Rational Internalism (original) (raw)

I describe and motivate Rational Internalism, a principle concerning the relationship between motivating reasons (which explain actions), and normative reasons (which justify actions). I use this principle to construct a novel argument against Objectivist theories of normative reasons, which hold that facts about normative reasons can be analyzed in terms of an independently specified class of normative or evaluative facts. I then argue for an alternative theory of normative reasons, the Reasoning View, which is consistent with both Rational Internalism and the standard motivations for Objectivism.