Mindfulness, Mysticism, and Narrative Medicine (original) (raw)
Related papers
Spiritual Dimensions of Illness and Healing: The 4th Annual Medicine and Religion Conference
Christian Journal for Global Health, 2015
In western culture, there continues to be a divide between care for the body (by healthcare) and care for the soul (by religious communities). This dualism and reductionism may have led to clinical advances, but has resulted in increased mechanization of care, dehumanization of the patient experience, and isolation in the experi-Competing Interests: None declared.
Narrative Medicine and Contemplative Care
Two important movements leading the way toward a new approach to healthcare are narrative medicine and contemplative care. Despite considerable common ground between these two movements, they have existed largely parallel to each other, with different literatures, different histories, different sub-communities, and different practitioners. This article works toward integration of narrative medicine and contemplative care through a philosophical exploration of key similarities and differences between them. I start with an overview of their similar diagnosis of healthcare's problems and then consider their related, but different, responses to these problems. Finally, I use the example of Margaret Edson's Pulitzer Prize winning drama W;t to highlight how these issues can play out at the end of life.
Narrative Medicine and Contemplative Care at the End of Life
Two important movements leading the way toward a new approach to healthcare are narrative medicine and contemplative care. Despite considerable common ground between these two movements, they have existed largely parallel to each other, with different literatures, different histories, different sub-communities, and different practitioners. This article works toward integration of narrative medicine and contempla-tive care through a philosophical exploration of key similarities and differences between them. I start with an overview of their similar diagnosis of healthcare's problems and then consider their related, but different, responses to these problems. Finally, I use the example of Margaret Edson's Pulitzer Prize winning drama W;t to highlight how these issues can play out at the end of life. Keywords Narrative medicine Á Contemplative care Á Healthcare reform Á Empathy Á Phenomenology Á Spirituality Á End of life Á Margaret Edson Á W;t Despite ongoing problems in healthcare financing and access, this is a time of growth and regeneration in healthcare. Practitioners and scholars are going beyond the obvious healthcare crisis problems to ask deeper questions: what kind of healthcare do we want, what kinds of clinicians do we most value, and what kinds of clinical encounters do we need in the face of suffering, disability, and death? These deeper questions take us to the heart of health and healing and to core issues of human empathy and wisdom in the face of morbidity and mortality. Healthcare reform devoted to these deeper questions aims at nothing less than combining the sophistication of scientific medicine with an equal sophistication in compassionate care.
'Spirituality' in Health Studies: Competing Spiritualities and the Elevated Status of Mindfulness
Religion and Health , 2019
The article investigates discourses of 'spirituality' in the field of Health Studies, among scholarly voices and the voices of the practitioners and patients these studies reflect. It examines current trends in contemporary spirituality as well as links with debates involving science, religion and secularisation. The article argues that, in the public domain, 'spirituality' is beginning to denote a collective practice rather than an individual search for meaning. Furthermore, the article identifies some common understandings of spirituality in the context of Health Studies and health environments , such as it being a tool that can facilitate closeness and emotional exchanges. Finally, it proposes that the success and, as I will show, elevated status of 'mindful-ness' in this field points to 'competing spiritualities', despite shared understandings.
Relationships between Medicine and Spirituality
Giornale Italiano di Nefrologia, 2019
This review aims at analysing the links between medicine and spirituality, two seemingly distant concepts. Medicine at its beginnings was imbued with rituals that invoked the intervention of supernatural powers, as man were unable to treat diseases and struggled to bear the suffering caused by them and the fragility of their own bodies. Today, in the post-genomic era, medicine has gained great benefits from new and extraordinary scientific and technological achievements, permitting sophisticated therapeutic and diagnostic approaches, which assure cures not previously possible. Even considering these great accomplishments in medicine and technology, it should be borne in mind that diseases not only induce bodily changes in sufferers, but also affect their emotional state and social interactions. Illness, especially when serious and in presence of a poor prognosis, raises profound questions around the meaning of life, affections, suffering and death. In the last few decades scientists...
2018
The presented study evaluates the effect of Buddhist spirituality with respect to resilience and coping mechanisms, addressing the application of mindfulness as a decontextualized adaptation of Buddhist teachings. Through a participant-phenomenological approach, the current study investigates the relationship between two different clinical conditions along with mindfulness-meditation in both clinical and non-clinical contexts. To guide the research process, semi-structured in-depth interviews were conducted with: 10 oncologic patients following the MBSR program in early palliative care; 7 epileptic patients following an MBSR adapted program; 10 mindfulness trainers engaged in the conduction of the program within clinical environments; 15 expert practitioners experiencing pain-elicitation in experimental conditions; 4 Buddhist teachers. The analysis scrutinizes the relationship between mindfulness and the following areas: reception of the hospital proposal, autobiographical-self, tra...
American Anthropologist, 2007
»Multiple Medical Realities-Patients and Healers in Biomedical, Alternative and Traditional Medicine« is a title to a reader comprised of 10 articles selected by Helle Johansen and Imre Lázár with the intent to bring together two major theoretical trends in medical anthropology: one based on its fundamental concept of medical pluralism and the other based on phenomenological studies of body and self. The work of authors of these studies, all prominent European social anthropologists with very diverse research focuses situated worldwide (Mexico, Ghana, India, Norway, etc...) uphold the optics on plurality of provision, use and understanding of medical practices as cultural universal. Multiple views on multiple medical realities, as given by this well rounded book, will be inspiring and invaluable reading for any contemporary interest or research in this field.
Spirituality, Science and the Medical Arts
Subtle Energies Energy Medicine Journal Archives, 2001
After a century of neglect, spirituality is returning to the practice of medicine. Controlled studies in distant healing and intercessory prayer challenge ingrained assumptions of the nature of consciousness and the mind-body relationship. Current evidence suggests that consciousness can both insert information into the environment, and extract information ft-om it. Both these vectors are health-relevant. Although energy-based models of healing may suffice to explain many of the phenomena taking place within the healer and healee, and in the immediate vicinity of each, a genuinely nonlocal, non-energetic framework is necessary to explain how the spatiotemporal gap separating the two is bridged. The implications of nonlocal mind transcend health and illness, and involve the survival of bodily death and immortality.
Religion Medicine and Healing. An Anthology.pdf
2021
Religion, Medicine and Healing is an anthology that brings together a broad spectrum of non-‐Western healing traditions from the different kinds of shamanisms to the world religions demonstrating how each offers valuable alternatives and complements to biomedicine. Many local traditions are in danger of being forgotten, not transmitted, or even discredited by modern, orthodox biomedicine. At best, most local traditions have survived as fragmented pieces of once greater totalities. Everywhere, Western biomedicine has occupied spaces that were once the domains of local traditions and specialists. Based on the unique experience and knowledge of the contributing authors, Religion, Medicine and Healing goes beyond mere descriptive ethnography by engaging important theoretical discussions of ‘performance’, ‘aesthetics’, ‘personhood’, ‘soul’, and ‘life-‐forces’. Released in eBook format, Religion, Medicine and Healing :