Municipal Water Use and Water Rates Driven by Severe Drought: A Case STUDY1 (original) (raw)
Related papers
Economic consequences of optimized water management for a prolonged, severe drought in California
Water Resources Research, 2010
If abrupt climate change has occurred in the past and may be more likely under human forcing, it is relevant to look at the adaptability of current infrastructure systems to severe conditions of the recent past. Geologic evidence suggests two extreme droughts in California during the last few thousand years, each 120-200 years long, with mean annual streamflows 40% -60% of the historical mean. This study synthesized a 72-year drought with half of mean historical inflows using random sampling of historical dry years. One synthetic hydrological record is used and sensitivity to different interpretations of the paleorecord is not evaluated. Economic effects and potential adaptation of California's water supply system in 2020 to this drought is explored using a hydro-economic optimization model. The model considers how California could respond to such an extreme drought using water trading and provides best case estimates of economic costs and effects on water operations and demands. Results illustrate the ability of extensive, intertied, and flexible water systems with heterogeneous water demands to respond to severe stress. The study follows a different approach to climate change impact studies, focusing on past climate changes from the paleo record rather than downscaled general circulation model results to provide plausible hydrologic scenarios. Adaptations suggested for the sustained drought are similar for dry forms of climate warming in California, and are expensive but not catastrophic for the overall economy, but would impose severe burdens on the agricultural sector and environmental water uses.
Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2020
This paper estimates feasible water savings for a sample of nine urban water districts in California during the height of the 2012-16 drought, just prior to the implementation of mandatory water use reductions, using household production theory and stochastic frontier analysis. Estimates of feasible savings are compared to mandated reductions and actual reductions in each district. Although the mandated reductions were generally feasible, our results show that they had asymmetric impacts across districts and tended to impose larger burdens on some disadvantaged groups.
Water demand projections produced by water utilities and state and federal agencies call for increases in municipal water demand. These projections rely on the so-called " requirements approach, " and typically assume an arbitrary floor on per capita demand, sometimes resulting in projections that diverge from recent trends. Seasonal trend and breakpoint analysis are used to investigate trends in four New Mexico municipalities where increases in demand are projected: Albuquerque, Clovis, Rio Rancho and Edgewood. Analysis points to declining aggregate and per premises water demand – typically for both residential and industrial users. Despite spatial proximity and similar climates, existence and reason for series breaks differs by municipality. While Albuquerque and Edgewood experienced no breaks, Clovis and Rio Rancho experienced breaks. Clovis breakpoints are likely to due to drought conditions, while Rio Rancho's break is confined to high volume users and is likely related to rate increases. Given the general decline in aggregate and premises-level municipal water demand over the period of interest, this study suggests that demand trends over the last decade are likely not fully accounted-for in near-term demand projections. Failing to account for recent trends can lead to costly overinvestment in infrastructure or unnecessary supply augmentation.
An analysis of water scarcity in a drought prone city: The case of Ensenada, Baja California, Mexico
Tecnología y ciencias del agua, 2020
The city of Ensenada depends on groundwater, particularly from the Maneadero and Guadalupe aquifer for water supply for agricultural irrigation, urban use, and to support a range of ecosystem functions. Due to intensive extraction, the aquifers' water levels are decreasing and there is water scarcity in the area. Among the solutions implemented by the state of Baja California government is the construction of a desalination plant in Ensenada to meet urban demand, the construction of a new aqueduct to transport water from the Colorado River-Tijuana and the implementation of water reuse for irrigation and aquifer's infiltration. This paper aims to analyze the potential alternatives to mitigate water scarcity in Ensenada region, Baja California, by comparing the costs of water management alternatives and discussing possible solutions. It was found that the use of treated wastewater for irrigation and aquifer's injection could restore aquifers overused at the long term and is more cost-effective from an environmental and economic point of view. Transporting water from Colorado River-Tijuana-aqueduct Ensenada and the construction of a seawater desalination plant are important steps towards provisioning water to Ensenada yet are less desirable due to their environmental impact and the dependency on an already highly impacted watershed.
Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2015
Warmer and drier conditions over the past decade in California, in addition to court-mandated restrictions on the Sacramento River Delta water supply, have generally reduced the amount of water resources available to Southern California. These constraints on water supply led water agencies to implement a range of water conservation and watering restrictions programs, mostly targeted at outdoor use. The City of Los Angeles, the largest of 88 cities in the County of Los Angeles and the most populous in the United States, took several measures to attempt to reduce residential water consumption. Three phases of water restrictions were implemented during the 2008-2010 period: voluntary restrictions (FY2008), mandatory restrictions (FY2009), and yet more stringent mandatory restrictions combined with a price increase and a decrease in overall household allocations (FY2010). Our research aims at quantifying the impact of these increasing restrictions on single-family residential water use across the City. Ten years of monthly individual billing data (2000-2010) were obtained from the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (LADWP), the municipal utility for the City. Monthly single-family customer water use records at the Public Use Microdata Area level from 2000 to 2007 were used to develop and validate a linear regression model that integrated unemployment and climate information during a period without restrictions. Predictions from the model were then compared to actual consumption to assess the impact of water restrictions during the 2008-2010 period. We also contrasted voluntary water restrictions counseled by LADWP with mandatory water use restrictions. Results show that more stringent mandatory outdoor watering restrictions combined with pricing measures were most effective and resulted in a 23% decrease in City average single-family water use during summer of FY2010. Voluntary restrictions in FY2008 were less effective in reducing water use.
Water and the California Economy
W hat are the key economic issues related to water management in California today? This report offers a consensus view, drawn from a wide-ranging group of experts. We find that despite many beneficial innovations in water management over the last several decades, risks to the economy remain. Water is indeed vital to the California economy, but not always in the ways one might think. It is a scarce resource, subject to numerous and competing demands-including increasing demands for environmental uses. And the state essentially stopped expanding its vast surface storage network several decades ago. Yet the economy has weathered periodic droughts, and enough water has been available to support a growing population and economy, thanks to management innovations including water use efficiency, water markets, underground storage (or "banking"), and reuse of highly treated wastewater. Another reason for resilience: California's economy has become less reliant on waterintensive activities. For instance, agriculture and related manufacturing account for nearly four-fifths of all business and residential water use-but make up just 2 percent of state GDP and 4 percent of all jobs. But California's current water system raises several red flags. Catastrophic interruptions of water supplies from earthquakes and floods could cause large short-term losses; unreliable supplies could also jeopardize business and infrastructure investments that support economic growth. Catastrophic flood risk and severely overdrafted groundwater basins are major concerns in some regions.
Using economic and other performance measures to evaluate a municipal drought plan
Water Policy, 2013
This paper explores the welfare costs associated with drought plan transactions between a public municipal water agency, the El Dorado Irrigation District (EID) in California in the USA and its customers. The EID imposes a tiered pricing plan for municipal customers, which was analyzed as a discrete continuous choice (DCC) model by water users within a climate driven water evaluation and planning (WEAP) model of the EID water system. The DCC is subsequently used to estimate the compensating variation (CV) measure of the loss of consumer welfare in the case where a customer does not receive water that matches a preferred level of demand. In addition to monetized welfare loss, we look at other metrics of performance such as reservoir storage and hydropower generation. For the drought-of-record under full build-out, results show that the welfare loss to EID customers from the imposed drought plan is far less than if no drought plan were in place. This suggests that current consumption ...
Water policies and their effects on water usage: The case of Tucson, Arizona
Water Utility Journal, 2021
As urban population grows and climate change unfolds, water utility companies and city governments are looking for innovative ways to achieve water security. Managing water demand is increasingly considered an efficient way to achieve water security, relying on policies at different levels to make this happen. However, the effects of water demand management policies on actual water consumption are not well documented. The purpose of this study is to analyze water demand management policies and their effects on overall water usage. We analyze the case of Tucson, Arizona, U.S., a city located in a water-scarce region, where population has been growing over the past decades, while their overall water consumption has decreased. We examine water-related policies at different levels (state, county, city, and utility), their caveats, and their effects on water usage. Our analysis shows that policy implementation needs to happen in parallel to management decisions at multiple levels. Lessons learned to reduce their water consumption in cities with water scarcity include the importance of institutional support; the need to collaborate with other organizations; the value of protecting and investing in ecosystem health; and that leveraging and combining existing efforts can result in synergies for water conservation and sustainability.
Water pricing in California (master thesis)
Based on panel data from the City of Davis, California, comprising more than 15,000 urban water consumption units and 81 billing periods over 13 years, this study investigates residential water demand and the effectiveness of three structural water conservation measures. The city switched from a uniform to an increasing block pricing scheme, introduced a second tariff block for single-family residential households, and changed the calculation logic for the household sewer rate. An instrumental fixed effects regression analysis results in a price elasticity of -0.19 for residential consumers. The data also suggests that all structural tariff adjustments were effective, even under consideration of the general economic situation. This is the first study which demonstrates the effectiveness of coupling the sewer rate with a proxy for indoor water consumption on a household level.
Patterns and controlling factors of residential water use in Los Angeles, California
Water Policy, 2014
The current study evaluates residential water use patterns and driving factors across Los Angeles, California. Ten years of monthly residential water data were obtained from the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. Socio-economic, vegetation characteristics, climate, and water pricing data were utilized to develop a statistical model to determine controlling factors of single-family residential water use. Key drivers were found to be household income, landscape greenness, water pricing, household volume allocation, precipitation and temperature. Results show that low water users are less sensitive to climate variability than high water users, likely because these customers have reduced outdoor water use. In the lower income group, average household size is a predictor for household water consumption, which increases with more residents. Lower water users are also more sensitive to changes in their first level household water allocation (Tier 1). However, low, medium and high w...