HIGH AND LOW BIDS IN TENDERS: STRATEGIC PRICING AND OTHER BIDDING BEHAVIOUR IN PUBLIC TENDERS OF PASSENGER RAILWAY SERVICES (original) (raw)
Related papers
Strategic Pricing by Oligopolists in Public Tenders of Passenger Railway Services
2005
An important component in the deregulation of the public sector in the European Union is public procurement of services and products. This paper studies the bidding behavior of firms participating in public tenders of passenger railway services in Sweden. At a later stage in this research, the intention is to broaden the analysis to include the similar markets of Great Britain and Germany. A general assumption in the paper is that firms sometimes place very low bids and sometimes very high bids in tenders. In a theoretical part of the paper we discuss both these forms of strategic pricing, linked to a discussion on continuous and discontinuous economies of scale regarding costs of production. Detailed data on bids and bidders in Swedish tenders of railway services are then analyzed. About 30 tenders taking place between 1992 and 2003 are included, checking for cases of very low and high bids and other types of deviation within the data material. Among the early results, based upon this rather limited data set, we find that big firms like SJ and Connex tend to place either the lowest or the highest bid when participating in tenders. Connex' bids generally deviate more from the average bid level than the bids from other firms. More data from Sweden and other countries is needed to make further analyses and hypothesis testing applicable. The scarcity of data is in itself an interesting result of the study, since it is caused by efforts of the procuring authorities to protect the "secrets" of the bidders. We argue that this is against the competition policy of the European Union and may harm the tendering process and industry development.
Prague Economic Papers, 2017
The article deals with the econometric analysis on the influence of selected characteristics of public contracts with respect to the decision making of bidders on public contracts regarding submissions to initiate proceedings to review the actions of the contracting authority at the Office for Protection of Competition. Logistic regression was applied to data on public procurement between the years 2007 and 2014, which was combined with the administrative decisions of the Office for the Protection of Competition, in order to identify the factors that affect the likelihood thatthe competitors will be protected against the conduct of the contracting authority by the Office for the Protection of Competition. The article also takes into account the possible obstructive behaviour of candidates, particularly those submissions which were subsequently withdrawn or submissions whose deposits were not paid.
The paradox of competition in a public tender
2007
Abstract: Additional Costs of Purchasing (ACP) are an important part of the whole cost of a transaction. However, the related literature usually addresses these costs from a private organization perspective only. In this paper we extend a previous contribution, proposing a model for a generic transaction including ACP, in a public tender context, and with particular regard to the European legislation.
Transacting under a performance-based contract: The role of negotiation and competitive tendering
Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2008
There is a growing body of theoretical and empirical evidence to support the promotion of awarding mechanisms with formal and informal devices, aimed at economic efficiency and effectiveness through the life of the contract, i.e., ex ante and ex post coordination. Building on growing arguments to support negotiations instead of auctions, Bajari et al. [Bajari, P., McMillan, R., Tadelis, S., 2002. Auctions versus Negotiations in Procurement: An Empirical Analysis, Department of Economics, Stanford University, October] suggest that auctions perform poorly when projects are complex and contractual design is incomplete. Areawide contracts in bus and rail appear to fit this circumstance, in contrast to somewhat simple and relatively unambiguous bus route contracts. This literature argues theoretically and empirically that auctions (i.e., competitive tendering) can stifle communication between buyers (i.e., the regulator) and sellers (i.e., the service provider), preventing the buyer from utilising the contractor's expertise when designing the project. A growing number of authors promote the case for greater emphasis on establishing a credible regulatory scheme able to govern the procurement of public services ex post, and that focusing on introducing market mechanisms via competitive tendering per se does not guarantee better value for money. Implicit in the arguments is the need to develop trusting partnerships and (incomplete) commercial contracts with unambiguous incentive and penalty structures throughout the life of a contract, with market mechanisms such as competitive tendering always present as a way forward when operators fail to comply under reasonable notice. This paper develops these themes as a way of gaining a better understanding of negotiated performance-based contracts.
REDUCING THE COSTS OF PUBLIC TENDERS: A MODEST PROPOSAL
2008
While in the private sector the buyer chooses the number of potential suppliers to involve in an exchange, in the public sector the procedures to follow usually oblige the purchasing manager to behave in a different way. According to the European Directive 2004/18/EC, the Public Administration has to consider all the bids belonging to all the suppliers willing, and able, to take part into the trade. The main purpose of the law is to increase the competitiveness among several bidders in order to reduce the public spending, avoiding monopolistic or oligopolistic behaviours. However the legislator has not taken into account the costs associated with participation in the single tender. In the paper we underline that these costs are relevant and so by limiting the number of bidders it is possible to save money both for the Public Administration and the private sector.
Tendering Design when Price and Quality Is Uncertain : Theory and Evidence from Public Procurement
RePEc: Research Papers in Economics, 2014
Departing from a simple normative theory for the choice between lowest price, highest quality (beauty contest) and more complex scoring rules, we empirically investigate the behavior of local and central authorities. We survey a gross sample of 40 contracting entities about perceived key characteristics of products bought in 651 public procurements and collect data on supplier selection methods for these procurements. We compare actual scoring rules with theoretical norms and analyze what product characteristics make deviation from the norm more or less likely. In addition, a control group of 275 authorities was surveyed about similar but hypothetical procurements. We find that more complex scoring rules are used more often when the authority is uncertain about costs and about delivered quality, in accordance with our hypotheses. However, authority effects are also found to directly and indirectly influence the choice of supplier-selection method, suggesting that tendering design is partially driven by local habits or institutional inertia.
Incentives and award procedures: competitive tendering vs. negotiations in procurement
Handbook of Procurement, 2006
Should the buyer of a customized good use competitive bidding or negotiation to select a contractor? To shed light on this question, we offer a framework that first describes the buyer's choice of contracts, and then links this choice to the selection of competitive tendering or negotiations. The analysis suggests a number of possible limitations to the use of competitive tendering. These may perform poorly when projects are complex, contractual design is incomplete and there are few available bidders. Furthermore, competitive tendering may stifle communication between buyers and sellers, preventing the buyer from utilizing the contractor's expertise when designing the project. Implications of these results for procurement in the private and public sector are discussed. * This is a preliminary version of a future chapter to appear in Dimitri, Piga, and Spagnolo (Eds.) "Handbook of Procurement", forthcoming in Manufactured goods, such as computers, TVs and automobiles are mass produced, have standardized characteristics and are typically purchased at list price. Other goods, such as new buildings, fighter jets, custom software or consulting services are tailored to fit a procurer's specific and often unique needs. To procure these customized goods, the procurer hires a contractor who supplies the good according to a set of desired specifications. We call this the procurement problem.