"Snakes Without Poison?": (Re)Negotiating Hybrid Masculinities in Thailand (original) (raw)
Related papers
“Where Men Can Be Men”: Resituating Thai Masculinity
Asian Social Science, 2011
Thailand is the last place left in the world," I was repeatedly told by the Western male sex tourists that I encountered in Thailand, "where men can be men." Indeed, thousands of foreign men flock to this Southeast Asian country every year for its notorious supply of plentiful and inexpensive sex with local prostitutes. Does this mantra also apply to Thai men? This article explores the beginnings of a continuing research project into how the massive influx of foreign male sex tourists during the past forty years has influenced how Thai men perceive their own masculinity.
The present study compares and contrasts some of the etic and emic models that have been employed in order to explain gender and sex in Thailand. Foucault’s concept of bio-power is shown to be inappropriate to explain gender in Thailand. One of the most well known emic models of Thai culture, the decha-khuna model developed by Niels Mulder is expanded to explain gender and sex in Thailand and is shown to be more appropriate than etic models derived from different socio-historical circumstances. The paper concludes that the Thai concept of gender revolves around the dimensions of degree of domestication of the sphere of existence in which the person mostly operates and of the relative moral goodness of the person’s role rather than being centered on sexual preference.
Conceptualizing Thai Genderscapes: Transformation and Continuity in the Thai Sex/Gender System
Contemporary Socio-Cultural and Political Perspectives in Thailand, 2014
In this chapter, I expand on the notion of “-scape” (Appadurai 1996: 33) in conceptualizing genderscapes in Thailand, which can act as a case study in developing genderscapes elsewhere. I argue for the conceptualization of a Thai sex/gender system, or genderscapes, based on five key gender categories. I explore the cultural logics of naming and transformations in meaning ascribed to gender-variant people and describe the contemporary genderscapes, or the conceptual distribution of gender/sexuality forms in everyday practice as they are conditioned by fields of uneven power. I contend that genderscapes provide an enhanced theorization of contemporary Thai gender categories. The lines between tom : woman : kathoey : gay : man are neither clear nor fixed, but coalesce around these key formations. These categories are grounded via the repetition and ritualization of routine practices in everyday life as they appear to others but also remain fluid in that gender performances exceed their intentions and interpretations.
Representing nakleng: modernity, media and masculinities in Thailand (1948-2018)
2019
This thesis presents a cultural history of the representation of nakleng − a traditional masculine figure that is rebranded and popularised in Thai popular culture − from 1948 to 2018. It argues that the tension between an emerging media industry's desire to commoditise the fantasy of a heroic nakleng, and the state's aspiration to criminalise and demonise the same figure, accounts for the pluralized and dynamic form of nakleng portrayals in various popular media. The study finds that nakleng figure in popular media represents the everchanging Thai masculine identity across seven decades in the local, national and global levels.
2000 An explosion of Thai identities: global queering and re-imagining queer theory 1
This paper reflects on recent research on Thai discourses of gender and eroticism in order to problematize some of the universalist assumptions that have dominated discussion of the international proliferation of forms of erotic diversity. By mapping the proliferation of Thai gender/sex categories from the 1960s to the 1980s, the paper shows that Thai homoeroticisms are not converging towards Western models and points to the cultural limits of Foucauldian-modelled histories of sexuality. In particular, it demonstrates the inability of Foucauldian history of sexuality, and queer theoretical approaches drawing on Foucault, to account for shifts in Thai discourses in which gender and sexuality do not exist as distinct categories. Only when current feminist theories of gender and queer theories of sexuality are integrated so as to offer a unified account of the eroticization of gender, and the gendering of eroticism, will Western theoretical models be capable of mapping shifts in non-Western patterns of eroticism.
2012
In Thailand, genderscapes, or the terrain of gender and sexuality, continue to evolve quickly, with male-to-female transgenderisms and effeminate gay identities proliferating alongside masculine ones. The previous coding of kathoey in popular discourse as being traditional is shifting to one that identifies ‘‘kathoeyness’’, or male effeminacy, with modernity. Recent incidents point to a discursive shift based on a purified nostalgia for Thai ‘‘tradition’’, which excises kathoey presence. In this article, I consider how social evaluation and moral legitimacy underscore the contemporary terrain of gender/sexuality and contradictory attitudes towards kathoeyness. I describe how the increasing visibility of male effeminacy provokes national anxiety, becomes associated with degeneracy, and is used to excise non-normative gender from recent reconstructions of Thainess.
Walailak Journal of Social Science, 2021
Based on Judith Butler's account of the performative construction of gender, this study uses a qualitative research method to analyse genderings performed by Thai gay men. The key finding is that Thai gay men are especially flexible in their gender play and performances of both effeminacy and masculinity in the various social situations in their daily lives as well as in their romantic relationships and sexual encounters. In addition to gendered forms of comportment and behaviour, a further important dimension of Thai gay men's multiple performances of gender is through the use of masculine and feminine forms of language. Thai gay men use gendered language forms to communicate and express both effeminacy and masculinity within their circles of gay friends and acquaintances. This study broadens our understanding of how gay Thai men exhibit differently gendered identities from Western gay men. It also counters the stereotypical negative image by which gay men are often stigmatised and labeled as not being masculine. Thai gay male identity is not based on a firm separation of femininity from masculinity. Rather, alternation between masculine and feminine forms of behaviour and language permits Thai gay men to adapt their public social and private sexual relations according to the different kinds of people they meet and interact with in the different domains of their lives.