‘Meet the New Boss... Same as the Old boss?’ Technology, toil and tension in the agrofuel frontier (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Political Economy of Agrofuels in Brazil and the Contested Meaning of Sustainable Development
In the face of rapid global warming and peak oil, agrofuels have been increasingly seen as a way of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from transport. This dissertation examines the political economy of agrofuels in Brazil. The study of Brazilian agrofuels is paradigmatic as the country has more than thirty years of experience and is one of the world's technological leaders in agrofuels. The Brazilian government has been promoting agrofuels as a path towards sustainable development at home and in other developing countries. In order to assess whether Brazilian agrofuels bring about sustainable development, this work discusses the contested meaning of sustainable development. It draws on principles of intergenerational, intragenerational and international distributive justice as defined by the Brundtland Report to elaborate a working definition of sustainable development as a multidimensional construct comprising six interdependent pillars. Thus, the Brazilian agrofuels strategy is analysed against the environmental, economic, social, political, cultural and spatial dimensions of sustainable development. The study argues that in its current shape and scale, the agrofuels strategy is boosting economic growth and promoting Brazil as a global player, yet it is not bringing about sustainable development.
Social sustainability of the Brazilian bioethanol: Power relations in a centre-periphery perspective
Biomass and Bioenergy, 2011
Power Biofuel Brazil a b s t r a c t While the environmental and economic dimensions of sustainability have received plenty of attention in biofuel policies and assessment, only recently has the social 'pillar' gained increasing weight, demonstrated e.g. by debates over the dilemmas such as food vs. fuel and large vs. small-scale biofuel production. This paper calls for greater attention to power relations when assessing biofuel policies. A centre-periphery framework is applied for examining power relations in the Brazilian sugar and alcohol sector since the launching of the country's transport biofuel programme, Proá lcool, in 1975. Particular attention is paid to the country's poor Northeast, today responsible for a small fraction of bioethanol production in Brazil, but highly dependent on its sugar and alcohol sector for employment and economic output. The analysis demonstrates the pervasive role of unequal and rigid power relations in shaping Proá lcool's social impacts. The small sugar elite in the Northeast has increased its power and protected itself against market instability by diversifying its activity, while the benefits have failed to trickle down to the poorest in the sugarcane zone in the Northeast coast. The recent and on-going entry of new players in the Brazilian biofuel scene may provide opportunities of breaking the entrenched power structures and
Futures, 2018
The prospects of agro-neoliberalism in Brazil are analyzed through a critical reading of tendencies, technoeconomic strategies and political disputes. Qualitative information, obtained in successive fieldwork campaigns, was used to assess trends and structure uncertainty. Empirical data also helped to describe three future scenarios that oscillate between the continuation of current agro-neoliberal trends (facilitated by the appropriation of sustainability and innovation agendas), the return of strong state interventions or the decline and eventual collapse of the agribusiness sector (due to sanitary risks or politico-economic reactions). The overall conclusion is that it is difficult to envisage the emergence of any radical alternative focused on agrarian justice or the production of basic food. Alternative developments would require a strong coordination of national and international social groups and political will to construct a different future for farmers, consumers and wider society.
Sugarcane Ethanol: The Hen of the Golden Eggs? Agribusiness and the State in Lula's Brazil
This book chapter was published in Spronk, S. and J. Webber (2014), Crisis and Contradiction. Marxist Perspectives on Latin America in the Global Political Economy, Leiden, Brill. It examines the role of the state in the rise and development of the sugarcane ethanol industry in Brazil. It shows how the state was a key source of funding for the industry, a mediator in labour relations, as well as driver of the internationalisation process. Theoretically, it makes two contributions: 1) it questions the idea of the developmental state, and 2) it highlights the importance of discourse and social representation in the early creation of markets, a phase which still characterises biofuels.
Journal of Rural Studies, 2018
This paper analyzes the politics of oil palm expansion and state intervention in the Brazilian Amazonian state of Pará. The Workers' Party (PT) envisioned moving away from previous neoliberal policies by using state support to facilitate the coexistence and synergetic nexus between the state, family farmers and agribusiness, through the Sustainable Oil Palm Production Program (PPSOP) launched in 2010. Using a Gramscian approach, we examine PT's ability to impose its hegemonic project and the contradictions that emerged from its efforts to ease capital accumulation and to support marginalized family farmers to legitimize oil palm expansion. We argue that, in light of the articulations and fragmentation generated in the PPSOP intervention, the PT played a key role in providing a common framework that facilitated oil palm expansion in which all the actors involved could find a response to their claims. While agribusiness moved to participate in PPSOP to legitimatize the monoculture of palm in international markets and to create the material and infrastructural conditions for monocrop expansion, family farmers and popular movements granted support to this intervention based upon concerns for land access and titling, and with the hopes for alternative agricultural activities and job creation to improve their livelihoods. We show, however, that PPSOP intervention works to reinforce large-scale production and exclude family farmers and popular movements by promoting the concentration of land ownership and failing to improve the terms of incorporation of marginalized actors in the oil palm chain.
Sustainability
The bioeconomy transition is a double-edged sword that may either address fossil fuel dependence sustainably or aggravate human pressures on the environment, depending on how it is pursued. Using the emblematic case of Brazil, this article analyzes how corporate agribusiness dominance limits the bioeconomy agenda, shapes innovation pathways, and ultimately threatens the sustainability of this transition. Drawing from scholarship on power in agri-food governance and sustainability transitions, an analytical framework is then applied to the Brazilian case. The analysis of current policies, recent institutional changes and the case-specific literature reveals that, despite a strategic framing of the bioeconomy transition as a panacea for job creation, biodiversity conservation and local development (particularly for the Amazon region), in practice major soy, sugarcane and meatpacking conglomerates dominate Brazil’s bioeconomy agenda. In what can be described as conservative ecological ...
Encroachment and entrenchment of agro-neoliberalism in the Centre-West of Brazil
Journal of Rural Studies, 2017
From being a net food importer in recent decades, Brazil is now considered a successful case of agricultural production and export. However, this image of triumph and efficiency helps to conceal growing socio-ecological impacts and mounting uneasiness. The complex and contradictory landscape of contemporary Brazilian agribusiness represent a relevant example of the advance of agro-neoliberalism, which is both an economic and technological process of agriculture modernization and intensification, in accordance to liberalizing pressures, and also a politico-ecological phenomenon centred on market-based solutions to old and new production, innovation and justification questions. Based on qualitative research and three fieldwork campaigns, the article discusses recent politico-economic adjustments particularly in the State of Mato Grosso, in the Centre-West region, which is fast becoming the main area of agribusiness activity in the country. Empirical results demonstrate that agro-neoliberalism has been promoted through inventive public-private associations not for the purpose of domestic food security, but primarily for capital accumulation and to support sectoral interests and macroeconomic strategies.
Tapuya: Latin American Science, Technology and Society, 2021
The Green Revolution exemplifies the capital-intensive modernisation model of resource plunder and labour exploitation. This has provoked small-scale producers and civil society groups to counterpose an agroecology-based solidarity economy (EcoSol-agroecology), especially in Latin America. But their efforts encounter dominant models – of innovation, management, markets, nature, etc. – which limit alternatives. To clarify a transformative agenda, advocates have elaborated agroecological innovation through several complementary practices. Nature is framed as agri-biodiversity complementing socio-cultural diversity. Short food-supply chains (circuitos curtos) build consumer support for production methods enhancing producers’ livelihoods, providing socio-economic equity and conserving natural resources. Through diálogos de saberes, i.e. knowledge exchange among farmers and with external experts, cultivation and water-management methods are designed or adapted as socio-environmental technologies. Capacities are built for collective self-management of those solidarity relationships. In such ways, agroecological innovation co-produces specific forms of nature, technoscientific knowledge and society; their practices construct a distinctive socionatural order. Such order arises through several instruments – making identities, institutions and discourses – as understood by STS co-production theory. Here it illuminates two Brazilian agroforestry initiatives whose cooperative practices seek to transform their own participants’ lives and wider agri-food systems. By combining diverse sources, composite cultures deepen the social basis of territorial belonging.
Antipode, 2020
In this paper, I examine the speculative dimensions of biodiesel production in Northeast Brazil under the National Program for the Production and Use of Biodiesel (PNPB), by focusing on the case of castor oil plant (Ricinus communis) in semi‐arid Bahia, a promising flex crop that was said to generate social, environmental and economic benefits, especially for the historically marginalised Northeast peasantry. I argue that speculative practices over castor have relied on state policies and discourses as well as biophysical and biotechnological (im)materialities that are transforming agrarian relations in ways that compromise peasants’ control over their (re)productive systems while promoting the expansion of the agroindustrial frontier. By examining the everyday, performative and place‐based character of speculative biodiesel practices and their uneven and contested socioenvironmental implications, this paper contributes to current political ecology debates on the nexus between agroenergy development, nature’s capitalist valuation and rural dispossession.