Perceptions of Crystallising and Paralysing Factors in the Development of Student Teachers of Music in Scotland (original) (raw)
Related papers
Some Perspectives on Musical Gift and Musical Intelligence
This article examines the debate over issues of musical intelligence, largely in a Scottish context, although it draws on recent international research in its discussion. It examines different perceptions of musical gift, and will relate these to factors which either release it, or constrict the release in different ways. Musical intelligence is then examined within the context of the multiple intelligences proposed by Howard Gardner, and is related to practical aspects of musical education.
Educational Philosophy and Theory, 2005
For some time there has been debate about differing perspectives on musical gift and musical intelligence. One view is that musical gift is innate: that it is present in certain individuals from birth and that the task of the teacher is to develop the potential which is there. A second view is that musical gift is a complex concept which includes responses from individuals to different environments and communities (Howe and . This then raises the possibility that musical excellence can be taught.
Conceptions of Musical Ability
Research Studies in Music Education, 2003
Historically, musical ability has been conceptualized in relation to aural abilities. Recently, this view has been challenged. Musical ability is now viewed by a number of authors as a social construction acquiring different meaning in different cultures, sub-groups within cultures and at the individual level. This study aimed to explore conceptions of musical ability in the United Kingdom. An inventory adopting a five point rating scale was developed to assess individuals' perceptions of musical ability. The inventory included 77 statements derived from previous qualitative research categorized into 21 themes . The inventory was completed by 660 individuals. Musical ability was most strongly perceived as relating to a sense of rhythm, followed by the ability to understand and interpret the music, express thoughts and feelings through sound, being able to communicate through sound, motivation to engage with music, personal commitment to music, and being able to successfully engage musically with others. Least important were having technical skills, being able to compose or improvise, being able to read music, and understanding musical concepts and musical structures. Factor analysis revealed 6 factors. The first was concerned with being able to read music and play an instrument or sing. The second focused on musical communication, the third valuing, appreciating and responding to music, and the fourth to composition, improvisation and the skills required for undertaking these.
Characteristics of music teachers and the progress of young instrumentalists
Journal of Research in …, 1998
This study investigated the role of some key characteristics of teachers in the development of musical ability. Interviewing 257 children who differed in the extent of their instrumental mastery, it was discovered that the most successful learners regarded their teachers differently to those children who ceased music tuition. The more successful learners rated their first teacher higher than other learners on personal dimensions such as friendliness, and rated their current teacher higher than other learners on task-oriented professional dimensions such as pushiness.
Peculiarities of Future Primary School Teachers’ Musical Competence
2019
Musical education belongs to significant spheres of personality development and human expression. Music develops human imagination, enhances the emotional experience, evokes the human ability to perceive the organised world of sounds and stimulates the esthetical experience of this world. Many studies have shown that the importance of musical education is more important for primary school pupils than in later years. If before this age, in the families or schools the music education is not given enough attention, the child loses a lot (musical receptiveness, specific visual thinking), and later this kind of abilities for various reasons (disharmony of physical, emotional development, etc.) are more suppressed. Therefore, much of significance must be devoted to the musical education of future primary school teachers. The research data from qualitative and quantitative study analysis have highlighted the peculiarities of musical and pedagogical psychological competencies of primary school teachers.
Primary school teachers' opinions towards musically gifted students
Problems of Education in the 21st Century, 2021
Primary school teachers have an important role in the early identification and further development of a child's musical giftedness. The research was aimed to examine the opinions of primary school classroom teachers (N = 1130) employed in Croatian primary schools regarding conceptualization of musical giftedness and its impact on identification of musically gifted students. Furthermore, their opinions about the support of parents, professional team and collective as well as competencies for recognizing and further development of the child's musical giftedness were investigated. Although most respondents assess their competencies in identifying musical giftedness, most of the surveyed teachers, especially younger ones, are willing to be additionally trained in this area. They stated that the existing curriculum should be expanded and enriched and stressed the need for more support from the expert assistants (psychologists and pedagogues). In addition to the teachers' age, their title (teacher, teacher mentor and teacher advisor) also proved to be a significant factor in the identification and development of a child's musical giftedness. Findings of research have implications for theory and practice of primary school teacher's music education and education for work with gifted children both during their higher education and lifelong learning.
Peculiarities of Pupils’ Learning to Learn: Insights of Music Teachers
Rural Environment. Education. Personality (REEP)
The mission of schools today is not only to develop experts in various professions, but also to cultivate autonomous lifelong learners. Learning to learn is recognised as an essential prerequisite for continuous learning to educate and develop individuals, who are motivated, self-confident and able to evaluate own capacity, to critically reflect, to make decisions and self-assess. The advantage of a music lesson is its attractiveness and complexity, so purposefully strategized musical activities influence the development of learning abilities. The aim of the study is to reveal the peculiarities of the context of learning to learn during music lessons of fifth and sixth formers in basic education from the teachers' point of view. During the semi-structured interview, attention was paid to the insights of music teachers (sixteen teachers) while reflecting on the peculiarities of pupils’ learning to learn during music lessons. The research results disclosed that teachers see learni...
NATURE VERSUS NURTURE: A REVISITED EXPLANATORY SYNTHESIS ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF MUSICAL ABILITIES
Almighty C. Tabuena, 2020
This article iterates and synthesizes findings from literature reviews that intended to describe and present the development of musical abilities. In this matter, the ability of music could be both influenced by society and/or by blood, in terms of genes; both science and experience contribute to this development. This study employed a descriptive method to gather information about present existing conditions through a library method and literature review. The data were analyzed using explanatory synthesis. Based on the literature review, the researcher identified two comparative views on the development of musical abilities: nature and nurture. The researcher used four criteria in synthesizing reviews such as cognitive development, intelligence, the relationship between nature and nurture, and musicality is nature, musical ability is nurtured. In conclusion, when it comes to musical ability, nature works in tandem with nurture; musical talent takes nature and nurture. The result of the perception in the origins and appearance of both the intelligence and action dwells in the discernment of how hereditary and social factors are involved in the active and interactional processes that specify and direct its development. The source and power of music could be some determined by association and/or by ancestry, in terms of genes; both scientific discipline and natural event impart to the development of musical abilities. Key words: Development, Explanatory Synthesis, Musical Abilities, Nature, Nurture