Anticipatory Representation: Building the Palestinian Nation(-State) through Artistic Performance (SEN 12.1: 82-100) (original) (raw)
Related papers
Creative Heritage: Palestinian Heritage NGOs and Defiant Arts of Government
American Anthropologist, 2010
Beyond the commonsense dichotomy between art as radical practice and heritage as conservation, this article analyzes Palestinian heritage as the ambiguous terrain where these two practices meet, creating a language that is both locally rooted and cosmopolitan. By examining the recent Palestinian art biennales (biennials), I show how heritage-informed art functions as a platform for performing the future Palestinian nation-state. Organized by a heritage organization, the biennales highlight the creativity of a new generation of Palestinian heritage NGOs, which continue a local social-organizing tradition marked by the alliance between heritage, the arts, and liberation politics. This cultural production undermines a traditional dichotomy between heritage and counter-memory because it represents both part of a state-building project and an act of anticolonial resistance, suspended between what scholars term "transnational governmentality" and "counter-governmentality." I argue that Palestinian heritage practices constitute a form of nonstate governmentality. In this context, problems of representation acquire strong relevance.
Artistic Interventions as Guardians of Palestinian Minority's Heritage
YOUR WAY OR MY WAY? Questions on Authenticity, Identity and Patrimonial Proceedings in the Safeguarding of Architectural Heritage Created in the Meeting of Cultures, 2017
Palestinians call Israel’s Independence the Nakba, i.e., the catastrophe that drove them out of their homes, destroyed their villages, expropriated their land, and denied their right to return. This paper focuses on the impressive remains of two villages - Ayn Hawd and Kufr Birim - in order to examine how Israeli and Palestinian artists, by means of their disciplinary operations, intervened in preserving physical edifices or suppressed narratives. The first is Ayn Hawd, on whose remains of which Marcel Janco, a famous Jewish Dada artist, established an artists’ colony. He prevented the destruction of the village, restored and reused it, yet was also involved in its dispossession. The second is Kufr Birim – a closed military zone situated in a national park – where Palestinian artists perform, regularly yet temporarily, site specific art interventions. They belong to a larger group of activists who renovate the church and perform religious, educational and cultural events in situ. In both cases, the artistic actions advanced an oppositional ideology within the dominant institutional apparatus that safeguarded the minority heritage. We propose to examine how art intervention deciphers the site through a different toolkit, and thus succeeds to expand the boundaries of preservation and approximates towards an experimental practice. Can preservation select its addressees? And if so, can we still consider it an act of preservation? The paper challenges the dominant practice with an alternative approach to transcultural heritage, based on interdisciplinary research tying together contemporary art theories, architectural heritage and political philosophy of sites in conflict.
Beyond negotiating impossibilities: The art of Palestinian creative resistance
In this essay I explore the idea of art as creative resistance against the modern-day colonization and occupation of Palestine. I reflect on Achille Mbembe’s post-colonial subjectivities in “crisis”, modes of self-writing, and necropolitical models of occupation and sovereignty to suggest ways beyond negotiating impossibilities in the colonial context. I consider Mbembe’s theoretical contributions to put forward an alternative perspective that recognizes the importance of art in creating living memory, preserving historical narrative, and transforming the dominant ethno-national narrative which has purposely excluded a people from its story.
Biennales in Palestine-Thinking Art and Making Art.pdf
The Riwaq Biennale marked Riwaq’s new approach and image of openness, networking and dialogue, not only with cultural heritage organisations, but also with the community at large, locally and internationally. This essay sheds light on the biennales in Palestine that have a responsive/radical perception of space (where things happen) and time (when things happen and for how long), and against the practices of artistic production and biennales that lend themselves to already formulated agendas. I critically engage with the Riwaq Biennale (RB) and Qalandiya International (Qi) to further speculate on the role of biennales and art in changing not only the content and form, but also the management modalities and the managerial structures of events in the public sphere. Biennales in Palestine, I claim, have a management twist to the artistic events and artistic production, and are therefore permanently oscillating between creative (thinking) and non-creative (making) artistic work. This twist acknowledges the inherent dialectical relation in the field of artistic production that strives to alternately celebrate and conceal the art and the practical world behind it. This turn also tries to make visible the structures that shape the lives and the practices of people, while making use of symbolic enterprise to point at the debilitating conditions that the artists, the managers and the audiences alike have to endure.
“From Palestine with Art”: Dreams of Sovereignty and Acts of Resistance at the 2022 Venice Biennale
react/review: a responsive journal for art & architecture, 2023
For the 59th Venice Biennale, curator Nancy Nesvet and the Palestine Museum US in Woodbridge, Connecticut, organized the Collateral Event “From Palestine with Art” at the Palazzo Mora (European Cultural Center). “From Palestine with Art” presents the work of nineteen contemporary Palestinian artists who invite audiences to imagine a new landscape and way of life in a liberated Palestine. The exhibition interweaves moments of joy with themes of struggle, resistance, and injustice. The artists and curators turn away from gratuitous images of suffering and violence to embrace creative forms of fighting and solidarity where happiness and presence is a radical act of resistance. As Israel continues to occupy Palestinian land and execute unprovoked military actions against unarmed civilians, the exhibition shows that Palestinians are still here. Their presence, even if far from the Biennale’s main events, is a visual argument for liberation, while its physical distance is indicative of the ways that many aim to neglect the current situation.
In the last decade, the international profile of Palestinian art has grown at an unprecedented rate. In the context of international exhibitions, the work of contemporary Palestinian artists is consistently framed as inherently political and is almost always discussed in terms of the conflict with Israel. This article examines the ways that a new generation of Palestinian artists have used their work to problematize the iconography of Palestinian nationalism developed by previous generations and the international framing of their work as inherently political. It considers the role of art in the development and dissemination of Palestinian nationalist iconography and maps the history of popular iconography to show the Nakba, the battle of Karameh and the Oslo Accords as events that each transformed Palestinian popular iconography. Examining the work of artists Khaled Hourani, Emily Jacir, Larissa Sansour and Monther Jawabreh, in this article I argue that contemporary art plays a significant role in subverting the trend of reducing the Palestinian experience to one of victimhood and loss.