Jurisprudence from Antiquity to Modernity: The Enduring Appeal of Natural Law Theory (original) (raw)

The goal of this essay is to provide an account of the philosophy of law which establishes the moral and practical appeal of one legal theory, natural law theory, above another, legal positivism. It does not aim to definitively overturn legal positivism, to deny the value of that theory, or to establish natural law theory as the absolute paramount of legal theories. Its aim, rather, is to effectively argue that natural law theory provides a better means of achieving social happiness than legal positivism can. It is a systematic approach, rather than an historical one, although historical evidence is cited at various points. It locates the particular problems facing an account of the philosophy of law, and addresses those problems using practical reasoning. The essay consists of seven sections and a conclusion. Section one establishes the conceptual location of the philosophy of law, describes its methodology, and identifies the purpose and possible scope of that philosophy. Section two discusses the external parameters of law, focusing particularly upon the relation between law and morality as envisioned by legal positivism and natural law theory. Section three outlines the argument presented by Aristotle that natural law provides a concrete means of attaining happiness, thus providing a justification for participation in a political community as well as the adoption of natural law theory. Section four addresses the question of political obligation. Section five then provides an account of the necessary criteria of legal authority which makes that obligation binding. Section six proceeds to discuss the notion of human rights, while section seven considers the justification of punishment in the context of such rights. Finally, a conclusion is presented, which summarizes the main themes addressed and reaffirms why natural law theory is of greater moral and practical appeal.

Sign up for access to the world's latest research.

checkGet notified about relevant papers

checkSave papers to use in your research

checkJoin the discussion with peers

checkTrack your impact