Sustainable forestry in the tropics: panacea or folly? (original) (raw)

Abstract

sparkles

AI

This study explores the ongoing debate surrounding sustainable forestry practices in tropical regions, specifically evaluating the effectiveness of sustainable timber management (STM) and sustainable forest management (SFM) as compared to conventional logging (CL). Key questions include the best approach to retain forest cover and the terms defining each forestry practice. The discussion reveals a lack of consensus on whether sustainable practices can effectively conserve biodiversity and if they are superior to outright forest protection. Findings suggest that while SFM may be the only viable solution in many scenarios, the complexities inherent in forest management necessitate a careful re-examination of existing strategies and terminologies.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (69)

  1. Ashton, M.S. and Peters, C., 1999. Even-aged silviculture in mixed tropical forests with special reference to Asia: Lessons learned and myths perpetuated. Journal of Forestry 97(11):14-19.
  2. Bach, C. and Gram, S., 1996. The tropical timber triangle. Ambio, 25(3), 166-170.
  3. Barbier, E., Burgess, J., Bishop, J. and Aylward, B., 1994. The Economics of the Tropical Timber Trade. Earthscan, London.
  4. Bawa, K. and Seidler, R., 1998. Natural forest management and conservation of biodiversity in tropical forests. Conservation Biology, 12, 46-55.
  5. Boscolo, M. and Vincent, J., 1998. Promoting better logging practices in tropical forests: a simulation analysis of alternative regulations. Development Discussion Paper 652, Harvard Institute for International Development, September.
  6. Bowles, I., Rice, R., Mittermeier, R. and da Fonseca, A., 1998. Logging and tropical forest conservation. Science, 280, 1899-1900.
  7. Brooks, D., Pajuoja, H., Solberg, B., Wardle, P. and Peack, T., 1996. Long-term Trends and Prospects in World Supply and Demand for Wood. Paper to the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Forests, European Forest Institute, Joensuu and Norwegian Forest Research Institute, As.
  8. Bruenig, E.F., 1996. Conservation and Management of Tropical Rainforests. CAB International, Wallingford.
  9. Bruner, A.G., Gullison, R.E., Rice, R.E. and da Fonseca, G.A.B., 2000. Effectiveness of Parks in Protecting Tropical Biodiversity. Science 291, 125-128.
  10. Buschbacher, R., 1990. Natural forest management in the humid tropics: ecological, social, and economic considerations. Ambio 19(5), August, 253-258
  11. Cannon, J., Gullison, R. and Rice, R., 1998. Conservation and Logging in Tropical Forests. Conservation International, for the World Bank, Washington DC.
  12. Chomitz, K. and Kumari, K., 1996. The Domestic benefits of Tropical Forests: a Critical Review. Global Environmental Change (GEC) Series, 96-19, Centre for Social and Economic Research on the Global Environment, (CSERGE), University College London and University of East Anglia.
  13. Crossley, R. and Points, J., 1998. Investing in Tomorrow's Forests: Profitability and Sustainability in the Forest Products Industry. WWF, Godalming.
  14. Dickinson, M., Dickinson, J. and Putz, F., 1996. Natural forest management as a conservation tool in the tropics: divergent views on possibilities and alternatives. Commonwealth Forestry Review, 75, 309-315.
  15. Dixon, R., 1997. Silvicultural options to conserve and sequester carbon in forest systems: preliminary economic assessment. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 27 (special), S139-S149.
  16. Godoy, R. and Lubowski, R., 1992. Guidelines for the Economic Valuation of Non-timber Tropical-Forest Products. Current Anthropology, 33 (4), August-October, 423-433.
  17. Godoy, R., Lubowski, R. and Markandya, A., 1993. A Method for the Economic Valuation of Non-timber Tropical Forest Products. Economic Botany, 47 (3), 220-233.
  18. Grut, M., 1990. Economics of Managing the African Rainforest. World Bank, Washington DC.
  19. Gullison, R., 1995. Conservation of Tropical Forests Through the Sustainable Production of Forest Products. PhD Thesis, Princeton University.
  20. Howard, A., Rice, R. and Gullison, R., 1996. Simulated financial returns and selected environmental impacts from four alternative silvicultural prescriptions applied to the neotropics: a case study of the Chimanes Forest, Bolivia. Forest Ecology Management, 89, 43-57.
  21. Howard, A. and Valerio, J., 1996. Financial returns from sustainable forest management and selected agricultural land use options in Costa Rica. Forest Ecology and Management, 81, 35-49.
  22. Hunter, I., 1998. Multiple-use forest management systems. In: See, L., May, D., Gauld, I., and Bishop, J. (Eds.), Conservation, Management and Development of Forest Resources. Forest Research Institute, Kuala Lumpur, 169-177.
  23. Hyde, W., 1999. Patterns of forest development. Lecture given at IIED, London, April 1999. Intergovernmental Forum on Forests, 1999. Valuation of Forest Goods and Services: Report of the Secretary General. United Nations Commission on Sustainable Development, New York, Report E/CN.17/IFF/1999.12.
  24. Kaimowitz, D. and Angelsen, A., 1998. Economic Models of Deforestation: a Review. CIFOR, Bogor, Indonesia.
  25. Kumari, K., 1995. An Environmental and Economic Assessment of Forest management Options: a Case Study of Malaysia. Environment Department Working Paper 026, World Bank, Washington DC.
  26. Kumari, K., 1996. Sustainable forest management: myth or reality? Exploring the prospects for Malaysia. Ambio, 25 (7), 459-467.
  27. Lampietti, J. and Dixon, J., 1995. To See the Forest for the Trees: A Guide to non-Timber Forest Benefits. World Bank, Washington DC.
  28. Manokaran, N., 1998. Effect, 34 years later, of selective logging in the lowland dipterocarp forest of Pasoh, Peninsular Malaysia, and implications of present day logging in the hill forests. In: L.See, D.May, I.Gauld and J.Bishop (Eds.), Conservation, Management and Development of Forest Resources. Forest Research Institute, Kuala Lumpur, 41-60.
  29. Mourato, S., 1999. Do slash and burn farmers value forest preservation? Evidence from the Peruvian Amazon, Chapter 2 of Ph D thesis, Essays in Contingent Valuation, University College London.
  30. Panayotou, T. and Ashton, P., 1992. Not by Timber Alone: Economics and Ecology for Sustaining Tropical Forests. Island Press, Washington DC.
  31. Pearce, D.W., 1986. Cost-Benefit Analysis. Macmillan, Basingstoke.
  32. Pearce, D.W., 1993. Economic Values and the Natural World, Earthscan, London.
  33. Pearce, D.W., 1996. Global environmental value and the tropical forests: demonstration and capture. In: Adamowicz, W., Boxall, P., Luckett, M., Phillips, W., and White, W. (Eds), Forestry, Economics and the Environment. CAB International, Wallingford.
  34. Pearce, D.W., 1998. Can non-market values save the tropical forest? In: B.Goldsmith (Ed), Tropical Rain Forest: a Wider Perspective. Chapman and Hall, London, 255-268.
  35. Pearce, D.W., 1999. Economics and Environment: Essays on Ecological Economics and Sustainable Development. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.
  36. Pearce, D.W. and Moran, D., 1994. The Economic Value of Biodiversity. Earthscan, London.
  37. Pearce, D.W. and Puroshothaman, S., 1995. The Economic Value of Plant-based Pharmaceuticals. In: Swanson, T. (Ed), Intellectual Property Rights and Biodiversity Conservation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 127-138.
  38. Pearce, D.W., Day, B., Newcombe, J., Brunello, A. and Bello, T., 1998. The Clean Development Mechanism: Benefits of the CDM for Developing Countries. Centre for Social and Economic Research on the Global Environment (CSERGE), University College London for the Department for International Development.
  39. Pearce, D.W., Krug, W. and Moran, D., 1999. The Global Value of Biodiversity. A Report to UNEP, Nairobi.
  40. Perez, M.R. and Byron, N., 1999. A methodology to analyze divergent case studies of non-timber forest products and their development potential. Forest Science, 45 (1), 1-14.
  41. Perman, R., Ma, Y. and McGilvray, J., 1999. Natural Resource and Environmental Economics. Longman, Harlow, 2 nd edition.
  42. Pinedo-Vazquez, M. and Rabelo, F., 1999. Sustainable management of an Amazonian forest for timber production: myth or reality?, PLEC News and Views, 12, 20-28.
  43. Putz, F.E., Dykstra, D.P. and Heinrich, R., 2000. Why poor logging practices persist in the tropics. Conservation Biology 14, 951-956.
  44. Putz, J., Sirot, L.K. and Pinard, M.A., 2001. Tropical forest management and wildlife: silvicultural effects on forest structure, fruit production and locomotion of non-volant arboreal animals. In: Fimbel, R., Grajal, A., and Robinson, J. (Eds), Conserving Wildlife in Managed Tropical Forests. Columbia University Press, New York.
  45. Putz, F.E., Blate, G.M., Redford, K.H., Fimbel, R. and Robinson, J., 2001. Tropical forest management and conservation of biodiversity: an overview. Conservation Biology 15, 7-20
  46. Reid, J. and Rice, R., 1997. Assessing natural forest management as a tool for tropical forest conservation. Ambio, 26 (6), 382-386.
  47. Repetto, R., 1990. Deforestation in the tropics. Scientific American, 262, 36-42.
  48. Rice, R., Gullison, R. and Reid, J., 1997. Can sustainable management save tropical forests? Scientific American, 276, 34-39.
  49. Rice, R., Sugal, C. and Bowles, I., 1998a. Sustainable Forest Management: a Review of the Current Conventional Wisdom. Conservation International, Washington DC.
  50. Rice, R., Sugal, C., Frumhoff, P. and Losos, E., 1998b. Options for conserving biodiversity in the context of logging in tropical forests. In: Prickett, G., Bowles, I. (Eds), Footprints in the Jungle: Natural Resource Industries, Infrastructure and Biodiversity Conservation. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  51. Romero, C., 1999. Reduced impact logging effects on commercial non-vascular pendant epiphyte biomass in a tropical forest in Costa Rica. Forest Ecology and Management.
  52. Salick, J., 1995. Non-timber forest products integrated with natural forest management. Ecological Applications, 5, 922-954.
  53. Schneider, R., 1995. Government and the Economy on the Amazon Frontier. Environment Paper No.11, World Bank, Washington DC.
  54. Smith, J., Mulongoy, K., Persson, R. and Sayer, J., 1999a. Harnessing carbon markets for tropical forest conservation: towards a more realistic assessment. Centre for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), Jakarta, mimeo.
  55. Smith, J., Mourato, S., Veneklaas, E., Labarta, R., Reategui, K. and Sanchez, G., 1999b. Willingness to pay for environmental services among slash and burn farmers in the Peruvian Amazon: implications for deforestation and global environmental markets. Centre for Social and Economic Research on the Global Environment, University College London and University of East Anglia, mimeo.
  56. Sohngen, B., Mendelsohn, R. and Sedjo, R., 1998. The effectiveness of forest carbon sequestration strategies with system-wide adjustments. Resources for the Future, Washington DC, mimeo.
  57. Southgate, D., 1996. What Roles Can Ecotourism, Non-timber Extraction, Genetic Prospecting, and Sustainable Timber Play in an Integrated Strategy for Habitat Conservation and Local Development? Department of Agricultural Economics, Ohio State University, Report to Inter-American Development Bank, mimeo.
  58. Southgate, D., 1998. Tropical Forest Conservation: An Economic Assessment of the Alternatives in Latin America. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  59. Southgate, D., Coles-Ritchie, M. and Salazar-Canelos, P., 1996. Can tropical forests be saved by harvesting non- timber products? Global Environmental Change (GEC) Series 96-02, Centre for Social and Economic Research on the Global Environment (CSERGE), University College London and University of East Anglia.
  60. Stephens, M., 1999. The marginal costs of a safe minimum standard for an endangered arboreal species. Department of Forestry, Australian National University, Canberra, mimeo.
  61. Toman, M. and Ashton, M., 1994. Sustainable forest ecosystems and management: a review article. Discussion Paper 94-42, Resources for the Future, Washington DC.
  62. Vanclay, J.K., 1994a. Modeling Forest Growth and Yield: Applications to Mixed Tropical Forests. CAB International, Wallingford.
  63. Vanclay, J.K., 1994b. Sustainable timber harvesting: simulation studies in the tropical rainforests of north Queensland. Forest Ecology and Management, 69, 299-320
  64. Vanclay, J.K., 1996a. Assessing the sustainability of timber harvests from natural forests: limitations of indices based on successive harvests. Journal of Sustainable Forestry, 3, 47-58.
  65. Vanclay, J.K., 1996b. Lessons from the Queensland rainforests: steps towards sustainability. Journal of Sustainable Forestry, 3, 1-17.
  66. Vanclay, J.K., 2001. The Effectiveness of Parks. Science, 291, in press.
  67. Vincent, J., 1992. The tropical timber trade and sustainable development. Science, 256, 1651.
  68. Whitmore, T.C., 1999. Arguments on the forest frontier. Biodiversity and Conservation, 8, 865-8.
  69. World Commission on Forests and Sustainable Development, 1999. Our Forests Our Future. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.