Victims, Villains and Fixers: The Urban Environment and Johannesburg's Poor (original) (raw)
Related papers
Journal of Southern African Studies, 26(4), pp.833 855, 2000
Urban water supply, sanitation and electricity have been identified as basic needs by the post-apartheid government and the Greater Johannesburg Metropolitan Council (GJMC). This article explores the relationship of Johannesburg's poor to the urban environment and in particular these three key urban services. On the basis of survey data, case studies, textual analysis and in-depth interviews with policy makers and planners, it reviews how poorer citizens were for a long time seen as victims under apartheid urban planning. During the rent boycotts that characterised urban struggle politics during the era of late apartheid in Johannesburg, they were often represented as villains. This perception persisted well into the post-apartheid period, where refusing to pay for services was seen as tantamount to a lack of patriotism. Today, Johannesburg's poorer citizens are increasingly being seen as fixers. The GJMC in its policy document, iGoli 2002, is committed to establishing the commercial viability of service delivery. Cost recovery is seen as important to solving the tension that exists between maintaining established service levels (in historically white areas) and extending services to new and historically under-serviced (mainly black) areas. We conclude that there are opportunities to address urban poverty, inequality and environmental management in an integrated way. However, these are predicated on the GJMC and its advisers understanding the ways in which pro-poor and social justice strategies interface with urban services and the urban environment.
Environment and Urbanization, 11(2), pp.107 122., 2000
This paper discusses the difficulties facing the post-apartheid metropolitan government of Johannesburg as it reforms itself, seeking to better respond to the needs of all its citizens, while also attracting new investment. These difficulties include high levels of poverty, unemployment and inequality as well as the apartheid legacy of "separate development" with its large backlog of poor quality housing and inadequate basic services, much of it concentrated in former "black townships" and peripheral informal settlements. Limited budgets and overloaded bureaucracy have limited the scale, quality and speed of delivery. Meanwhile, the need for organizational change and for good fiscal performance compete for attention and resources with poverty reduction and with the need for a more integrated, cross-sectoral poverty reduction policy. The paper ends with a discussion of how the principal challenges facing Johannesburg are also challenges for contemporary urban governance in many other cities.
IALJS-17, 2023
In Blinded City: ten years in inner-city Johannesburg, writer and researcher Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon aims to document how those who occupy buildings illegally because they can afford no other housing are affected by both the decay and regeneration of South Africa's 'city of gold'. Sidestepping the multitudinous, complex plans made in offices in high rises above the crumbling city, Wilhelm-Solomon focuses his attention on those who desperately seek to make homes and communities in abandoned buildings.
The Inner-City Federation: Fighting for Decent Housing in Inner-City Johannesburg
Community Practice Notes: Social Movements Series, 2018
This short community practice note examines the strategies and tactics of the Inner City Federation (ICF), a self-organising coalition of tenants and unlawful occupiers from over 40 buildings in inner-city Johannesburg in South Africa that advocates for housing and basic services, and challenges the stigma associated with low-income inner-city residents. The community practice note provides a brief background to the challenges facing low-income tenants and unalwful occupiers in inner-city Johannesburg. It also summarises the key events in the struggles of poor inner-city residents to resist evictions, harassment and displacement; establish and maintain effective self-management structures in dilapidated buildings; collectively mobilise; and advocate for decent housing.
Prolonging the global age of gentrification: Johannesburg’s regeneration policies
New Urban Policy and New Conventional Wisdom are not restricted to cities of the global North, but are being imported by municipalities of the global South as ‘world class’ enabling precedents. Johannesburg may be added to the growing number of cities that are adopting economic competitiveness, responsive governance, social cohesion, and social mix strategies to facilitate urban regeneration, so that free-market economic strategies rather than social policies may act as catalysts for change. However, such strategies may lead to the social and spatial exclusion of poor inner city residents and not to a Just City conceptualization for urban planning.
Sapience journal, 2024
Since the adoption by the ANC government of GEAR in 1996, policy debate has privileged causal channels linking the structural constraints of racial dispossession on growth, on one hand, and persistent racial disparities in wealth and income on the other. However, whereas inherited structural contradictions may define the broad terrain of the post-apartheid transition, they do not in any direct way determine the course of local class and state formation in cities. Instead, this article challenges the dominant policy discourse in transition studies, arguing that the post-apartheid trajectory, highlighting capital accumulation as a policy priority, has done more to ghettoise and mask the social costs of growth behind informal enclosures of resource scarcity, surplus labour and ecological ruin. My central thesis is that in the government’s attempt to decompress and corral historical race and class differences around a series of hegemonic neoliberal adjustments, a subaltern class of slumdwellers, disincorporated from the official economy, is emerging as collateral consequences. Drawing on an adaptation of David Harvey’s concept of ‘accumulation by dispossession’ as the primary lens through which I try to convey more concrete insights and meanings on the post-apartheid dynamics of urbanisation, I contend that the government’s macroeconomic framework has had the effect of articulating a false abstraction of social justice.
Environment, Development and Sustainability
A significant proportion of South African municipalities, who hold the mandate for providing solid waste management (SWM) services for millions of South Africans, appear to be on the brink of collapse. On the frontlines of municipal failure, the city of Makhanda, following two decades of poor governance and mismanagement, has found itself unable to fulfil its mandate, with the state retreating on SWM service provision, and disruptions to waste management services becoming a daily reality. Drawing on embedded, qualitative fieldwork, this article examines how differently placed residents have experienced disruptions to SWM services. This work explores how residents of Makhanda’s two halves: the affluent and predominantly white neighbourhoods in the west, and the poor, non-white townships in the east, have (or have not) adapted to manage and dispose of their own waste during periods of disruption. Findings suggest that disruptions to waste management service provision have been broadly...
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2008
AbstractIn line with a broader ‘participatory turn’, the collective elaboration of city development strategies (CDSs) has become a leitmotiv in urban development planning, promising to deliver on both democracy-deepening and pro-poor concerns. Yet, this promise reposes on somewhat shaky grounds: much depends on the broader political opportunity structures within which CDSs are attempted. Using Johannesburg's recent experiment with city-wide strategic planning as a case study, this article explores the complex interplay between participatory processes and the broader political machinery of governance. In the messy terrain of late 1990s transition politics, Johannesburg's CDS can be read rather more as an instrument of the ruling ANC party's consolidation of power over the city, than as a ‘genuine’ attempt at collective strategic planning. However, this usurpation of participatory ideals did not entail the demise of equitable or even pro-poor concerns: more formal proce...