A Royal Republic? Deciphering the Multiple Lineages of Popular Sovereignty in India (original) (raw)
Related papers
Friend not Foe: Popular Sovereignty in the Indian Constitution
IIC Quarterly, 2022
The rise of right wing authoritarian leaders and movements in liberal democracies are an indication of some of the underlying problems with the nature of liberal democracy itself. The belief that democracy requires a level homogeneity can be traced back to Carl Schmitt who identified some of these problems in the time of the Weimar Republic. However, liberal democracies may need to take leaf out of Ambedkar's writings to address the current threat to the liberal democratic order.
Towards a Political Sociology of Power in Post-Colonial India
Shodh Disha [ISSN 0975-735X] UGC Care Listed Journal, 2023
This paper in two sections elucidates upon how democracy enters a particular historical and socio-cultural setting and becomes ‘vernacularized’, and how through this process it produces new social relations and values which in turn shapes ‘the political.’ The First Section of the paper suc- cinctly puts conceptualization of power dynamics through the canons of Western Political Theory. The Second Section, then helps us re-imagine power dynamics in postcolonial democracies as an interplay of capital and social clout. Finally, in the Third Section, it brings back this discussion of power dynamics in postcolonial democracies into the heart of a fundamental problem in classical political theory i.e., the crisis of legitimation.
INDIA'S DEMOCRATIC HERITAGE AND CONTEMPORARY POLITICAL REALITIES
“India’s Democratic Heritage and Contemporary Political Realities”, 2023
Is India's democracy a gift of the British? If so, how can we explain India's democratic traditions prevalent in the hoary past , of which the Greeks spoke of glowingly and the Buddhist chronicles recorded ? How can we ignore the democratic practices prevalent in medieval India? Unearthing India's democratic traditions will destroy the myth of 'Oriental Despotism' which the Westerners claimed to have destroyed .The present paper is the outcome of Delivered an Invited Talk entitled India’s Democratic Heritage and Contemporary Political Realities at ICSSR Sponsored Two Day National Seminar on ‘India’s Glorious Cultural Heritage: Continuity and Changes’ (23rd and 24th March, 2023) organized by Kashipur Michael Madhusudan Mahavidyalaya, Purulia. It has been published in Subhrajit Chatterjee ed. 'India’s Glorious Cultural Heritage: Continuity and Changes' (Selected Papers from ICSSR Sponsored Two Day National Seminar , Organized by Department of Sociology, Michael Madhusudan Mahavidyalaya , Kashipur, Purulia, West Bengal, India), Levant Books, India (ISBN: 978-93-91741-40-2)p.1-40.
Winston Churchill felt that the Indian polity was not ripe enough for independence but Mahatma Gandhi pressed for swarajya nevertheless. Some fifty-five years after Atlee freed India off the British colonial yoke, what is the bottom line of the world's largest democracy? Barring the brief aberration that was the internal emergency imposed on it by Indira Gandhi, India, has been cruising on the path of democracy. That is about the physicality of going through electoral motions but what about the cerebral quality of the Indian democratic output? The cheerleaders of the Indian democracy cite the shining examples of its electoral maturity in avenging Indira for her emergency and dumping the Janata Party for its insipid rule. Oh, how the wonderful Indian voters routinely dump the haughty in the dustbins of anti-incumbency and where else on earth does democracy shine ever so bright, and such, tend to shape the grand narrative. Was Winston wrong then? No for doubts arose soon as the electorate tended to vote on caste lines and communal contours only to be cemented as voters, in the wake of Indira Gandhi's assassination, swayed by emotion, swamped its 8 th Lok Sabha with Congressmen. But the clinching evidence that Churchill was doubly right came a little later.
Decoding Democracy: Describing Tradition of Democracy in Ancient India
Themes in Early Indian History, ed. Prithwiraj Biswas, Santanu Dey et al. (ISBN: 978-81-966201-6-5) Department of History, Ramakrishna Mission Vidyamandira, Belur Math, Howrah, 2023
The year 2022 marked the platinum jubilee of India's independence from foreign yoke and completion of 75 years as a "democratic republic". Democratic traditions have existed in India since prehistoric times. My paper traces the origin and evolution of democratic tradition in India since the Vedic Age characterised by 'Janapadas' (literally 'foot of the tribe'; 'jana' meaning 'people' and 'pada' meaning 'foot') or tribal republics. Since the seminar is themed on 'Early Indian History', my paper discusses democratic tradition in India till the establishment of the Delhi Sultanate in 1206 AD, which is conventionally regarded as the concluding point of Ancient Indian History. Essence of democracy lies in accepting multiplicity, as opposed to Fascism which decimates people who are not in favour of the ruling body. Democracy is catering to all, irrespective of who voted for the ruling party. This element of democracy is what sets it apart from all other forms of government. In my paper I have endeavoured to highlight and trace the multifarious instances of democratic practices in ancient India that bear testimony to the antiquity of the deeply rooted democratic tradition in India.
Scalar, Spectacular and Subaltern Sovereignty: Colonial Autocracy and Democracy in Interwar India
Sovereignty: A Global Perspective, 2022
This chapter opens by introducing three recurring characteristics of contemporary debates regarding sovereignty in colonial India. The first concerns scale; the way in which the sovereignty of the Government of India was positioned between that of the Indian village and the imperial capital in London. The second concerns spectacle; the accentuated role of the visual and of violence in the Raj. The third debate emerges from subaltern studies and regards the popular sovereignty of the Indian non-elite. These three types of sovereignty will be shown to have been renegotiated at the Round Table Conference which took place over three sittings in London between 1930 and 1932. A new federal hybrid of autocracy and democracy was devised, a new spectacle of interwar colonial sovereignty was manufactured, and vying claims were made to speak not only of but for Indian subalterns.
The Art of Governing Well: Freedom and the Practice of Government in Modern India
2020
This dissertation studies political development and transformation in modern India. It stresses the impact of Indian political thought in shaping governmental practice since the 1940s. The theoretical emphasis is placed on freedom and, in particular, how Indians have thought themselves as free and in how this thought has inspired practices of government in a range of sectors including the family, and the private and public sectors. Two important moments in Indian political thinking around freedom since the mid-twentieth century are identified and elaborated. Between the 1940s and 1960s, the theory of freedom was framed in a juridico-political register where the rights of the newly independent Indian subject both defined the individual's freedom and the parameters of governmental practice. Through their juridically secured rights, the Indian subject-citizen was at once made free and obliged to a nation-building project. And government governed well when it respected the rights of...