The frantic gesture of interpassivity: Maintaining the separation between the corporate and authentic self (original) (raw)
Related papers
Contemplation and the 'Performative Absolute': submission and identity in managerial modernity
Practices derived from the 'vita contemplativa' and other spiritual sources are drawn upon by management, but as the power of human resources management (HRM) is extended so the relationship between 'contemplation' and the surrender of self-identity required by HRM demands critical examination. The conscious construction of the individual has become a social and political goal. Subjects are required to strip away attributes of their identity that might impede protocols that cascade down from the executive. Total transparency becomes a condition of the re-creation of individual identity. Practices drawn from religious and spiritual traditions that enact the surrender of the self facilitate submission to the demands of the Performative Absolute, the immanent sublime, Demiurge or dieu caché articulated by HRM. The informed passivity of the employee precedes oblation, the sacrificial offering of the self that facilitates the donation by HRM of the attuned identity that ensures the organisational survival of the individual. Absolute'
Rethinking the" production" of identity in the work context
Electronic Journal of Radical …, 2000
The Organisation behavior and management discourse that addresses itself to the forms of connectedness of the individual and the organisation has traditionally viewed such a relationship as a form of socialisation. Perhaps the most pervasive description of such a relationship is that captured by in his notion of the psychological contract. For Schein, the psychological contract involved reciprocation (contribution -inducement) where the employee and employer became engaged in an interactive process of mutual influence and bargaining (see Schein) to suggest that the forms of employee involvement were a natural outcome of the rewards and kinds of authority used in an organisation.
Cogent Business and Management, 2023
This article presents an interpretative framework that fuses together key concepts that would be applied by way of ethnographic and qualitative research methods. The framework seeks to enable interpretations concerning the subjective experience of employees under various cultural conditions by specifying essential conceptual building blocks that gradually build on top of each other, resulting in a more complete theoretical framework for empirical application. The framework is highlighted in four parts A, B, C and D to enable an analysis of an organization’s managerial ideology, normative control, an organization’s culture from the integrationist perspective, its various subcultures and microcultures from the differentiation perspective, and cultural ambiguity from the fragmentation perspective. In addition, interpretations concerning the performances displayed by employees are supported by adopting one of the six sites of enactment as a guide for dramaturgical interpretation, notably, front stage scenes, front stage encounters, front stage relationships, back stage scenes, back stage encounters and back stage relationships. Finally, the interpretative framework enables the analysis of subjective experiences by adopting psychological and sociological concepts of the self as employees traverse various cultural conditions. This article extends existing theory by expanding the realm of possible interpretations concerning the subjective experiences of employees under various cultural conditions within organizational settings.
identity vicissitudes in work organizations_di stefano
Today's pressing scientific and technological changes, while having an impact on the organizational life of our post-industrial world, are producing drastic transformations within organizations, creating in workers new feelings of anxiety and uncertainty. The features of the present state of crises -instability, uncertainty, weakening of family bonds -define a peculiar social and psychological uneasiness, proper of our time, as a consequence of the technological business culture prevailing today, which is destabilizing the institutional role of organizations, namely fixing the various forms of personal identity. This contribution offers, also by presenting a training experience in a business setting, a critical psycho-socio-analysis of the roles that individuals and organizations must presently face to foster development and, at the same time, provides directions to avoid the perverse drift of today's culture and promote the identity process through the reactivation of the learning/changing capacity aimed at the definition of new shared meanings.
Communication Theory, 2005
This article begins with the following question: Why, even with the proliferation of poststructuralist theoretical understandings of identity, do people routinely talk in terms of "real" and "fake" selves? Through an analysis of critical empirical studies of identity-construction processes at work, this article makes the case that the real-self↔fake-self dichotomy is created and maintained through organizational talk and practices and, in turn, serves as a constitutive discourse that produces four subject positions with both symbolic and material consequences: strategized self-subordination, perpetually deferred identities, "autodressage," and the production of "good little copers." The article challenges scholars to reflexively consider the ways they may perpetuate the dichotomy in their own academic practices. Furthermore, the authors present the metaphor of the "crystallized self" as an alternative to the real-self↔fake-self dichotomy and suggest that communication scholars are well-poised to develop alternative vocabularies, theories, and understandings of identity within the popular imagination.
Lok & Willmott, 2013 Journal of Management Inquiry
We examine the dynamics of identity formation in organizations, with a particular focus on the development of antipathies and deadlocks, by engaging a well-regarded study of identity in organizations. By revisiting this study through the lens of a social theory of hegemony (STH), we show how this theory can bring fresh insights to studies of identity, resistance, and deadlock in organizations. We argue that the "othering" and scapegoating involved in organizational deadlocks can be driven by fantasmatic identifications that dim the prospects for discerning and exploring areas of common cause. A condition of possibility of breaking such deadlocks is, conversely, a traversing of the fantasies that cement the impasse.
Beyond dis-identification: A discursive approach to self-alienation in contemporary organizations
Human Relations, 2009
Dis-identification is now an important research area in organization studies investigating how employees subjectively distance themselves from managerial domination by constructing identities considered more `authentic'. But how should we understand situations where actors become aware that their putative`real' selves are paradoxically unreal and foreign? We draw inspiration from the concept of self-alienation to explain experiences beyond dis-identification, where actors perceive the truth of themselves (`who I really am') as alien. An empirical study of a global management consultancy firm demonstrates how a discursive and non-essentialist understanding of self-alienation might usefully capture this experience of identity. Three causes of self-alienation are proposed and we discuss their significance in relation to identity and authenticity in contemporary organizations.
This research is focused on exploring subjectivity through the lens of how employees as subjects strive to be emotionally autonomous, with the backdrop of strategic change. Emotional autonomy relates to a sense of selfhood, a perception of self that is independent of the demands of all others. An exploration of this concept thus goes beyond the formation of the subject to the transitions that she undergoes thereafter in carving a niche for herself. Based on the data gathered from interviews conducted in two financial organisations, the study draws on Lacan’s notion of the Symbolic, Other and desire in order to offer a psychoanalytical perspective to emotional autonomy. It contends that the subject pursues and attains emotional autonomy in so far as perceiving a distinctive sense of selfhood. This perception however is transient and is continually pursued within the grips of the forces that form the subject. In responding to the convention’s call for psychoanalytic studies of organizations and work, this empirical study pushes the boundaries of research on subjectivity, by taking a Lacanian view in the exploration of how subjects transition into forming a distinct sense of selfhood. With the backdrop of strategic change, this study explores how the subjectivity of the employees in two financial organisations is re-articulated.
2007
The purpose of this paper is to argue that the concept of identity regulation has much to offer in understanding management and leadership development in corporate, multinational contexts, but is incomplete without accounting for insecurity, both material and symbolic , experienced by the participants. Thus the paper will work to fuse these two seminal ideas -identity regulation and the importance of insecurity in identity construction --through presenting findings of fieldwork in two contrasting international firms. The first, I argue, reflects a Darwinian model of management/leadership development; the second, a Creationist model. In each case, participants were carefully selected as future leaders of the firm and participated in an 'elite' months-long development program, while performing their regular jobs. Using an iterative research design that combined in-depth interviews with key informants and program participants (N=47) in both firms, observations of their joint working in strategic project groups, and careful examination of the literature, this study presents findings which: a) illustrate two models of identity regulation in practice, b) outline in detail the identity work that is done in these contexts --the 'selves' which are enacted, given the regulation, and c) suggest conclusions which have implications for the theorizing of identity dynamics and the importance of insecurity in the contemporary workplace.
(De)stabilizing Self-identities in Professional Work
It is characteristic of much professional work that it is performed in ambiguous contexts. Thus, uncertainty, unpredictability, indeterminacy, and recurrent organizational transformations are an integral part of modern work for, e.g., engineers, lawyers, business consultants, and other professionals. Although key performance indicators and other knowledge management systems are used to set standards of excellence for professionals, the character of professional work is still flexible, open to interpretation and heterarchical. The very successfulness (or unsuccessfulness) of the work is established in a complex work context where various goals, interests, and perspectives are mediated, altered, contested, mangled, and negotiated in a process of sense-making. The work context is heterogeneously populated by various actors (e.g., the customer, the manager, the colleagues) and actants (e.g., quality systems and technical equipment) that give “voice” to (conflicting) interpretations of what constitutes successful work. Thus, the professionals must navigate in a very complex environment where the locus of governance is far from stable. These characteristics of professional work seem to have implications for the way professionals make sense of their work and their own identities. The identity work of professionals is interwoven with their professional training and career background. With an academic training and a professional career, the individual typically identifies with the profession’s values and adopts a certain way of seeing and approaching the world. This professional outlook typically will constitute the basis of the individual’s appraisal of the work and lay out a horizon of expectations in relation to fulfillment, self-realization, and job satisfaction. In this way, the construction of self-identity becomes the yardstick for the individual’s sense-making and, a fortiori, for the individual’s sense of meaningful work. In this paper, we will claim that the ambiguity involved in professional work becomes a potential strain on the identity construction of the employees engaged in professional work and a potential source of enthusiasm and self-fulfillment. On a conceptual basis, the paper develops three interpretative frameworks that are useful in understanding how professionals deal with ambiguity in professional work. To illustrate this point, the paper refers to qualitative material from a research project conducted in six Danish knowledge-intensive firms. Referring to this empirical material, we discuss how professionals perceive and relate to their work and the role played by professionalism in this relation. Drawing on neo-institutional theory our paper discusses how professionals draw on different frameworks of meaning in order to stabilize their identities.