Comparative advertising in the global marketplace: The effects of cultural orientation on communication (original) (raw)
Related papers
The effectiveness of comparative advertising: a literature review
The aim of this paper is to organize the research so far conducted on the effectiveness of comparative advertising on consumers attitudes towards products. With comparative advertising a company promotes its products or services comparing them with those of competitors. These competitors can be identified generally or specifically. In the first case we are talking about indirect comparative advertising, which can be explicit or implicit according to the fact that the competitor is explicitly mentioned or not. Comparative advertising has traditionally attracted direct concern of many enterprises, because his aggressive nature increases the costs of competitive battle. However, if properly conducted, it is an important source of information for consumers, as it increases the transparency of the market. The international research so far conducted in comparative advertising effectiveness for consumers has given sometimes contradictory results. Indeed, some authors such as Levine (1976), Shimp and Dyer (1978) have, in their studies, shown how comparative advertising is not more effective than non-comparative. On the contrary, Tannenbaum (1976), Demirdjian (1983), Pechmann and Ratneshwar (1991) have achieved better results with comparative advertising
China Compared with the US: Cultural Differences and the Impacts on Advertising Appeals
An important first step to successful global marketing is to understand the similarities and dissimilarities of values between cultures. This task is particularly daunting for companies trying to do business with China because of the scarcity of research-based information. This study uses updated values of Hofstede's (1980) cultural model to compare the effectiveness of Pollay's advertising appeals between the U.S. and China. Nine of the twenty hypotheses predicting effective appeals based on cultural dimensions were supported. An additional hypothesis was significant, but in the opposite direction as predicted. These findings suggest that it would be unwise to use Hofstede's cultural dimensions as a sole predictor for effective advertising appeals. The Hofstede dimensions may lack the currency and fine grain necessary to effectively predict the success of the various advertising appeals. Further, the effectiveness of advertising appeals may be moderated by other factors, such as age, societal trends, political-legal environment and product usage.
Cross-Cultural Models in International Advertising and Consumer Behavior Research
Proceedings of the International Conference on Language Politeness (ICLP 2020), 2021
Past advertising and marketing research has employed two distinct approaches to understanding consumer behavior. Some studies have used the informational social influence approach by operationalizing the consumer behavior outcome domain as a psychological phenomenon wherein individuals are intended to adopt the actions of others to replicate the accurate behavior in a specified condition. This is contrasted with the cultural approach that advocates normative influence where an individual conforms to be adored or accepted by others. This study is inclined to shed light on the cultural approach wherein conformity is an influence involving a change in consumer behavior to align with normative standards. It is also a common and pervasive approach to define the domains of cross-cultural advertising studies wherein norm-congruence is used in defining the influences on consumption patterns. For a better description, in the case of cultural values incongruence, an individual is persuaded to do somewhat that they might not intend to do but which they distinguish as "necessary" to retain a positive relationship with his/her associated members of a particular group or culture. Thus, the conformity approach generally consequences from identification with the group associates or from compliance of some associates to appease others. The study offered a direction for future international advertising research to tap the cultural influences by using GLOBE dimensions.
Horizontal and Vertical Cultural Differences in the Content of Advertising Appeals
Journal of international consumer marketing, 2011
The distinction between vertical (emphasizing hierarchy) and horizontal (valuing equality) cultures yields novel predictions regarding the prevalence of advertising appeals. A content analysis of 1211 magazine advertisements in five countries (Denmark, Korea, Poland, Russia, U.S.) revealed differences in ad content that underscore the value of this distinction. Patterns in the degree to which ads emphasized status benefits and uniqueness benefits corresponded to the countries' vertical/horizontal cultural classification. These and other patterns of ad benefits are analyzed and the predictions afforded by the vertical/horizontal distinction versus the broader individualism-collectivism distinction are compared and tested.
A Cross-Cultural Study of Global Brands Advertising Strategies in Iran
2019
The success rate of international brands in the global market is affected by many factors, one of the most important of which is culture. These days, advertisements which can be adapted to meet the cultural needs of the community will be far more effective. Therefore, the researchers have studied three international outdoor advertising in Iran contributed to cultural differences from the perspective of Hall and Hofstede cultural theories. In the process of this research, which is considered Quasi-quantitative, a questionnaire was developed based on the indexes of the Hofstede and Hall models and filled in by marketing and visual communication specialists. The results indicate that "Clear" in the "indulgence" and "power distance" indicators of the Hofstede model and "non-verbal communication" indicator of the Hall model had a score higher than 5 and L'Oréal had the highest score of 5.66 in the Hall model of "being". Signal, was able to score 5.08 and 5.06 in Hofstede's dimension of "collectivism" and Hall's dimension of "indirectness", respectively. The results show that "Clear" follow the Hall and Hofstede models more than two other brands and "being" and "femininity" are the indicators which are considered more than other indicators in advertisements of all three brands.
Journal of Advertising Research, 2014
For decades, scholars have debated the growth of segments of consumers around the world who share similar needs and tastes . There is ample empirical evidence to support the existence of global consumers who show similarities in consumption behaviors-shared practices that, in part, are attributable to accelerating globalization van Ittersum and Wong, 2010). The growth of global consumer segments has coincided with the emergence of global consumer culturesgenerally accepted beliefs and consumer tendencies toward globally shared consumption-related symbols, such as brands, product categories, and consumption activities .
International Communication Gazette, 2009
This study reports results from a content analysis of comparative advertising studies published in 11 major journals between 1975 and 2005. In the context of sociology of knowledge, the objective was to determine how we come to know what we know about the relationship between culture and advertising in cross-national settings in terms of competing theories and common methodological practices, and to propose concrete solutions to analytical problems encountered in comparative advertising research. The results show that the framework of existing studies was often misguided and the comparative design inadequate to determine the effect of culture on advertising, leaving the knowledge claim of a causal relationship dubious.
Advertising a Product in South Asian Countries: A Study on Cultural Diversities
The purpose of this report is to reach an understanding about how cultural differences in global marketing advertising can be handled by global companies in the South Asia. Qualitative research have been conducted in order to gather the information to support the theoretical findings. The collection of empirical data was done through semi-structured interviews from various global companies and advertising agencies in the South Asia, and case studies based on previously conducted cases.