows infinitely. So the model is not able to describe the fire behaviour during the eruption but it is possible to give the precise conditions for the occurring of the eruption. When meteorological conditions and fuel bed properties are known, we can find the slope angle at which a fire, with given dynamic parameters (fire front width, flame length), erupts. In particular, we will pay interest in the influence of the fire front width on the condition leading to eruption. We validate the model on two sets of experiments at the laboratory scale and a real accident, happened on the Kornaty Islands, Croatia, 2007.
Simulating wildland surface fire behaviour to support emergency management
Imprensa da Universidade de Coimbra eBooks, 2022
The recent upsurge in the incidence of extreme wildfire events, the expected impact of climate change on the frequency and severity of fires, and the progressive expansion of wildland-urban interface areas highlight the tangible need for improvement in our ability to predict, mitigate and manage the growing risk to which communities are exposed. The aim of this research is to contribute to deepen the knowledge on the spatial simulation of the complex dynamics of wildland surface fire behaviour through the development and application of a spatially distributed predictive model for the simulation of wildland surface fire spread intended for operational purposes. Given the position of one or more ignition points, the developed model allows to (i) obtain near real time dynamic estimates of the geo-environmental parameters that control the fire spread, (ii) compute the direction and intensity of the maximum rate of fire spread in heterogeneous environments, and (iii) simulate the surface fire spread using agent-based models. The final aim is to provide competent authorities with timely information on the expected evolution of the flame front to optimise decisionmaking processes. The model, developed under synthetic conditions, is then applied to case studies recorded in the territory of the Autonomous Region of Sardinia, that offers institutional information on the ignition location, the evolution of the flame front, and the completed fire suppression activities, which are implemented in the model as well. Overall, the model showed a promising predictive capacity evaluated in quantitative terms of morphological matching between the observed and predicted fire spread patterns, returning more accurate results in areas with less complex morphologies and dominated by herbaceous rather than shrubby fuels. The model also made it possible to obtain simulations with processing times compatible with its operational application as a tool for optimising and planning fire risk prevention and mitigation strategies and policies as well as fire management activities. Future research will be aimed at estimating the propagation of the parametric uncertainty through the model and applying the model to fire events occurred across different Mediterranean-type climate regions to consistently evaluate its predictive capacity.
Numerical study of high intensity experimental field fires across Corsican shrubland vegetation
Imprensa da Universidade de Coimbra eBooks, 2022
Field-scale experiments have been conducted on steep sloped terrains in Speluncatu and Letia, northwestern and southern regions of Corsica. This work lies within the GOLIAT project framework and it was provided by the Fire and Rescue Service of North Corsica and the Corsican DFCI (Défense de la Forêt Contre l'Incendie) Group. This work reported high intensity fires propagating through shrub vegetation areas (Genista Salzmannii) lying between 60 cm and 85 cm. These sites were selected because of the density of the vegetation, the high slope angle values with a wind direction aligned with the main slope, which can generate a fire close to wildfire behaviour. A detailed experimental protocol is used in order to determine the propagation conditions and the fire behaviour using UAV cameras and heat flux gauges. In order to investigate the different phenomena encountered in these types of fires, numerical simulations were conducted using a complete physical fire model, based on multiphase formulation, namely FireStar2D. Numerical predictions were used to examine the fire front dynamics related to the fire's rate of spread and fireline intensity. Despite the unfavourable wind and humidity conditions, experimental results analysis showed that the fireline intensity was higher than 7 MW/m, which means that these fires fall into the category of the very high fire severity. Numerical results predicting the fire's rate of spread, fireline intensity and fire impact were in good agreement with the experimental data.
Fire
Driving wind and slope of terrain can increase the rate of surface fire propagation. Previous physical modelling under higher driving wind (3–12.5 m/s) on slopes (Innocent et al., IJWF, 2023, 32(4), pp. 496–512 and 513–530) demonstrated that the averaged rate of fire spread (RoS) varied from that of empirical models. This study investigates the potential for better agreement at lower wind velocities (0.1 and 1 m/s), since empirical models are typically developed from experimental studies conducted under benign wind conditions. The same physical model WFDS is used. The results are analysed to understand the behaviour of various parameters (RoS, fire isochrone progression, fire intensity, flame dynamics, and heat fluxes) across different slopes. The RoS–slope angle relationship closely fits an exponential model, aligning with the findings from most experimental studies. The relative RoSs are aligned more closely with the Australian and Rothermel models’ slope corrections for 0.1 and 1...
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.