Mere Intention to Perform Painful Movements Elicits Fear of Movement-Related Pain: An Experimental Study on Fear Acquisition Beyond Actual Movements (original) (raw)
Related papers
PAIN, 2011
Current fear-avoidance models consider fear of pain as a key factor in the development of chronic musculoskeletal pain. Generally, the idea is that by virtue of the formation of associations or acquired propositional knowledge about the relation between neutral movements and pain, these movements may signal pain, and hence start to elicit defensive fear responses (eg, avoidance behavior). This assumption has never been investigated experimentally. Therefore, we developed a pain-relevant fear conditioning paradigm using a movement as a conditioned stimulus (CS) and a painful electrocutaneous stimulus as an unconditioned stimulus (US) to examine the acquisition of fear of movement-related pain in healthy subjects. In a within-subjects design, participants manipulated a joystick to the left/right in the experimental (predictable) condition, and upward/downward in the control (unpredictable) condition or vice versa. In the predictable condition, one movement direction (CS+), and not the other (CSÀ), was followed by painful stimuli. In the unpredictable condition, painful stimuli were always delivered during the intertrial interval. Both fear of movement-related pain ratings and eyeblink startle measures were more elevated in response to the CS+ than to the CSÀ, whereas no differences occurred between both unreinforced CSs in the control condition. Participants were slower initiating a CS+ movement than a CSÀ movement, while response latencies to CSs in the control condition did not differ. These data support the acquisition of fear of movement-related pain by associative learning. Results are discussed in the broader context of the acquisition of pain-related fear in patients with musculoskeletal pain.
PAIN, 2013
Recent evidence indicates that pain-related fear can be acquired through associative learning. In the clinic, however, spreading of fear and avoidance is observed beyond movements/activities that were associated with pain during the original pain episode. One mechanism accounting for this spreading of fear is stimulus generalization. In a voluntary movement-conditioning paradigm, healthy participants received predictable pain (ie, one movement predicts pain, another does not) in one context, and unpredictable pain in another context. The former procedure is known to induce cued pain-related fear to the painful movement, whereas the latter procedure generates contextual pain-related fear. In both experimental pain contexts, we subsequently tested fear generalization to novel movements (having either proprioceptive features in common with the original painful movement or nonpainful movement). Results indicated that in the predictable pain context, pain-related fear spreads selectively to novel movements proprioceptively related to the original painful movement, and not to those resembling the original nonpainful movement. In the unpredictable context, nondifferential fear generalization was observed, suggesting persistent contextual pain-related fear and poor safety learning. These data illustrate that spreading of pain-related fear is fostered by previously acquired movement-pain contingencies. Based on recent advances in anxiety research, we proposed an innovative approach conceptualizing predictable pain as a laboratory model for fear of movement in regional musculoskeletal pain, and unpredictable pain generating contextual pain-related fear as a prototype of widespread musculoskeletal pain. Consequently, fear generalization might play an important role in spreading of pain-related fear and avoidance behavior in regional and widespread musculoskeletal pain.
The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society, 2015
Recent experimental data show that associative learning processes are involved not only in the acquisition but also in the spreading of pain-related fear. Clinical studies suggest involvement of positive affect in resilience against chronic pain. Surprisingly, the role of positive affect in associative learning in general, and in fear generalization in particular, has received scant attention. In a voluntary movement paradigm, in which one arm movement (reinforced conditioned stimulus [CS+]) was followed by a painful stimulus and another was not (unreinforced conditioned stimulus [CS-]), we tested generalization of fear inhibition in response to 5 novel but related generalization movements (GSs; within-subjects) after either a positive affect induction or a control exercise (Group = between-subjects) in healthy participants (N = 50). The GSs' similarity with the original CS+ movement and CS- movement varied. Fear learning was assessed via verbal ratings. Results indicated that t...
Behaviour Research and Therapy, 2012
Excessive fear of movement-related pain (FMRP), and its associated avoidance behavior, is considered a major risk factor for disability in chronic musculoskeletal pain. The current study aimed to investigate whether engaging in safety behavior, conceptualized as an avoidance response, hampers the extinction of FMRP. In a differential conditioning paradigm, we used joystick movements as conditioned stimuli (CSs) and a painful electrocutaneous stimulus as the unconditioned stimulus (US). In the Safety group, participants received the opportunity to avoid the pain-US by pressing a safety button during the extinction phase, whereas in the Control group, this option was not included. In a subsequent test phase, this safety button was no longer available. In two experiments, results demonstrate successful acquisition and extinction. Retrospective FMRP ratings in both experiments revealed a return of fear of pain in the test phase in the Safety group, but not in the Control group. In Experiment 1, mean eyeblink startle reflex amplitudes partly corroborated the self-report findings on fear of pain. The present results suggest that performing safety behavior during cognitive-behavioral interventions, i.e., exposure, might increase the risk of a return of FMRP.
2012
The fear-avoidance model advances fear of pain as a key factor in the origins of chronic pain disability. Initial evidence in those with chronic back pain reveals that exposure therapy reduces fear levels, disability, and pain. Despite the success of exposure in the clinic, fundamental research about its underlying mechanisms lags behind. Using a conditioning paradigm with movements as conditioned stimuli (CS) and a painful shock as unconditioned stimuli (US), we investigated the extinction of experimental fear of movement-related pain and pain-related anxiety (respectively induced by predictable and unpredictable pain). Dependent measures were self-reported fear and eyeblink startle. During acquisition, all groups received both predictable and unpredictable training. In the predictable context, one movement (CS+) was consistently followed by the shock-US, but another movement was not (CSÀ). In the unpredictable context, joystick movements never signaled the shock-US; shock-US were delivered during the intertrial interval (ITI). During extinction, the extinction group continued training in the predictable context but the CS+ movement was no longer reinforced; the context exposure group continued training in the unpredictable context but ITI shock-US were omitted. The control group continued training after the acquisition reinforcement scheme. Results revealed that fear ratings for the CS+ were extinguished in the extinction group but not in the control group. Interestingly, omitting the ITI shocks not only reduced ITI startle responses in the context exposure group compared with the control group, but also reduced the fear ratings and startle responses elicited by the unpredictable CS. The clinical implications of these findings are discussed.
Generalization of Pain-Related Fear Using a Left–Right Hand Judgment Conditioning Task
Behavior Therapy, 2015
Recent research suggests that the mere intention to perform a painful movement can elicit painrelated fear. Based on these findings, the present study aimed to determine whether imagining a movement that is associated with pain (CS+) can start to elicit conditioned pain-related fear as well and whether pain-related fear elicited by imagining a painful movement can spread towards novel, similar but distinct imagined movements. We proposed a new experimental paradigm that integrates the left-right hand judgment task (HJT) with a differential fear conditioning procedure. During Acquisition, one hand posture (CS+) was consistently followed by a painful electrocutaneous stimulus (pain-US) and another hand posture (CS-) was not. Participants were instructed to make left-right judgments, which involve mentally rotating their own hand to match the displayed hand postures (i.e. motor imagery). During Generalization, participants were presented with a series of novel hand postures with six grades of perceptual similarity to the CS+ (generalization stimuli; GSs). Finally, during Extinction, the CS+ hand posture was no longer reinforced. The results showed that (1) a painful hand posture triggers fear and increased US-expectancy as compared to a non-painful hand posture, (2) this pain-related fear spreads to similar but distinct hand postures following a generalization gradient, and subsequently, (3) it can be successfully reduced during extinction. These effects were apparent in the verbal ratings, but not in the startle measures.
Threatening Social Context Facilitates Pain-Related Fear Learning
The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society, 2014
This study investigated the effects of a threatening and a safe social context on learning pain-related fear, a key factor in the development and maintenance of chronic pain. We measured self-reported pain intensity, pain expectancy, pain-related fear (verbal ratings and eyeblink startle responses), and behavioral measures of avoidance (movement-onset latency and duration) using an established differential voluntary movement fear conditioning paradigm. Participants (N = 42) performed different movements with a joystick: during fear acquisition, movement in one direction (CS+) was followed by a painful stimulus (pain-US) whereas movement in another direction (CS-) was not. For participants in the threat group, an angry face was continuously presented in the background during the task, whereas in the safe group, a happy face was presented. During the extinction phase the pain-US was omitted. As compared to the safe social context, a threatening social context led to increased contextu...
The opportunity to avoid pain may paradoxically increase fear
The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society, 2018
Fear-avoidance models propose that pain-related fear may spur avoidance behaviour leading to chronic pain disability. Pain-related fear elicits avoidance behaviour, which is typically aimed at reducing fear. We hypothesized that engaging in avoidance may (paradoxically) increase rather than decrease pain-related fear (i.e. bidirectionality hypothesis). In a between-subject design, participants (N=64) were randomly assigned to the avoidance group or the control group. Avoidance group participants were led to believe they could avoid full exposure to a painful heat stimulus by pressing the stop-button, while control group participants believed they were exposed to the full painful heat stimulus at all times. In reality and unknown to the participants, the intensity and duration of the heat stimulus was independent of the avoidance response, and was identical in both groups. During the test, the avoidance response (i.e. pressing the stop-button) was no longer available. As expected, pa...
Pain, 2020
Nonspecific chronic low back pain (CLBP) is a multifactorial disorder. Pain-related fear and altered movement preparation are considered to be key factors in the chronification process. Interactions between both have been hypothesized, but studies examining the influence of situational fear on movement preparation in low back pain (LBP) are wanting, as well as studies differentiating between recurrent LBP (RLBP) and CLBP. Therefore, this study examined whether experimentally induced painrelated fear influences movement preparation. In healthy controls (n 5 32), RLBP (n 5 31) and CLBP (n 5 30) patients central and peripheral measures of movement preparation were assessed by concurrently measuring trunk muscle anticipatory postural adjustments (APA) with electromyography and contingent negative variation with EEG during performance of rapid arm movements. Two conditions were compared, one without (no fear) and one with (fear) possibility of painful stimulation to the back during rapid arm movements. Visual analogue scales were used to assess pain-related expectations/fear in both conditions. The experimentally induced fear of pain during movement performance led to an increase in contingent negative variation amplitude, which was similar in all 3 groups. Concerning APAs, no effects of fear were found, but group differences with generally delayed APAs in CLBP compared with controls and RLBP patients were evident. These results suggest that with fear, an attentional redirection towards more conscious central movement preparation strategies occurs. Furthermore, differences in movement preparation in patients with RLBP and CLBP exist, which could explain why patients with RLBP have more recovery capabilities than patients with CLBP.