Jean-Jacques Nattiez, Analyses et interprétations de la musique: La mélodie du berger dans le Tristan et Isolde de Richard Wagner (Paris: Vrin, 2013) (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Labyrinth of the Soul:: Wagner’s Musical Lament
2016
EnglishIn spite of the witty saying that more books have been written about Richard Wagner than anyone else except Jesus Christ and Napoleon Bonaparte, I will venture to sail into the high seas. This essay is the first installment of a trilogy devoted to Wagner’s Tristan—a musical lament, indeed the cornerstone of modern(ist) art. Taking my cue from Eduardo Lourenco’s self-questioning remark on such powerful music, ‘By what mysterious means?’, I shall examine it anew, trying different tacks. The complete text— literary, theoretical and analytical—weaves through music and language. ‘Music in language’ is a preliminary attempt to explore sensual, artistic sound qualities in the word. ‘The language of music’, then, puts forward a grammar for tonal music as it may be sensed in a wider panorama of the evolving Western consciousness. ‘Music as language’, eventually, offers a novel approach to Wagner’s musicopoetic process: I thus seek to unravel that distinctive longing (Sehnen) of the so...
The Fade Out: Metaphysics and Dialectics in Wagner
The Fade Out: Metaphysics and Dialectics in Wagner, 2020
This article is a critique of the failure of Wagner's Der Ring des Nibelungen. It considers this as a metaphysical problem rather than an aesthetic or formal one. The article, considering Wagner's inheritance from Haydn, claims him as the first composer of the culture industry. This will lead the author to conclusions regarding a gendered Das Unheimlich, the distinction between technology and technique, and the philosophy of aesthetics.
Although historically informed performance practice has come to encompass the music of the 19th century in the past decades, Romantic music still presents many challenges for performers, especially in musical shaping and timing. This paper tries to shed light on these interpretative issues by combining aspects of analysis and performance in the opening movement of Robert Schumann’s D minor Piano Trio Op. 63 (1847). The main analytical methods are Schenkerian harmony and voice-leading analysis, which are flexibly combined with formal and narrative aspects, among others. The analytical discussion begins with the distinctive, harmonically unstable opening phrase, which reaches the structural tonic only at the end of the phrase together with a local culmination. The analytical insights lead the author to suggest two alternative, yet equally justifiable, ways how to shape the phrase in performance. The second example is the surprising new episode in the development section, which raises many interpretation issues for committed performers. With its powerful returning in the formal coda, the episode eventually has a far-reaching influence on the whole movement both in the voice leading and the musical narrative. As a conclusion, the article suggests that analysis and performance are able to communicate with each other on many levels. By taking another look at the musical work, analysis can offer choices for musical interpretation and give performers a “second opinion” without being excessively authoritative over performance. At the same time, the experience gained from performance can inspire analytical insights.