UNDERSTANDING RELIGION-STATE RELATIONS IN MUSLIM SOCIETIES: Beyond Essentialist and Secular-Liberal Narratives (original) (raw)
Related papers
Umran; International Journal of Islamic and Civilizational Studies, 2016
UMRAN | 03-1 (2016) pp. 28-36 | www.http://jurnalumran.utm.my/index.php/umran | Abstract This research aims at analyzing political secularism in Indonesia and most specifically dealing with the recurrent polemic upon the relationship between Islam and State. The research initially seeks to describe the political situation of the country where the formalistic and substantives debate, especially on their distinctive approach to stipulate the proper role of religion on the country's politic, could be witnessed. The description, however, will deal more on the latter political paradigm which is increasingly grasping an impressive preference from numbers of political individuals and institutions particularly when they come to discuss Islamic tenets and their application within the context of a pluralistic society like Indonesia. Using normative and socio-historical approaches, the paper argues that this political preference, despite its convincing successes in Islamizing the country's politic, still suffers from numbers of defects that finally raise our apprehension. These defects summarily provide proofs to the questioned commitment of the substantive to the Islamic political values as a whole; the one which reveals an agreed separation of the state and religion; the one of secularism.
The Relationship Between Religion and The State in Indonesia, and Its Relation to Islamic Law
NEGREI: Academic Journal of Law and Governance
The relationship between religion and the state has become an actual and dynamic discourse in every phase of the development of civilization, both in the West and in the East. The debate revolves around the question of the form of the state, whether it is integral, symbiotic, or secular. Departing from this discourse, this study examined the existence of the relationship between religion (Islam) and the state in Indonesia. The approach used was Martin Heidegger's hermeneutics, while the study method used was a comparative method. The results of this study indicate that historically-normatively, the Prophet SAW had formulated the State of Medina based on the Medina Charter which spirit was based on the texts of the Qur'an, not an Islamic state based on the literal Qur'an. The scholars who became the founders of the Indonesian state had also formulated Pancasila as stated in the Preamble to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia as the ideal building for establ...
The Relationship of Islam and The State in Contemporary Islamic Political Discourse in Indonesia
Dirasah International Journal of Islamic Studies
The purpose of this study was to relate the views in the context of Islamic politics in Indonesia, this article is intended to explore issues relating to relations between Islam and the state. This study was motivated by the desire to criticize the development and relationship between Islam and the state which is very dynamically coloring the political situation in “Islamic majority country” Indonesia. This article concludes that understanding the relationship between religion and state with an Islamic political approach is not meant to establish a religious state or an Islamic state of Indonesia but rather to fill the spaces that are functionally religion in order society, nation, and state., and secularistic relations.
Islamic Thought in Indonesia’s Religio Political Context
2010
Not like in Western state, religion and politics in Indonesia is something difficult to be strictly separated. As a lecturer on al-Fiqh al-Siyasa (law and politics in Islam) as well as an activist on human rights advocacy studies I cannot evade issues related to religion, law and politics in Indonesia. So it can be understood if all of papers or articles written in this book were actually reflections or opinions related to these issues
Religion and State in the Islamic Political Paradigm in Indonesia Perspective of Prof. Kamsi
Analisis: Jurnal Studi Keislaman
The relationship between religion and the state has always been an actual problem in the discourse of Islamic political thought. This paper aims to describe the relationship between religion and the state in Indonesia with a focus on studying the Islamic political paradigm in the view of Prof. Kamsi, who is one of the professors in the study of Islamic law politics at UIN Sunan Kalijaga Yogyakarta. Then, library research with analytical descriptive nature is used in this research by conducting a descriptive study that aims to provide answers to various problems regarding the state of a particular subject or object in detail. Then, various data that have been obtained are analyzed and interpreted to get an adequate explanatory meaning. Furthermore, this study states that in the view of Prof. Kamsi. In general, the pattern of relations between religion and the state is not just a pattern of dichotomous relations that cancel each other out. However, the relationship between religion an...
Islam's Relationship to Politics and the State in Indonesia
2018
This study aims to reveal and explain the political relations between Islam and the state in Indonesia. The study was conducted on the inspiration that emerges from the writer's observation, after doing a historical study on the growing phenomenon since the end of Western colonialism in the mid 20th century. The phenomenon that is, the difficulty of Islam in Indonesia, even in other Muslim countries to develop appropriate synthesis between Islamic movements and political ideas with countries in the context of their respective localities. In Indonesia, a predominantly Muslim country, the political relations between Islam and the state is often characterized by sharp tensions, even hostile. With respect to the position of the Muslim majority, drove us to the question. Why Islam is the majority of it is difficult to get a place as a state religion? Why the state is still difficult to make Islam the basis of the state? The fact is what attracted the attention of researchers, thus was born a question "whether Islam can be in line with modern political system, in which the idea of the nation-state is one of the constituents. The results showed that in Indonesia Muslim group active in the political movement regards the state with suspicion. The group is looking at countries are doing double standard policy on political Islam in Indonesia. On the one hand supports the formation of a secular Muslim societies, and on the other hand did not leave the room or the slightest opportunity for the growth of political Islam. As a result, frequent political tension between Islam and the state, especially during the reign of Sukarno and Suharto regime. Key Words:Islamic relationship, politics and the state in indonesia, a historical analysis.