Cultivation of Moral Concern in Theravada Buddhism: Toward a Theory of the Relation Between Tranquility and Insight (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Nature of Buddhist Ethics and its Implications to Meditation 1
In this paper the author tries to understand the character of Buddhist ethics, with its individual and social aspects and bring out the implications of Buddhist ethics to Buddhist meditation. Having tried to bring out the anti-dogmatic rational character of Buddhist ethics, he argues that the latter can be called consequentialist and utilitarian. Since Buddhism emphasises the roots of ethical and unethical actions in mind and hence accepts purification of mind as the moral goal, Buddhist theory of meditation can be understood as an extension of the Buddhist moral psychology, as an important aid to moral purification of mind rather than as a means to the achievement of a metaphysical goal. Similarly the arhat ideal as well as the bodhisattva ideal can be understood as the forms of moral perfection with meditative realisation of the goal as one of its dimensions.
19. Virtues without Rules Ethics in the Insight Meditation Movement
2019
Virtues without Rules: Ethics in the Insight Meditation Movement Gil Fronsdal tradition's teachings on lay ethics were addressed to people who, by and large, did not meditate. Teachings to the laity did not, therefore, emphasize a relationship between ethics and meditation. Lay ethics was advocated by stressing the benefits and merits, or the harm and demerits, that various actions would bring in this or future lives. For the majority of Western lay Insight Meditation practitioners, however, the ideas of merit and rebirth hold little sway. Rather, meditation is the primary Buddhist activity providing the basis for understanding Buddhist teachings. How then, does the movement view the relationship between meditation and ethical behavior? The next section will give a general introduction to the Insight Meditation movement, including a definition. This is followed by a study of the movement's ethical teachings, including a detailed discussion of the role of the five lay precepts. While these precepts do not always have a prominent role, the way they are handled provides a useful reference for understanding the movement's approach to ethics. THE INSIGHT MEDITATION MOVEMENT Currently no clear institutional, doctrinal, or membership boundaries exist for the wide range of Western practitioners of the Theravāda practice of vipassanā, that is, the meditative cultivation of undistracted, and at times highly concentrated, attentiveness to what is being experienced in the present. However, the subject of this study and what I am calling the Insight Meditation movement are those vipassanā practitioners, teachers, institutions, and publications with either formal or close informal affiliation with the Insight Meditation Society (IMS) in Barre, Massachusetts, and Spirit Rock Meditation Center in Marin County, California. This includes the meditation centers and sitting groups led by teachers or practitioners affiliated with these two. IMS and Spirit Rock are the most visible and active vipassanā centers in North America. Furthermore, the largest, best-organized and most clearly bounded groups of Western vipassanā teachers are those associated with these centers. 1 In defining the Insight Meditation movement in this way, it is important to recognize that this definition might obscure some real differences in teachings among the movement's teachers. It is also important to remember that this Insight Meditation movement is a subset of a much larger movement of vipassanā teachers in the West. On one end of a broad spectrum are Theravāda monks and nuns teaching the practice within the religious context of their Theravāda temples. On the other end are people with no personal affiliation with, or even interest in, Buddhism, who teach Theravāda-derived mindfulness practices in such secular applications as pain and stress reduction. In between are many people and centers teaching the practice independent of any affiliation with the Insight
Foundations for Developing Buddhist Tranquility (Śamatha) and Insight (Vipaśyanā) Meditation 童蒙止观
Awaken Publishing & Design, 2020
It is said that the Foundations for Developing Buddhist Tranquility (Śamatha) and Insight (Vipaśyanā) Meditation was originally a lecture delivered by Master Zhìyǐ (智觊 538—597 CE) to instruct his lay, elder brother Chén Zhēn 陈针 on how to practise meditation. The Foundations is an introductory meditation manual rather than a book. It is short. Yet, it provides a practical, accessible and condensed framework for both beginning and long-term meditation practitioners throughout Chinese Buddhist history up until today.
Mindfulness, the Buddha, and Naturalism Introduction: Buddhism, Mindfulness, and Science
Under review, 2020
The success of the Buddhist-inspired concept of mindfulness and of interventions based on it, both in psychological practice and in basic research, suggests that parts of the Buddha's teaching should be compatible with the results of contemporary science. Nevertheless, there has been considerable controversy regarding both the relationship between the Dhamma and supernaturalism, and between mindfulness, Buddhism, and science. In this context, the present paper first argues against claims that the supernatural is inextricably interwoven with the Buddha's teaching. It then considers two recent attempts to understand the dharma in a contemporary framework: a brief discussion of Johannes Bronkhorst's reading of the Buddha's teaching in psychoanalytical terms is offered, and a more extended discussion of Stephen Batchelor's `Secular Buddhism.´ Concerning the latter, it is argued that, despite a number of strong points, Batchelor's use of canonical texts is incoherent, and that he makes implicit psychological claims that are reflective of a number of cognitive biases including negativity bias and cognitive dissonance, a discussion which appears also relevant to the wider mindfulness community. The paper then takes a first step towards developing an alternative naturalistic approach by showing that the Ariyapariyesanā Sutta (which has been argued to be the oldest account of the Buddha's enlightenment) both can coherently be read without supernatural occurrences, and presents a dharma free from negativity bias. Finally, the paper sketches how this reading might relate to positive psychology and contemporary psychotherapy.
Although mindfulness has been embraced by the West, this has mostly been a secular “decontextualized” form of mindfulness, disembedded from its original Buddhist nexus of beliefs/practices. This has arguably deprived the practice of its potential to effect more radical psychospiritual development. This article therefore argues for the “recontextualization” of mindfulness, drawing explicitly on Buddhist teachings to enhance our appreciation of it, and offers a contribution to such recontextualization. It presents a novel (in the context of Western psychology) theoretical model of mindfulness, drawing on concepts in Theravada Buddhist literature. In particular, it suggests that Buddhism identifies 3 main “forms” of mindfulness: sati (awareness of the present moment), appamada (awareness suffused with ethical care), and sampajañña (awareness suffused with a sense of spiritual development). Although, currently, only sati has been recognized in the West, we have much to gain from also recognizing the potential ethical and spiritual dimensions of mindfulness.
Mindfulness and Moral Transformation: Awakening to Others in Ś ā ntideva's Ethics
My purpose in this chapter is to present Śāntideva’s ethics as it is embedded in his accounts of the bodhisattva path of moral transformation and mental discipline. I begin with a brief historical introduction to the interdependence of morality, concentration, and insight in Indian Buddhist traditions that is the basis of the bodhisattva ideal and bodhicitta, the awakened mind of wisdom and compassion. I then turn to an explicit discussion of Śāntideva’s account of the perfections of generosity, vigilant moral discipline, forbearance, and vigor. Each of these perfections, I argue, involves the cultivation of moral virtues through the development of a stable, attentive, and compassionate mind. This leads to a more explicit discussion of the fundamental role of mindfulness and the perfection of meditative concentration in Śāntideva’s ethics. For, according to Śāntideva, mindfulness is the very condition for the possibility of pursuing the bodhisattva training. With a stable and attentive mind, it is possible, then, to pursue the perfection of wisdom. Meditating deeply on the wisdom of emptiness, dependent origination, and the distinction between the two truths enables the embodied enacting of this insight in relation with others. Especially important to Śāntideva, this embodied insight allows the aspiring bodhisattva to overcome the fundamental delusion of a separate, substantial self that is at the root of our fearful and confused existence. Śāntideva’s moral thought has elements of both virtue ethics and consequentialism. However, in the end, I argue, his texts are best understood as meditation manuals that, through skillful means, help practitioners facing different situations and with different challenges overcome obstacles to awakening. Because awakening means cultivating particular embodied, skillful, affective, and cognitive ways of being in the world that involve attending with compassionate care to the needs and sufferings of others, the bodhisattva path is fundamentally about moral transformation and the development of moral consciousness.
The Foundations of Buddhist Meditation
Our Heritage (Journal of Sanskrit College and University, Kolkata), 2018
Abstract The Foundations of Buddhist Meditation - P. P. Gokhale Central University of Tibetan Studies, Sarnath The paper is an attempt to grasp the essence of Buddhist meditation from a philosophical point of view. Here the author approaches Buddhist meditation, not from a sectarian Buddhist point of view, but from the point of view of a lay seeker. The paper explores three foundations of Buddhist meditation: ontological, epistemological and moral-psychological. By investigating into different forms of Buddhist meditation, the author observes that the Buddhist meditation is not of unitary nature, but is multifaceted. Different limbs in the Noble 8-limbed path are involved in the different kinds of meditation. Sammāsamādhi, Sammāsati, Sammāditthi and also Sammāsaṅkappo. The paper also deals with the difference between Śamatha and Vipaśyanā and the way Vipaśyanā is understood differently in Yogācāra and Mādhyamika tradition.