Voluntary Slavery and the Limits of the Market (original) (raw)
Related papers
Bonded labor and serfdom: a paradox of voluntary choice
Journal of Development Economics, 2002
Among the oldest and most pervasive economic institutions are bonded labor and serfdom. While seemingly exploitative, both bonded labor and serfdom are often not imposed on the laborers but voluntarily chosen. It is generally the lack of suitable alternatives which makes workers opt for a life in servitude. This paper shows that the existence of these voluntary forms of servitude itself may restrain the laborers' opportunities so that they are left with no better alternative than bondage. Under these circumstances, government interventions banning servile institutions, by promoting the development of alternative options for the laborers, have the potential to substantially improve the condition of a large class of laborers. JEL Classification Numbers: D40, C72, O10, J41, K31.
The Modern Slavery Trap: Bonded Labour
2018
agencies have dominated the discussion on modern slavery in recent years. However, while this work is important, it is just the tip of the iceberg. It misses the diversity of relationships and perpetrators colluding to make modern slavery, and particularly bonded labour, a public secret in the twenty-first century. Across the world bonded labour is taking place in formal and informal industries, such as brick kilns or quarries and in restaurants, tea shops, nail salons, or carpet-making. In areas of South Asia, some families marginalised by customs and traditions are living in poverty and turning to illegal moneylenders to cover emergency costs, such as a sudden illness. This leads some to become trapped in a cycle of bonded labour. Financially illiterate, they are forced to pay off the debt by working for the moneylenders directly or for third parties linked to the moneylenders, who may be local landlords or businesses in local activities such as brickmaking, farming, stone breakin...
The Historical and Modern Arguments against Contractual Slavery
Conventional classical liberalism takes consent not only as a necessary condition but sometimes as a sufficient condition for the legitimacy of an institution or practice. This chapter reviews the acceptance of contractual slavery or servitude from ancient times down to and including the modern era. The case against the sufficiency of consent is based on the notion of inalienable rights, rights that may not be alienated even with consent. The intellectual history of inalienable rights arguments against voluntary slavery or servitude are also reviewed and restated in modern terms. The conclusion is that any institution or practice, e.g., human trafficking, that, in effect, treats a person as a non-person, as only a means instead of as an end-in-themselves, is illegitimate-even with consent.
Forced and Unfree Labour: An Analysis
International Critical Thought, 2014
In 2011 the UN International Labour Organization produced a new estimate of 20.9 million victims of forced labour (ILO, 2012: p. 16). Forced labour continues to be found in almost all countries and all economic sectors. This persistence and development of forced labour raises various issues that we explore in this paper. It is free labour that is central to the Marxist account of capitalism, both in terms of its economic and ideological dynamics. There is, therefore, a potential tension for Marxist theory in terms of the persistence and diversification of forced labour and we explore this, drawing also on the 'realist' concepts of agency and structure. For forced labour to flourish, as clearly it is, there must also be a combination of motive and opportunity in the contemporary world. One can, therefore, ask what kind of capitalism promotes forced labour.
2012
The observation that propertylessness effectively forces individuals to accept employment is not new. What is most new in the chapters above is the central role this observation takes in a theory of status freedom. This chapter puts the theory of status freedom outlined in this book into relation with the modern literature on freedom. It argues that recent literature on freedom has paid insufficient attention to status freedom 2 and that a concern for status freedom as ECSO freedom or independence would make theories of freedom more plausible. The following chapter (Chapter 8) discusses independence in the context of modern liberal-egalitarian theories of justice.
Modern Slavery, Unfree Labour and the Labour Market
Social & Legal Studies, 2017
Treating the United Kingdom’s Modern Slavery Act as its focus, this article examines what the legal characterization of labour unfreedom reveals about the underlying conception of the labour market that informs contemporary approaches to labour law in the United Kingdom. It discusses how unfree labour is conceptualized within two key literatures – Marxist-inspired political economy and liberal approaches to modern slavery – and their underlying assumptions of the labour market and how it operates. As an alternative to these depictions of the labour market, it proposes a legal institutionalist or constitutive account. It develops an approach to legal characterization and jurisdiction that is attentive to modes of governing and the role of political and legal differentiation both in producing labour exploitation and unfree labour and in developing strategies for its elimination. It argues that the problem with the modern slavery approach to unfree labour is that it tends to displace l...
Slavery, Serfdom and Wage labor: local connections and global dynamics
This book is about the evolution of labor and labor institutions in Russia compared with Europe, Central Asia, and the Indian Ocean between the sixteenth and the early twentieth centuries. It questions common ideas about the origin of labor institutions and market economies, their evolution, and their transformation in the early modern and modern world.