Identifying Theories of Agency In Information Systems (original) (raw)

Abstract

Previous research has suggested that systems that are designed according to existing methodology fail in routine contexts whereas others that have evolved in such contexts without a traditional methodology work better. In previous work we have suggested that this is because the theory about purposeful activity that underlies the design of a system has an impact on the success of the system in particular task domains. In order to investigate this empirically we need to establish a method for determining the underlying theory of agency that informs an existing system's approach to purposeful activity. This poses the following question: how do we recognize the theories of agency in systems? To investigate this, we propose a method for extracting the theory of agency from an existing system where we have tentatively assigned an underlying theory of agency to the system but want to definitively categorize it. This is a vital first step in developing an IS design methodology for routine information systems.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (24)

  1. Agre, P. (1997). Computation and Human Experience, Cambridge University Press, New York.
  2. Agre, P. (2001) The Fall of Babbage's Theory (unpublished article)
  3. Agre, P. E. and Chapman, D. (1987). Pengi: an implementation of a theory of activity. In Proceedings of the Tenth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI-87), pages 268-272, Milan, Italy. Morgan Kaufmann.
  4. Agre, P.E. and Horswill, I. (1992). "Cultural Support for Improvisation." Proceedings of AAAI-92. The Tenth National Conference on Artificial Intelligence., Menlo Park, CA., AAAI Press: 363-368.
  5. Agre, P. and Horswill, I. (1997) "Lifeworld Analysis", Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research 6(1), 1997, pages 111- 145
  6. Bently, R. , Hughes, J.A., Randall, D., Rodden, T., Sawyer, P., Shapiro, D., Sommerville, D., (1992). Ethnographically Designed Systems for Air Traffic Control CSCW 92 Proceedings, Assn for Computing Machinery, Toronto, Canada, 123-129.
  7. Brooks, R.A. (1986). "A Robust Layered Control System For A Mobile Robot." IEEE Journal of Robotics and Automation 2(1): 14-23.
  8. Brooks, R.A. (1991a). "Intelligence Without Representation." Artificial Intelligence 47(1-3): 139-159.
  9. Brooks, R.A. (1991b). "New Approaches to Robotics." Science 253(9): 1227-1232.
  10. Chapman, D. (1988). "Planning for Conjunctive Goals." Artificial Intelligence 32(3): 333-377.
  11. Chapman, D. (1991). Vision, Instruction, and Action. Cambridge, MA., The MIT Press.
  12. Clancey, W.J. (1997). Situated Cognition: On Human Knowledge and Computer Representations. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  13. Dreyfus, H.L. (1992). What Computers Still Can't Do. Cambridge, Massachusetts, The MIT Press.
  14. Hammond, K.J., Converse, T.M. and Grass, J.W. (1995). "The Stabilization of Environments." Artificial Intelligence 72(1): 305-328.
  15. Hendriks-Jansen, H. (1996). Catching Ourselves in the Act: Situated Activity, Interactive Johnston (2001). "Situated Action, Structuration and Actor-Network Theory: An Integrative Theoretical Perspective." Proceedings of ECIS 2001 the 9th European Conference on Information Systems, Bled, Slovenia: 232-242.
  16. Johnston, R. B. and M Brennan (1996). Planning or Organising: The Significance of Theories of Activity for the Management of Operations, Omega, 24, 367-384.
  17. Mataric, M.J. (1992). "Integration of Representation into Goal-Driven Behavior-Based Robots." IEEE Journal of Robotics and Automation 8(3): 304-312.
  18. Suchman, L (1983). Plans and Situated Actions, Cambridge University Press, New York.
  19. Suchman, L. (1993). Response to Vera and Simons Situated Action: A Symbolic Representation, Cognitive Science, 17, 71-75.
  20. Vera and Simon (1993) Situated Action: A Symbolic Representation, Cognitive Science, 17, 71-75.
  21. Wight, O. W. (1981). Manufacturing Resource Planning:MRP11, Oliver Wight Publications, Inc., Essex Junction, VT.
  22. Wong, W. (2000). The Integrated Decision Model in Emergency Dispatch Management and its Implications for Design. Australian Journal of Information Systems, 2(7), 95-101.
  23. Wong and Blandford (2001) Situation Awareness and Its Implications For Human Computer Interaction, Proceedings of the Australian Conference on Computer-Human Interaction OzCHI 2001, 20-22 November 2001, Perth , Australia.
  24. Zuboff, S. (1988). In the Age of the Smart Machine, Basic Books Inc, New York.