Economic development of the early modern China: A revisiting (original) (raw)
2015, paper presented at the World Economic History Congress, Kyoto
Recently, many Japanese have been shocked by the fact that the GDP of China had exceeded that of Japan, and that China had overtaken Japan as the world’s second-largest economy. This would further encourage economic historians of China to reevaluate potential of China’s economy, even before its encounter with the West. In this paper, I argue that i) in the recent China’s economic historiography, scholars have been increasingly focusing on quantitative changes, rather than qualitative and transformative “development”. This can be interpreted in the context of the important shift in social thoughts after the collapse of post-Cold War regime, and in the evolutional development in the cliometrics. ii) recent findings in quantitative history are best culminated in the historical statistics compiled by Angus Maddison, including those of pre-modern China. Maddison’s studies have made a great contribution: He incorporates the experiences of China into global economic historiography, in a way which encourages the comparison beyond time and space, and empirical and cross-disciplinal discussion as well. Yet the credibility of statistical records (and estimation itself) on population and productivity, for example, are still opened to debate. iii) one of the most critical issues is that most of the arguments in comparative history obviously resort to a conventional essentialism to understand the economic growth in pre-modern China, in which monotonous “institutions” are often identified as explanatory variables.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Related papers
A Review and Reflection on the Historiography of 18 TH – 20 TH Century China
2004
This article surveys major themes on the latest revisionist thesis of economic growth in China during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. With an emphasis on the role of informal and formal institutions to economic growth, this article reviews the traditional legal system and its impact on the organizational evolution of major Chinese merchant groups. It argues that, to understand the distinctive path of long-term economic growth or stagnation in China, we need to go beyond the study of resource endowments or technologies, to also incorporate an economic analysis of China’s traditional social and political institutions and their associated ideologies.
International Review of Social History, 1988
SummaryDuring the last 15 years or so, the study of Chinese history in the United States and Europe has been transformed through new foci of interest as well as the employment of social science methodologies. This article surveys a selected number of recent publications and categorizes them according to five themes: “commoners, women, and outsiders”, “the structural approach”, “state and society”, “China and l'histoire globale”, and “China and the West”. It is demonstrated that the continuities within Chinese development, including the progressive demographic expansion of the Chinese population, the formulation and exercise of gentry rulership, the general vigour of the economy, and increased regional and subregional agricultural/industrial production and distribution are not confined to specific dynastic periods and should be viewed in a long-term context.
Unfolding the Turbulent Century: A Reconstruction of China's Economic Development, 1840-1912
2016
This paper reconstructs China's economic development between 1840 and 1912 with an estimation of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). It provides for the first time a time series of GDP (per capita) for the late Qing Dynasty (1644-1911), based on sectoral output and value added, in current as well as in constant prices. The present estimation of per capita GDP in the late Qing period comes out higher than previous estimations, but it still suggests low average levels of Chinese living standards. The economy during the late Qing Empire was characterised by a large and growing agricultural sector and displayed only minor structural changes. Only in the beginning of the twentieth century did the economy start to show signs of growth.
The Developing Economies, 2012
When the Chief Economist and Senior Vice President of the World Bank publishes a book on China's economic development based on his lectures notes for the course on China's economic development and transition at Peking University, one may rightfully be curious about how he will explain China to us. And one will not be disappointed. His economics arguments are fascinating and he is a superb storyteller: he points out a puzzle, attacks it from all sides, and argues his way to an answer. The book takes a broad historical perspective and paints a seamless picture of China's economic development since premodern times. An introductory chapter on opportunities and challenges in China's economic development is followed by chapters on the cornerstones of China's economic development: why the industrial revolution did not occur in China, the Socialist Revolution (and its failings), and three chapters on the comparativeadvantage-defying vs. comparative-advantage-following development strategy as they apply to Maoist and reform-period China. The second half of the book is devoted to individual topics of current interest: rural reform, urban reform, state-owned enterprise reform, financial sector reform, the new socialist countryside, and harmonious development. The book closes with reflections on neoclassical theory and an appendix on global imbalances. Much of the first half of the book draws on earlier publications by Justin Lin in academic journals, here revised for a broader audience and with new insights added. These are solid ideas that have become widely accepted in the study of the Chinese economy, and Justin Lin packs quite some punch. His "general theory of economic transition and development" (p. 3) begins with an explanation of why China for many centuries was the technological leader in the world but then lost out to Western powers: China was ahead when innovation was based on experience (and the widespread adoption of experience-based innovation), for the simple reason that China had such a large population, i.e., more scope for experience. The West later pulled ahead because of the scientific revolution which allowed it to overcome the limits of experience with mathematics and controlled experiments. Justin Lin advances plausible reasons for the absence of a scientific revolution in China. But as is often the case in the social sciences, Justin Lin's theory cannot be proven. To prove his point, one would need a controlled experiment with several countries that are perfectly identical except that some are randomly assigned a bias towards math, and others are randomly assigned a bias towards the Chinese classics. All he can do is argue convincingly, which he does. At the core of his theory of economic transition and development is the distinction between comparative-advantage-defying and comparative-advantage-following transition
Outlines how as a result of a chance meeting with Professor Mao Yushi in Toronto, Canada in 1986 I was subsequently invited to visit China to give lectures at Nankai University in Tianjin (which I did in 1989). This visit was extended by my being awarded an Exchange Fellowship Academy of Social Sciences in Australia and the Australian Academy of Humanities in conjunction with the Chinese Academy of Social Science (CASS). This enabled me to make further contact with Mao Yushi who was Professor of American Studies at that time. Presentations of papers and academic contacts were made at various centres of learning in Wuhan, Xian and Beijing. One of the results of my visit to China was the publication of my book Economic Development in the Context of China. This was put online in 2011 by Palgrave Macmillan. The nature and genesis of this book is outlined, together with my experiences in China in 1989 and the sequel to my visit. The sequel includes subsequent visits to The University of Queensland of several Chinese economists, including Mao Yushi, my involvement in several research projects focused on China, as well as several articles dealing with Chinese economic and environmental issues. Some biographical information about Mao Yushi and Clem Tisdell is also included in this article.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.