Seeking Barriers to the Development of Knowledge Transgressivity Potential (KTP): Lessons from a Postgraduate Student Survey at The University of Johannesburg (original) (raw)

Abstract

ABSTRACT Institutional mergers coupled with the distinction between teaching-focused ‘comprehensives’ and traditional, research-intensive universities are evidence of differentiation in action within South African higher education. Comprehensive institutions such as the University of Johannesburg (UJ) are relatively underresearched. A UJ-based survey of postgraduate students (n=300) suggests the possibility of knowledge transgressivity within and outside of UJ. However, the development of a transdisciplinary platform [to facilitate the evolu tion of knowledge transgressivity potential (KTP)] between natural and social science-focused postgraduates, is likely limited by perceptual class and race barriers, with the former proving most influential. Moreover, inter institutional KTP between UJ, as a comprehensive, and WITS, as a traditional university, is present, but limited by material class barriers, such as fees differentials. Nevertheless, findings suggest that KTP could be developed at the junior postgraduate level if class perceptions and structural legacies are to be overcome. Comprehensives like UJ are capable of more than solely fulfilling an undergraduate teaching function as such, they should enjoy more research attention. While all South African universities contribute to transformation and competitiveness in distinct ways, the rigid demarcation, and potentially inadvertent ‘privileging’ of some South African universities, should be avoided. This is critical as such demarcation cannot lead to long-term institutional integration and increased potential for true knowledge transgressivity.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (40)

  1. Aitchison J 2004. Lifelong learning in South Africa: Dreams and delusions. International Journal of Life- long Education, 23(6): 517-544.
  2. Arnolds CA, Stofile R, Lillah R 2013. Assessing the outcomes of the higher education mergers in South Africa: Implications for strategic management. Acta Commercii, 13(1): 1-11.
  3. Brink E 2010. University of Johannesburg: The Uni- versity for a New Generation. Johannesburg: Jacana Media.
  4. Bunting I 2006. The higher education landscape under apartheid: T ransformation in Higher Education. Higher Education Dynamics, 10: 35-52.
  5. CHET South African Higher Education Open Data 2012. Fromhttp://www.chet.org.za/data/sahe-open-data (Retrieved on 10 September 2014).
  6. Cloete N 2011. South Africa: Radical New Plan for Higher Education. From <http://www. university- worldnews. com/article. php? story= 201 112 02 22252975.> (Retrieved on 25 March 2013).
  7. Cloete N, Bunting I 2013. Strengthening Knowledge Production in Universities: Five South African Case Studies. Cape Town: OECD.
  8. Collins A, Loots L, Meyiwa T, Mistrey D 2009. No- body's business: Proposals for reducing gender-based violence at a South African university. Agenda: Empowering Women For Gender Equity, 23(80): 3 3 -4 1 .
  9. Cooper D 2011. The University in Development: Case Stud ies of Use-oriented Research. Ca pe Town: HSRC Press.
  10. Cooper D 2014. Social Justice and South African Uni- versity Student Enrolment Data by 'Race' 1988- 1998-2008: From 'Skewed Revolution' to 'Stalled Revolution'. Paper presented at the South African Sociological Association (SASA) Annual Congress, 6-8 July 2014, Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Uni- versity, Port Elizabeth.
  11. Deacon R, Osman R, Buchler M 2010. Education pol- icy studies in South Africa, 1995-2006. Journal of Education Policy, 25(1): 95-110.
  12. Dugmore H 2013. Measuring Success. A South African University League Table. The WITS Review, Janu- ary 2013, P. 13.
  13. Erasmus D 2006. Living the future now: 'Race' and challenges of transformation in higher education. South African Journal of Higher Education, 20(3): 5 1 -6 3 .
  14. Frick L, Bitzer E, Leibowitz B 2007. Integrating as- sessment and recognition of prior learning in South African higher education: A university case study. Education as Change, 11(2): 131-155.
  15. Gibbons M, Limoges C, Nowotny H, Schwartzman S, Scott P, Trow M 1 994. The New Produ ction of Knowledge: The Dynamics of Science and Research in Contemporary Societies. Berkeley: Sage Publi- ca tions. HEMIS 2012. Data was from the CHET Website. From <http://chet.org.za/data .> (Retrieved on 12 Sep- tember 2012).
  16. Henkel M 2005. Academic identity and autonomy in a changing policy environment. Higher Education, 49(1-2): 155 -176.
  17. Jansen J 2009. Knowledge in the Blood: Confronting Race and the Apartheid Past. Cape Town: Univer- sity of Cape Town Press.
  18. Kay L, Youtie J, Shapira P 2014. Inter-industry Knowl- edge Flows and Sectoral Networks in the Economy of Malaysia. Knowledge Management Research and Practice. From <http://www.palgrave-journals.com/ kmrp/jou rna l/vaop/ncurrent/abs/kmrp 201 430 a. html> (Retrieved on 12 September 2014).
  19. Kraak A 2000. Changing Modes: New Knowledge Pro- duction and its Implications for Higher Education in South Africa. Pretoria: HSRC Press.
  20. Kruss G 2008. Balancing old and new organisational forms: Changing dynamics of government, indus- try and university interaction in South Africa. Tech- nology, Analysis and Strategic Management, 20(6): 6 67 -6 82 .
  21. Kruss G 2012. Reconceptualising engagement: A con- ceptual framework for analysing university inter- action with external social partners. South African Review of Sociology, 43 (2): 5-26.
  22. Leibowitz B, Swartz L, Bozalek V, Carolissen R, Nicholls L, Rohleder P. 2012. Community, Self and Identi- ty: Educating South African University Students for Citizenship. Pretoria: HSRC Press.
  23. Letseka M, Maile S 2008. High University Drop-out Rates: A Threat to South Africa's Future. HSRC, South Africa, Policy Brief.
  24. Mapasela M, Hay HR 2005. Through the magnifying glass: A descriptive theoretical analysis of possible impact of the South African higher education pol- icies on academic staff and their job satisfaction. Higher Education, 50: 111-128.
  25. McLean M, Walker M 2012. The possibilities for uni- versity-based public-good professional education: A case-study from South Africa based on the 'capa- bility approach'. Studie s in Hig her Educ atio n, 37(5): 585-601.
  26. Mêgnigbêto E 2014. Efficiency, unused capacity and transmission power as indicators of the Triple He- lix of u niversity-industry-government rela tion- ships. Journal of Informetrics, 8(1): 284-294.
  27. Mgqibela L 2008. Comprehensive University Reality, 'Fraught and Complicated'. University World News, Issue 1, 29 January 2008. National Development Plan (NDP) 2011. South Afri- can National Planning Commission. From <http:// www.ncponline.co.za.> (Retrieved on 15 January 2 01 3).
  28. Nowotny H 2003. The Potential of Transdisciplinarity. Article 5 in Rethinking Interdisciplinarity Online Conference. Manuscript in authors'possession.
  29. Nowotny H, Scott P, Gibbons M 2003. Introduction: 'Mode 2' revisited: The new production of knowl- edge. Minerva, 41(3): 179-194.
  30. Reddy T 2004. Higher Education and Social Transfor- mation: South Africa Case Study. Pretoria: Coun- cil for Higher Education.
  31. Rothearmel FT,Thursby M 2005. University-incuba- tor firm knowledge flows: Assessing their impact on incubator firm performance. Research Policy, 34: 305-320.
  32. SAQA-Summary Lists of all Registered Qualifications and Unit Standards -August 2014. From <http:// www.saqa.org.za/show.php?id=5677>(Retrieved on 15 September 2014).
  33. Seepe S 2010. South Africa: Reflections on a Major Merger. University World News. Issue 67, 28 No- vember 2010.
  34. Singh M 2008. Valuing differentiation as a qualified good: The case of South African higher education. Higher Education Policy, 21: 245-263.
  35. Soudien C 2010. Entering the gates of the elect: Ob- taining the doctorate in education in South Africa. In: P Thomson, M Walker (Eds.): The Routledge Doctoral Student's Companion: Getting to Grips with Research in Education and the Social Scienc- es. London and New York : Routledge, pp. 116- 12 7.
  36. VanVught F 2007. Diversity and Differentiation in High- er Education Systems. Paper presented at the CHET Anniversary Conference, Cape Town, November 2007.
  37. Van Zyl A, Amadi-Echendu J, Bothma TJD 2007. Nine drivers of knowledge transfer between universities and industry R&D partners in South Africa. South African Journal of Information Management, 9(1): 1-2 2.
  38. Walker M 2012. Universities, professional capabilities and contributions to the public good in South Afri- ca. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and In- ternational Education, 42(6): 819-838.
  39. Winberg C 2006. Undisciplining knowledge produc- tion: Development driven higher education in South Africa. Higher Education, 51(2): 159-172.
  40. Wyngaard A, Kapp C 2004. Rethinking and re-imagin- ing mergers in further and higher education: A hu- man perspective. South African Journal of Higher Education, 18(1): 185-201.