Steps along the journey: Documenting undergraduate White women’s transformative processes in a diversity course (original) (raw)
Related papers
Beyond personal transformation: Engaging students as agents for social change
Although Transformative Learning Theory (TLT) has been around for more than 40 years, few studies empirically engage critical theoretical frameworks to move beyond personal learning to identify the impacts of transformation on society. The purpose of this article is to discuss academic literature that expands TLT in the direction of societal transformation rather than merely personal change. The idea, supported by myriad scholars (Brookfield, 1998, 2002, 2012; Cranton & Taylor, 2012; Johnson-Bailey & Alfred, 2006; O’Sullivan, 1999, 2012), is deeply rooted in my desire to understand what transformational learning moves students toward acting as agents of social change (Gambrell, 2017a; 2017b). As a professor of teacher candidates, I teach several foundational classes that encourage students to be educators to work to dismantle structures that uphold White supremacy, (hetero-)patriarchy, cis-normativity, neoliberalism, linguicism, among other educational injustices.
A Call for Transformative Teaching
This paper is a focused literature review that discusses the power and potential for as well as the dimensionality of Transformative Teaching (TT). Through my analysis of critical and radical scholarship around specific types of teaching, I show I need for adopting this type of education due to calls from academic activists and marginalized communities. My discussion highlights A Call for Transformative Teaching where I show why we should incorporate these practices into higher education curricula. I specifically discuss how Transformative Teaching Counter Standardized Education, Hegemony and Hegemonic Forces, and can be used as a Tool for Positive Social Change. Lastly, I discuss the Dimensions of Transformative Teaching where I describe the core theoretical tenets of these teaching practices. Through this, one can see the multidimensionality of these praxes as well as their function for promoting equity and justice for all students. I conclude by arguing the critical importance of incorporating TT in all institutions. I discuss how educators and institutions might develop strategies with Minority Communities understand their needs and recognize their intellectual significance. In doing so, academic and societal power holders will validate these communities’ previously disrecognized intellectual importance and potential.
How White students learn about race and privilege: Curricular and co-curricular experiences
The 6th annual Conference on Higher Education Pedagogy is focused on higher education teaching excellence and the scholarship of teaching and learning. The conference provides a forum for faculty members, researchers, administrators, and graduate students to showcase the latest in instructional practice and educational research; a mechanism to network with like-minded educators regarding higher education instruction; and, an opportunity to expand one's understanding of and motivation for learner-centered instruction.
A Transformational Journey: Exploring our multicultural identities through self-study
This article reports a self-study of multicultural identities in a public high school ethnic studies class and a university multicultural education course in Hawai'i, a unique multicultural setting in which no ethnic group is in the majority. Participants are the two authors and 117 of their high school and university students. Three important findings emerged from constant comparison analysis of students' and authors' personal multicultural narratives, reflections, and coursework. First, a personal-constructivistcollaborative approach to self-study in an intellectually safe classroom environment provides both students and teachers with a context for challenging their socially constructed assumptions about race, culture, and ethnicity and supports the unpacking of previously held stereotypes and biases. Second, the students' narratives are transformational teaching texts. The formal and informal sharing of personal stories helps students and teachers to be more thoughtful about the complexity of identities, develop new understandings of their own and others' multicultural identities, and gain a critical consciousness about the connection between self-understanding and prejudice reduction. Third, self-study is a multicultural pedagogy that promotes social perspective taking, tolerance, and understanding of diversity through personal transformation. The article concludes by encouraging multicultural educators to transform traditional classroom pedagogies so that the journey to understand other people begins with the self.
Journal of Transformative Education, 2019
Critical race courses challenge today's college students to cognitively grapple with issues of justice and the good society. In some instances, these challenges lead to positive, relational growth-fostering attitudes and behaviors. Transformative learning educator Jack Mezirow's approach to facilitating cognitive shifts appears especially promising in its ability to promote such outcomes. In our own work, we apply this frame to guide our teaching, with an aim toward fostering and studying racially privileged (i.e., White) students' cognitive shifts around the meaning of whiteness. The present case study is an in-depth description of one student's whiteness frame of reference elaboration. Several tentative contributions to Mezirow's theory emerge as a result. Namely, whiteness frame of reference elaboration may include (1) periods of cognitive homeostasis in addition to disruption, (2) positive affective experiencing in addition to negative affect, and (3) shifts in cognition that are subjectively encoded within the context of affective experiencing.
Toward Abolishing White Supremacy on Campus, 2023
University towns are often painted as progressive bubbles amid more conservative "townie" backdrops, yet college campuses are rarely impervious to their surroundings and often reflect the complex social dynamics of their communities. In step with increases in hate crimes across the United States (Beirich, 2019) and more globally (Bond, 2018), in the wake of the 2016 U.S. election, hate crimes surged on college campuses (Bauman, 2019). Any already tenuous "town/gown" division may be particularly porous at public, land grant institutions, whose core missions center on serving and being responsive to its state's citizens.
For this project, I am interested in understanding how transformative pedagogies can be beneficial to nontraditional and minority university students. Specifically, I want to show how public university professors use various teaching approaches following transformative frameworks, if they feel these approaches benefit students, and how they developed their pedagogical perspectives. I gathered data through qualitative dialogic methods by interviewing twelve public university professors (N = 12). Analyses illustrate how respondents experienced forms of social injustice, which inspired their transformative consciousness and teaching praxis. Findings also describe various methods respondents employ to provide students with validating transformative educational environments and perceived benefits of these methods. Findings also underscore various institutional constraints educators face when implementing transformative practices. I conclude by providing rationale for the greater institutional inclusion of transformative pedagogies, the expansion of transformative pedagogical research focused on both the student and professor perspectives, and for a dramatic conceptual shift regarding education. This project contributes to the literature by moving beyond theoretical transformative education discussions to examining the lived experiences of those engaged in emancipating forms of teaching and learning. I provide theoretical insights on processes where professors came to develop their transformative pedagogical perspectives and a digital disconnect that may occur with on-line education.