History at Home: Leighton House, Sambourne House, and the Heritage Debate (original) (raw)
Related papers
Keeping up Appearances: heritage values in house museums
2008
Determining and valuing the intangible spirit of place has been a complex and varied exercise for cultural heritage curators. Using historic house museums Elizabeth Farm, Meroogal and Vaucluse House, all properties of the Historic Houses Trust of NSW, as examples, this paper examines the effects that physical methods of conservation and restoration have in the transmission of the spirit of the place. It looks at the role of the statement of significance as a guide to the spirit of the place. The pivotal roles and influences of individual curators, and their use of consultants, including educators, as mediators and determinants of the significance of the intangible elements of the spirit of the place are addressed, with a focus on the role that research-based decision-making plays in interpretation. The paper concludes that the uniqueness of a place can be captured in part by diverse approaches, and that it is valued and continuous.
Is There a Museum in the House? Historic Houses as a Species of Museum
The historic house museum exemplifies the enormous power of the museum idea to make specimens out of the material world. In fact, houses are an old museum form, very numerous and globally spread. This paper surveys the diverse inspirations of the species, its peculiar expressions, and its formative/deformative relationship to the English country house, via case studies in the UK, the US, and Australia. The paper identifies a characteristic museology that has developed to manage the conditions of house museums and suggests that the contemporary practice of heritage management derives an important strand of its direction from the traditions of house museology. Lastly, it considers the challenge, 'who wants house museums?'
Going public: The modern heritage house on display
The Historic Environment, 2013
This paper investigates issues surrounding the conservation, display and interpretation of modern houses of architectural significance. It draws on a large body of research collected by the author through visits to Modern heritage houses in the UK, France, Belgium, the Netherlands and Australia, alongside interviews with heritage curators and conservationists associated with these properties. From this work, three key themes are elucidated: Firstly, the paper examines the status of Modern heritage houses as 'historical documents' and the role they play in the ongoing formation of architectural histories of Modernism. Secondly, the research critically interrogates how conservation, interpretation and display strategies have been modified to the particularities of Modern houses, in contrast to older and more 'traditional' heritage properties. Thirdly, the protection of many Modern houses has involved controversy over their value, and divided opinion as to their appropr...
House museums are not all the same! Understanding motivation to guide conservation
This paper presents the implications for conservation of analysis showing that houses are preserved as museums for distinctive reasons, which impact on the ways in which they are subsequently conserved, presented and interpreted. For example, the houses of culture heroes (sometimes referred to as ‘celebrity’ houses) possess the aura of sacred places, and hence I argue their conservation should be oriented to retention of the magical character of all original elements. By contrast, houses museumised for their design qualities (interior and/or exterior) are more similar to artworks – walk-through artworks – and I suggest it is appropriate to clean and restore them to conventional museum standards of integrity in order to display the rationale of their preservation. In another contrast, the multi-generational accretion of contents, building and landscape typical of British country houses requires the modulation of historical judgment in restoration and conservation decisions. This kind of decision-making is even more called for in the modern genre of historic process or social history houses, which may be all or part re-created for interpretive purposes. Thus the spectrum of conservation intervention in historic house museums stretches from maintenance of as-found condition to replacement or reinvention of a significant portion of contents and building. Despite this logic, understanding the motivation to transform a house into a museum and undertake appropriate conservation treatments can be, and often is, over-ridden by contemporary needs. This paper calls for conscious consideration of the initial purpose of the house – its cultural significance, in heritage management terms – in coming to appropriate conservation decisions.
Scenographic and artistic interventions and interactions have gained in significance within the fields of exhibition and museum design since the 1990s. This article specifically focuses on historic house museums, and how they use their theatrical and scenographic assets in order to recharge and reinvent themselves. The author discusses the different aims and tasks these interventions and interactions take on, and the attitudes that make them happen. Further, the author argues that the field of art history should address these changes in museological practice, and should investigate new possible readings of the historic house, the objects within, and artistic interventions. This would also show the relevance of art history to the field of critical heritage studies in a period that is characterized by the heritage boom and the new experience industry.