Some new tools for visualising multi-way sensory data (original) (raw)
Related papers
Non-Symmetrical Multivariate Analyses for Sensory Data
2007
The nature of the data arising from sensory analysis can be somehow different and can depend upon the objectives of the researcher. Therefore, there is a strong demand for a variety of methodologies able to cope with different types of data as well as to answer to different questions. In this ...
Measuring validity in sensory analysis
Food Quality and Preference, 1995
detailed information about each individual attribute. Therefore, the two types of techniques must be considered as complementary. Two methods for assessor evaluation are demonstrated, both based on graphical techniques: plots of an assessor's ability to detect diff erences vs. his/her repeatability, and the 'egg-shell plot' which highlights an assessor's agreement with the panel's rankings. The methods presented in this paper are modafications of already established methods in the area. All methods are illustrated by an example from sensory profiling of beef boullion.
Three-way principal component analysis applied to noodles sensory data analysis
Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 2011
The results presented in this paper are issued from the study and the interpretation of a 3-way data matrix constituted from the sensory analysis of wheat noodles. The aim of this work was to provide a complementary understanding of internal relationships between the chemical composition of the noodles and sensory attributes such as color, surface smoothness, elasticity or chewiness. The application of the Tucker3 algorithm involving the noodles composition, the sensory attributes and the assessors as the three modes, facilitates the interpretation of the differences among the types of noodles and also the estimation of the effect of different sources of variability on the sensory evaluation. A joint interpretation of the first and of the second mode (noodles and sensory attributes) allows to link appearance and texture attributes with the composition of the noodles.
Journal of Food Quality, 2002
The first part of this paper demonstrates a simple graphical way to visualize estimated variances, in terms of a plot of the total initial variance ("SIGNAL ") versus residual variance ("NOISE n ) , as a pragmatic altemative to tables of Ftests. The recently developed Procrustes rotation in the bilinear ''jackknifing form is then presented as a method for simplifring the comparison of PLS Regression modelsfrom dfferent data sets. These methods are applied to sensoly data in order to study ifnatve (untrained) sensory panelists can produce reliable descriptions of systemic differences between various test meals. The results confirm that three panels of 15 naive assessors each could give repeatable intersubjective description of the most dominanr sensory variation dimensions.
A hierarchy of models for analysing sensory data
Food Quality and Preference, 1995
We propose a hierarchy of models for averaging sensory profile data. The models follow from formulating the data from each assessor in terms of association matrices and considering different strategies for weighted averaging of these matrices. It turns out that two forms of weighting contained within the hierarchy are very close to Generalised Procrustes Analysis (GPA) and Individual Differences Scaling
Sensory profiling data studied by partial least squares regression
Food Quality and Preference, 2000
The statistical analysis of a descriptive sensory pro®ling data set distributed at the sensometrics meeting is presented. The data set is analysed with focus on the sensory dierences between products (cooked potatoes). The data analytical strategy involves a descriptive statistical analysis to obtain an overview of the distribution and standard deviations of the scores for each sensory attribute. Subsequently, three-way analysis of variance (AVOVA) of the data gives a statistical measure of the reliability of the sensory attributes supplemented by principal component analysis, which visualise the main tendencies of systematic variation. Discriminant and ANOVA partial least squares regressions are used to relate the sensory structure to product design structure and vice versa. Statistical reliability and predictive validity of the product dierences are obtained by ANOVA and cross-validation. Similar data structures are observed in the various multivariate models. Texture, taste and¯avour attributes dierentiated the potato samples, with the texture attributes being most reliable. It is emphasised that an appropriate interpretation of the pro®ling data should also include knowledge of the experimental background.
Food Quality and Preference, 2001
The sensory profile measures an interaction between products and subjects. Faced with this complex information, industry needs an operational tool for describing product sensory properties. Thus, the statistical analysis of profile data should yield a sharp and robust product picture. We set up quality criteria, based on extended cross-validation and re-sampling techniques, to quantify the relevance of factorial method results. We target PCA on mean product scores, and several MANOVA models. We used assessor cross-validation and assessor re-sampling to evaluate respectively the impact of each assessor and the impact of the panel make-up on the product results. PCA and simple MANOVA models are highly robust, whereas complex MANOVA models lead to unstable results.
SensomineR: a package for sensory data analysis
Journal of sensory studies, 2008
We propose a new package for sensory data analysis, named Senso-MineR. SensoMineR is implemented in the R programming environment and can be accessed at the following addresses: http://sensominer.free.fr or http:// cran.r-project.org. This package produces graphical displays of data that are simple to interpret, and it also provides syntheses of results issuing from various analysis of variance models or from various factor analysis methods accompanied with confidence ellipses.
Optimized Descriptive Profile: A rapid methodology for sensory description
2012
The objective of this study was to propose a rapid method for obtaining sensory descriptions of foods utilizing semi-trained judges and the quantitative evaluation of sensory attributes, called the Optimized Descriptive Profile (ODP). It was proposed that reference materials be present during final evaluation of the products. Therefore the judges could compare samples with the reference materials, facilitating the allocation of attribute intensity on the unstructured scale. The description obtained by the ODP was compared with the Conventional Profile (CP). Comparative analyses were made between the graphical representations obtained by the Principal Components Analysis (PCA), t-test and correlation analysis. Correlation between sensory measurements obtained by both methods and the instrumental texture measurements was also evaluated. The proposed methodology provided a sensory profile that was very similar to that of the evaluation trained panel (CP) in relation to the graphical configuration of the samples and the correlation of attributes with the principal components. Results of the sensory description presented significant correlation without significant differences according to the t-test at the probability level of 0.10. Sensory data obtained by the CP and ODP presented significant correlation (p < 0.10) with the instrumental properties of texture. The proposed descriptive analysis thus has the potential to quantitatively report sensory attributes, reducing the time and cost of sensory tests and facilitating the correlation of sensory and instrumental measurements.
Food Research International, 2004
The objective of this work was to explore the differences and similarities between the assessments obtained by means of a trained panel and a group of na€ ıve consumers using Projective Mapping techniques. Ewes milk cheeses sensory description was used as a case study. For this purpose, data was analyzed by means of INDSCAL (individual difference scaling) and panels reproducibility, discrimination and consensus were studied. Trained panel in sensory profiling got better performance quality indexes using Projective Mapping techniques than consumer panel. However, results revealed great individual variability mainly attributable to the absence of specific sensory training. Overall consumer and trained panel sample configurations followed similar trends although several differences were also perceived in the maps. In order to obtain further interesting information and to avoid inaccurate or biased conclusions, the use of specific trained panel in parallel to consumers is highly recommended.