Online Media as a Means to Affect Public Trust in Emergency Responders (original) (raw)
Related papers
Trust-building through Social Media Communications in Disaster Management
Proceedings of the 24th International Conference on World Wide Web - WWW '15 Companion, 2015
Social media provides a digital space-a meeting place, for different people, often representing one or more groups in a society. The use of this space during a disaster, especially where information needs are high and the availability of factually accurate and ethically sourced data is scarce, has increased substantially over the last 5-10 years. This paper attempts to address communication in social media and trust between the public and figures of authority during a natural disaster in order to suggest communication strategies that can enhance or reinforce trust between these bodies before, during and after a natural disaster.
Online media use and adoption by Hurricane Sandy affected fire and police departments
2014
This thesis work examines the online communications of 840 fire and police departments during Hurricane Sandy (2012). Using a mixed methods approach, this research combines interviews with fire and police department members and quantitative data around online media use and adoption to better understand different features of these departments and their online communications. The research provides the following contributions: (1) an examination of how and why affected fire and police departments used (or did not use) online communication media for public communications during Hurricane Sandy and (2) an examination of how a large-scale disaster event like Hurricane Sandy affects online communication media use and adoption by affected fire and police departments. (75 pages) iv PUBLIC ABSTRACT Online Media Use and Adoption by Hurricane Sandy Affected Fire and Police Departments Apoorva Chauhan In this thesis work, I examine the use and adoption of online communication media by 840 fire and police departments that were affected by the 2012 Hurricane Sandy. I began by exploring how and why these fire and police departments used (or did not use) online media to communicate with the public during Hurricane Sandy. Results
Toward an Integrative Model of Trust for Digital Emergency Communication
2020
Digital technologies have become an integral enabler of communication during various phases of emergency management (EM). A crucial prerequisite of e ective communication between authorities and the public during EM is the establishment of adequate mutual trust. Trust, however, is an elusive concept which is not easily translatable into technical settings. In this paper we propose an integrative model of trust in digital communication and show how such model can be advantageous in assessing and improving trust relations in context of EM. Our interdisciplinary model, which is based on findings from psychology, sociology and computer sciences provides an abstraction which not only seizes both subjective and objective as well as personal and non-personal, e.g., institutional or cultural, aspects of trust but at the same time is concrete enough to be applicable to real-life scenarios.
Trust, but verify: social media models for disaster management
A lack of trust in the information exchanged via social media may significantly hinder decision-making by community members and emergency services during disasters. The need for timely information at such times, though, challenges traditional ways of establishing trust. This paper, building on a multi-year research project that combined social media data analysis and participant observation within an emergency management organisation and in-depth engagement with stakeholders across the sector, pinpoints and examines assumptions governing trust and trusting relationships in social media disaster management. It assesses three models for using social media in disaster management—information gathering, quasi-journalistic verification, and crowdsourcing—in relation to the guardianship of trust to highlight the verification process for content and source and to identify the role of power and responsibilities. The conclusions contain important implications for emergency management organisations seeking to enhance their mechanisms for incorporating user-generated information from social media sources in their disaster response efforts.
Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management
This study investigates how citizens perceive the role of mobile phone apps specifically designed for disaster communication, and how these perceptions may differ from perceived roles and functions of social media in disaster-related tasks/situations. Focusing on trust in authorities and technology use, results suggest that social media use not only fosters trust via shared narratives and collective sense-making but may also improve trust relationships through local authorities assuming the function of a trustworthy information provider. In disaster apps usage, trust between citizens and authorities is generated through perceptions of shared responsibility rather than shared narratives. Apps were seen as mechanisms that reveal authorities' general willingness to share control, which may help overcome citizens' perceptions that they are distrusted by authorities.
Trial by Fire: The Deployment of Trusted Digital Volunteers in the 2011 Shadow Lake Fire
We report on the use of a team of trusted digital volunteers during the 2011 Shadow Lake Fire that occurred in the US Pacific Northwest to extend the social media capacity of a Type I incident management team. In this case study, we outline the tools and processes used by this virtual team to coordinate their activities, monitor social media communication and to establish communications with the public around the event. Finally, we discuss the potential merits and limitations of implementing a team of trusted volunteers and explore how this idea could be incorporated into emergency management organizations.
The Role of Social Media Network Participants in Extreme Events
role relationships within the social network. As EMAs are also responsible for taking action to protect the community in times of such an extreme event, we also argue that "swift trust" is built within EMA roles. EMA roles are also reinforced by the non-relational role attribute of communication quality that reflects message authenticity, in this case "transparent and understandable" communications that are expected of an EMA.
Communication Media Use in Emergency Response Management
The communications of emergency response managers were tracked during simulated catastrophic events at a university campus in the Washington, D.C. region. Local, state, and federal response managers interacted with each other and with students using a variety of communication media in order to investigate the utility of new communication channels for emergency response management. Students and emergency managers interacted using a Twitter-like platform and a portal built with Ushahidi crowd-sourcing software. The emergency managers also used a chat interface that included private instant messaging, telephone, and the county's existing emergency web portal. Their media use was analyzed along with the functions of their communications, and the patterns that emerged are described and quantified.
Journal of Public Affairs, 2019
The manuscript investigates how social media were used during a flood disaster managed by public affairs officers. We conducted high-level "elite" interviews with the state's top emergency managers about their social media policies, practices, and use in both media relations and citizen communication. We explored the strategies and communication models implemented, challenges and barriers for effective adoption of these platforms, and ethical implications in the use social media during natural disasters. The study investigates gaps between theories and practice, adopting a multidisciplinary perspective that involves public relations, social media studies, government/public affairs, and public sector communication. Recommendations are offered to improve disaster communication via social media including dedicated staff and resources, evaluation, symmetry, and the use of ethical communication to quell rumors or misinformation during a disaster. 1 | INTRODUCTION Social media has reframed communication as rapidly emerging, without geographic boundaries, and interactive on both a societal and individual scale. Rapid communication is a challenge to manage, and that challenge is exacerbated in the most exigent situations: emergencies and disasters to be managed by public sector organizations (PSOs) and by public affairs specialists (Bowen, Rawlins, & Martin, 2019). Social media serves as a powerful tool for emergency management and disaster relief in many recent emergency situations worldwide, such as Hurricanes Sandy and Harvey in the United States, the tsunami in Japan, earthquakes in Italy and Chile, and the Queensland floods in Australia. We focus on the role of social media as used by government agencies and PSOs (i.e., public departments, officials, and other government agencies) as part of their emergency and disaster response. This case study examines a disaster in which eleven trillion gallons of water fell in South Carolina (SC), United States, causing massive flooding in residential areas; results included fatalities, massive infrastructure damage including road and bridge collapses, evacuations, and prolonged loss of energy in October 2015. The death toll was 17 and property damage totaled $1.2 billion. Social media took a prominent place during the flood in interactions between PSOs, media, and citizens. Messages were disseminated on social media to inform news media and citizens, and to coordinate disaster operations. Emergency communication and disaster response is not optional for elected officials, organizations, and government entities at every level: national, state, county, and city. In the United States, there were 137 major disasters in 2017 and 79 in 2018's hurricane season (FEMA, 2018). The flood in SC was only one of the major disasters in 2015 but offers a unique opportunity to examine disaster response and social media use from the perspective of the communication function in numerous government entities with high-level (elite) public affairs officers (PAOs). We examined social media around this disaster from a perspective of crisis management (Coombs, 2019) and public relations
Mediating Trust in Terrorisme Coverage
Mass mediated risk communication can contribute to perceptions of threats and fear of “others” and/or to perceptions of trust in fellow citizens and society to overcome problems. This paper outlines a cross-disciplinary holistic framework for research in mediated trust building during an acute crisis. While the framework is presented in the context of television coverage of a terror-related crisis situation, it can equally be used in connection with all other forms of mediated trust. Key words: National crisis, risk communication, crisis management, television coverage, mediated trust, 911, rescue operation, audience, journalism, trust.