Planning Electronic Trading Systems: Re-Thinking is Practices via Triple Loop Learning (original) (raw)
Related papers
Operationalising Guidelines for Inter-Organisational Systems Planning: Exploring a Learning Model
European Conference on Information Systems, 2001
This paper addresses the issue of operationalising guidelines for IOS planning. The authors explore the usefulness of Triple Loop Learning in light of the IOS development experiences of three inter-organisational networks. They conclude that the principles of Triple Loop Learning explain the evolutionary planning process studied, and that further analysis must be undertaken to determine the suitability of the underlying techniques.
Realigning Research and Practice in Information Systems Development, 2001
Infonnation systems development (ISD) continues to be an issue of central significance and concern in the IS field-arguably the core topic for the field. Even as new research topics emerge in tandem with the latest developments in technology, the core issue of how to develop systems to leverage these new technologies and topics remains as problematic as ever. Looking at electronic commerce, one of the most recent areas to have stimulated much research interest, we can see that the work in this area is characterized initially by research that considers the basic functionality of these systems: what can they do? Then the focus moves to how to manage them: how can they be used to support organizational strategy? However, a fundamental principle-which may seem obvious, but is nevertheless not always stated-is that all of these systems have to be developed, and that someone must assume responsibility for doing that. Another fundamental principle is that identifying the purpose, functions, and structure of these systems is an extremely complex process. Although some aspects of the development process have come to be more automated (supported by technology such as CASE tools, for example), the social and organizational issues remain as the crucially important ones. How do we get the right system for the organization? How does the process of development change? Who are the stakeholders? Even in the packaged The original version of this chapter was revised: The copyright line was incorrect. This has been corrected. The Erratum to this chapter is available at
Strategic information systems planning: A case study from the financial services industry
Strategic Information Systems Planning (SISP) is an important topic for managers and researchers alike. However, there is evidence of a gap between SISP research and practice. Taking this situation as a motivation, we conducted an in depth case study on SISP to investigate this gap. The study was carried out in a German financial services company (FSC) over a period of five months in summer 2003. During this time, the enterprise situation and the information system (IS) practices situation of FSC were studied with respect to the SISP approach in place. Our findings confirm the hypothesis that practitioners largely ignore academic literature and do not use it in support of their SISP endeavours. This is all the more striking since FSC extensively used guidance from IS research in other fields such as systems analysis and software development. Our case study examines in detail two possible explanations for the gap: firstly a lacking transfer of academic knowledge to practice, and secondly deficiencies in the academic knowledge base itself. In fact, our observations highlight a disconnect between academic discussion and practical conduct. However, we found that the ignorance of academic literature on SISP is not primarily caused by a constrained knowledge transfer. In order to exclude communication barriers, we filtered the academic discussion according to the specific situation and the needs of FSC and translated it into practical recommendations. Nevertheless, the academic arguments we put forward hardly had any impact, either on IT managers' thinking or on SISP practice at FSC. Though academic literature was partly perceived as inspiring, it was not regarded as a touchstone for SISP practice. Academia, in the eyes of FSC's practitioners, ignores the ''real problems'' and thus is not accredited as a relevant source of advice. Moreover, in a final discussion with FSC's senior IT executives we got the impression that the professional identity of FSC's IT management -and more specifically the CIO's role -was different from interpretations 0963-8687/$ -see front matter Ó
An Integrative Framework For E-Business Information System Development
The advent of networked economy calls for new understanding of business, and it is evidenced by the visible trend of traditional businesses either migrating to e-business or expanding to embrace electronic commerce. The development of new business models supported by information technology has become an important issue in the business community. This paper first describes different kinds of information systems and their criteria, e-business information system framework and then map IS criteria into the EBIS criteria to extend the former EBIS framework and to reach an integrative framework which fills the gap between IS categories and EBIS. The mapping process was done by academics and managers of top 50 firms in Iran. Consequently the paper discusses the roadmap guiding information system planners and designers.
Acquiring Information Systems through Organisational Learning
2nd European Conference on …, 2008
Acquiring ICT applications is becoming a routine in organisations today. However, making an ICT investment decision is a complex task, especially for SMEs which do not have the time and knowledge needed to do the task properly. The existing models supposed to help in the ICT acquisition process are mostly designed for IT professionals and they are too heavy and technical to be used in SMEs. The decision makers in SMEs are obligated to rely on the software vendor's ability to solve the problem with the systems provided.
Implementing an IS strategy—A team approach
Long Range Planning, 1997
I NFORMATION SYSTEMS STRATEGY PLANNING (ISSP) has been identified as vital to continuing organizational success and effective IS performance.'-3 However, although ISSP methodologies have been used for many years, organizations are still failing to deal effectively with untangling IS planning-related problems. This is mainly because many ISSP methodologies do not seem to realize that the IS-related problems result not merely from technological problems, but are also derived from paying too little attention to the interrelationship between IS and business and organizational factors." Research has shown that despite the growing number of theoretical frameworks for ISSP, practice still faces three major problems: ?? need for integration of ISSP and overall corporate ?? moderate practical utility of existing ISSP meth-?? limited management involvement and commitment to the ISSP activities4."
Bosch and Nguyen Business Systems Review Vol 2 p48-70 edited
Managers and leaders today are expected to deliver innovative solutions and policies to cope with increasing change and uncertainty. Even more challenging is the fact that the complex issues tend to transcend the jurisdictions and capacities of any single organisation or Government department. Systems thinking offers a holistic and integrative way of appreciating all the major dimensions of a complex problem, and enables the formation of effective management strategies (systemic interventions) with long lasting outcomes. This paper reports on three major systems based approaches to help current and create future managers and leaders to be equipped with new ways of thinking that are systems design-led to deal with complex problems in a systemic, integrated and collaborative fashion. These include establishing Evolutionary Learning Laboratories (ELLabs); "Starting with the Young"; and introducing systems education at tertiary level.