Successful Leadership in Global Public Good Provision: Incorporating Behavioural Approaches (original) (raw)
Related papers
Climate leadership by conditional commitments
Oxford Economic Papers, 2017
Under the 2015 Paris climate agreement, each Party sets its own mitigation target by submitting a Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) every …ve years. An important question is whether including conditional components in NDCs might enhance the agreement's e¤ ectiveness. We report the results of a closely controlled laboratory experiment-based on a mixed sequential-simultaneous public good game with one leader and three followers-that helps answer this question. The experiment investigates how two factors in ‡uence the e¤ ectiveness of leadership based on intrinsically conditional commitments. Measuring e¤ ectiveness in terms of followers' and total contributions, we …nd that it may help if the conditional promise is credible and if its implementation in ‡uences followers' welfare substantially. Importantly, however, for both factors we …nd a signi…cant e¤ ect only if the leader does not reap disproportionate gains from the group's e¤ orts. These …ndings have important implications concerning the future success of the Paris agreement.
Non-Instrumental Behavior in an Environmental Public Good Game
This paper reports a puzzling result from an experiment based on an indeflnitely repeated N-player Prisoners' Dilemma game carried out in a PC lab. The experiment used real monetary payofis, and was conducted in the context of international cooperation to curb cli- mate change. It was puzzling that after the experiment, a large ma- jority of subjects reported they were at least partially motivated out of concern for the climate; however, nothing they did in the experi- ment could possibly have had an impact on the climate. We show that subjects acting out of concern for the climate incurred a real cost in monetary terms, and argue that many subjects' behavior in the ex- periment deviated quite fundamentally from instrumental rationality. Although much recent research on public goods provision questions the traditional assumption that players are purely self-regarding, the as- sumption of instrumental rationality is typically preserved. The results reported in this paper go...
2020
Evidence from public goods game experiments holds the promise of informing climate change policies. To fulfill this promise, such evidence needs to demonstrate generalizability to this specific policy context. This paper examines whether and under which conditions behavior in public goods games generalizes to decisions about voluntary climate actions. We observe each participant in two different decision tasks: a real giving task in which contributions are used to directly reduce CO2 emissions and an abstract public goods game. Through treatment variations in this within-subjects design, we explore two factors that are candidates for affecting generalizability: the structural resemblance of contribution incentives between the tasks and the role of the subject pool, students and non-students. Our findings suggest that cooperation in public goods games is only weakly linked to voluntary climate actions and not in a uniform way. For a standard set of parameters, behavior in both tasks ...
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2000
One may misread economic theory on climate policy to provide a warning against unilateral mitigation. While important lessons are drawn from 'global problems require global solutions', these say little about what to do in a phase before or without a global agreement-or with weak ones. In the literature on cooperation and leadership in provision of public goods, early provision may stimulate provision from others. A key to leadership is signaling; an early mover has private information and is motivated in part by knowing that others will follow. Others will follow if they understand that the early mover demonstrates that emission reductions are feasible and adoptable. Our analysis finds that early movers will be cognizant of what they need to demonstrate, and they will be concerned about and act on carbon leakage. Leadership can be deterred by concerns for free riding, but this is more likely for a country or coalition that is large in terms of emissions and face others who are both large and vulnerable to climate change. We suggest leadership is possible early in this century: numbers indicate that few-if any-need find themselves deterred from early action of some sort.
Donating-selling tradeoffs and the influence of leaders in the environmental public goods game
Hans J. Czap and Natalia V. Czap (in press). Donating-selling tradeoffs and the influence of leaders in the environmental goods game. Journal of Socio Economics. Contributions to environmental goods are motivated by both pecuniary incentives and environmental consciousness. Public policy often uses financial incentives to encourage contributions. However, individuals often donate their time or money to the environmental cause without such incentives. The purpose of this paper is: (a) to examine the relationship between “donating” (without monetary incentives) and “selling” behavior (motivated by monetary incentives) of individuals in the context of environmental protection and (b) to analyze the influence of a leader on individual contributions to the environmental good. The major results are: (1) there is a tradeoff/substitution between donating and selling for a given level of incentives; (2) donating is much less sensitive to changes in monetary incentives and, furthermore, there is no evidence that the increase in financial incentives to sell will crowd out donations; (3) the changes in contributions by leaders have a significant impact on followers’ behavior.
Donating-selling tradeoffs and the influence of leaders in the environmental goods game
Journal of Socio-Economics, 2011
Contributions to environmental goods are motivated by both pecuniary incentives and environmental consciousness. Public policy often uses financial incentives to encourage contributions. However, individuals often donate their time or money to the environmental cause without such incentives. The purpose of this paper is: (a) to examine the relationship between "donating" (without monetary incentives) and "selling" behavior (motivated by monetary incentives) of individuals in the context of environmental protection and (b) to analyze the influence of a leader on individual contributions to the environmental good. The major results are: (1) there is a tradeoff/substitution between donating and selling for a given level of incentives; (2) donating is much less sensitive to changes in monetary incentives and, furthermore, there is no evidence that the increase in financial incentives to sell will crowd out donations; (3) the changes in contributions by leaders have a significant impact on followers' behavior.
Interests and Norms Shape Support for Global Climate Cooperation
The provision of manageable greenhouse gases to mitigate climate change is the paradigmatic global public good. As with most global public good problems, domestic political conflict over its provision determines success or failure of cooperation on climate policy. We explore the extent to which domestic disagreement over climate cooperation mirrors the distribution of economic interests or differences in social norms. We examine observational and experimental data from original surveys in France, Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States, using various measures of the pollutiveness of individuals' industries of employment and behavioral measures of altruism and reciprocity. Our results suggest that both sector-based interests and social norms determine support for global climate cooperation. We also find evidence that these factors interact, mediating each other's effect on support for climate change cooperation.
Behavioral Economics and Climate Change Policy
Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2008
The policy recommendations of most economists are based, explicitly or implicitly, on the rational actor model of human behavior. Behavior is assumed to be self-regarding, preferences are assumed to be stable, and decisions are assumed to be unaffected by social context or frame of reference. The related fields of behavioral economics, game theory, and neuroscience have confirmed that human behavior is other regarding, and that people exhibit systematic patterns of decision-making that are "irrational" according to the standard behavioral model. This paper takes the position that these "irrational" patterns of behavior are central to human decision making and therefore, for economic policies to be effective these behaviors should be the starting point. This contention is supported by game theory experiments involving humans, closely related primates, and other animals with more limited cognitive ability. The policy focus of the paper is global climate change. The research surveyed in this paper suggests that the standard economic approach to climate change policy, with its almost exclusive emphasis on rational responses to monetary incentives, is seriously flawed. In fact, monetary incentives may actually be counter-productive. Humans are unique among animal species in their ability to cooperate across cultures, geographical space and generations. Tapping into this uniquely human attribute, and understanding how cooperation is enforced, holds the key to limiting the potentially calamitous effects of global climate change.
Playing a better global warming game: does it help to be green?
Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics, 1998
It is commonly believed that an increase in environmental awareness is conducive to the protection of the global commons. Moreover, it has been proposed that governments should "give a good example" by unilaterally reducing emissions. In a simple analytical framework it is shown that these relations are less straightforward than intuitively expected. On the contrary: "Good intentions" might lead to lower abatement targets within an international environmental agreement and to lower stability due to strategic behavior of governments.